Marshal Eden McCabe is baffled by the hanging of Frank Badger, and the situation only worsens when Frank's brother Jack comes to town and is also hanged, leaving McCabe to figure out a motive for the townspeople's vendetta
Mystery Writers of America Awards "Grand Master" 2008 Shamus Awards Best Novel winner (1999) for Boobytrap Edgar Awards Best Novel nominee (1998) for A Wasteland of Strangers Shamus Awards Best Novel nominee (1997) for Sentinels Shamus Awards "The Eye" (Lifetime achievment award) 1987 Shamus Awards Best Novel winner (1982) for Hoodwink
The basic idea is that a stranger is found hanged in a small town and the Sheriff has to solve the mystery. The book was interesting to me as a writer. It's not highly action driven. In fact, in many ways relatively little happens. The mystery is not that hard to figure out. Yet, I kept turning the pages and was very interested in it. I really enjoyed the characters and their stories, and the writing, which didn't get in the way of the story but had enough poetry in it to keep my attention. Much enjoyed.
Closer to a 3.5, it's a very solid western, a mystery in a western setting. A small town, with just a constable and a part time deputy as law enforcement, has a hanging and no one knows who did it. The dead man was a drifter that no one knew, then when another hanging took place the town started to crack. It's up to the constable to figure it out.
Recommended, it has a solid story and I enjoyed the characters for the most part. The action is lacking, much more a mystery than a typical pulpy western.