Before the advent of these instant reviews as video capsules ( think Anupama Chopra….to the other extreme is KRK with his rants which pass off as a review), viewers used to wait for the review on Friday in Times of India or Indian Express and decide which movie to go and which one to pass. Khalid Mohammad was the resident God of reviews in TOI before he moved to the other side of making movies…slightly less famous but some one who reviewed movies as competently was Shubra Gupta for the Indian Express…her reviews were characterized by balance and were objective and unbiased. Not the one to sit on a high horse and look down on everything mainstream like most critics do….her reviews gave you a reasonable insight into what to expect in the movie and you were rarely disappointed with her reviews and ratings.
So when she picks up 50 movies (one per year) from 1995 to 2015 that changed Bollywood and redefined movie making – I was tempted to read this as it will also serve as a speed-review of the last 20 years which coincided with my peak movie watching. I average some 50-75 Bollywood movies on TV and at least 25 on the big screen even till today every year.
In the 70s and 80s, we were caught in the lost and found formula, 6 songs and 2 item numbers, a climax in a shed with barrels which rolled over, rich boy – poor girl or vice-versa, a rape and its consequences as a pivot for a movie. We endured these movies week after week and before we knew what happened, we all got middle aged. With the opening up of India post 1991, movies also changed. While the stories continued to be the same, the treatment and the narrative style changed. Real stories with real people…which were off the beaten track but not toally abstract and off-beat got main streamed. The large NRI diaspora also became the target audience and a generation of successful directors emerged focusing on heros and heroines whose only pursuit in life was falling in and out of love. Small town India also got main stream – not for the showcasing of poverty and rural oppression but showcasing their dreams and aspirations…While we still have a long way to go, movie watching has become a very enjoyable experience in terms of the sheer diversity. On another note, even the theaters have improved.
Shubra Gupta’s format is very interesting. You first get the original review….written whenever between 1995 to 2015….then there is a post script, written in 2016 why the movie is hatke. The collection of movies is eclectic. From hardcore romances like Kuch Kuch Hota Hai and DDLJ, to the bump and grind action movies of Bhai Khan, to the ones made by Anurag Kashyap and Omung Kumar- any movie that moved the needle slightly – makes it to her list. There are no ‘pretensions’ (in terms of arthouse cinema dominating the list) in her choice of movies. Any movie which was interesting, well presented, got viewers hooked and had some breath of fresh air qualifies. ( you have Govinda’s Hero no: 1 qualifying as a movie that changed our perception of film heroes as comedians and Dhoom 2 for the slick presentation)
For me, reading the book was like doing a quick review and recap of all the interesting movies I watched in the last two decades.
A few interesting movies slipped out and you also wonder why some movies got added….I am not going to quibble about the odd omission or addition….
Breezy read and a balanced choice of movies….the kind of book you should read on a long Bangalore – Delhi flight and complete it before you land.