What do you think?
Rate this book
Advocacy and Opposition: An Introduction to Argumentation
Advocacy and An Introduction to Argumentation [paperback] Rybacki, Kathryn C.,Rybacki, Donald J. [Jan 01, 1991]
226 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1985
5 people are currently reading
103 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
April 27, 2022
Yes, I am that person who reviews textbooks.
Side note: there is nothing wrong with reviewing textbooks because A. they are still books, B. I gave up heartbeats of my life to read them and C. it definitely helps my reading challenge.
Anyways back to the main topic.
This semester I had taken an argumentation class, and this was our primary textbook.
I have always been fascinated by the topic of argumentation. I think everyone should learn the principles of argumentation as they serve one well in both personal and professional life. So, naturally I was excited to take this class.
While I enjoyed the class, I did have some problems with this textbook.
First, it is not exactly written at the most accessible level. The writing is a bit convoluted and can be hard to follow at times. It was also quite dry. I felt that the authors took concepts that should have been straightforward and easy and definitely complicated them. Second, the examples they used were not the most exciting. They literally used geese shit as the topic for the argument in one of the chapters. Whoever thought it was a good idea to make that a topic clearly needs to have their head examined.
What I did like was that they covered a lot of ground and I feel that most of what they mentioned (geese shit aside, of course) was very much relevant to the field of argumentation. While the writing was not the best, they did get their point across and I do feel that I walked away with a much better understanding of argumentation, which is why this book is getting three stars.
If I were a professor, I would have chosen a better written, more engaging textbook, this book does hold its ground and explains what makes one a successful arguer so I would not consider it a waste of time.
Side note: there is nothing wrong with reviewing textbooks because A. they are still books, B. I gave up heartbeats of my life to read them and C. it definitely helps my reading challenge.
Anyways back to the main topic.
This semester I had taken an argumentation class, and this was our primary textbook.
I have always been fascinated by the topic of argumentation. I think everyone should learn the principles of argumentation as they serve one well in both personal and professional life. So, naturally I was excited to take this class.
While I enjoyed the class, I did have some problems with this textbook.
First, it is not exactly written at the most accessible level. The writing is a bit convoluted and can be hard to follow at times. It was also quite dry. I felt that the authors took concepts that should have been straightforward and easy and definitely complicated them. Second, the examples they used were not the most exciting. They literally used geese shit as the topic for the argument in one of the chapters. Whoever thought it was a good idea to make that a topic clearly needs to have their head examined.
What I did like was that they covered a lot of ground and I feel that most of what they mentioned (geese shit aside, of course) was very much relevant to the field of argumentation. While the writing was not the best, they did get their point across and I do feel that I walked away with a much better understanding of argumentation, which is why this book is getting three stars.
If I were a professor, I would have chosen a better written, more engaging textbook, this book does hold its ground and explains what makes one a successful arguer so I would not consider it a waste of time.
April 21, 2013
This book provided some interesting information, but it was pretty outdated and confusing in some parts. I did appreciate the length of the chapters, though.
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews