What do you think?
Rate this book
Les Batailles de l'impôt: Consentement et résistances de 1789 à nos jours
Comment convaincre les citoyens qu’il est utile et légitime de verser à l’État une partie de leur argent ? Cette question s’est posée à tous les régimes de 1789 à nos jours. Des révoltes paysannes du XIXe siècle aux stratégies contemporaines de fraude et d’évasion, les charges fiscales n’ont cessé d’être combattues et contournées au motif de leur poids excessif ou de leurs inégalités. Le consentement à l’impôt n’a en effet rien de naturel : dans les démocraties, il repose sur un lien de confiance qu’il faut perpétuellement reconstruire. Fondé sur une enquête approfondie dans les archives, ce livre retrace les nombreuses batailles, intellectuelles, sociales et politiques, qui ont façonné notre système de redistribution et divisé la société française au cours des deux siècles passés.
464 pages, Paperback
First published March 24, 2011
12 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
Read
May 16, 2025*Les Batailles de l’impôt. Consentement et résistances de 1789 à nos jours* is a rigorous and enlightening historical analysis of the complex relationship between taxation, political legitimacy, and citizen resistance in France from the French Revolution to the present. Authored by historians Nicolas Delalande and Alexis Spire, the book traces the evolution of tax policies and the social struggles they have generated, offering a nuanced perspective on how fiscal systems shape and reflect the dynamics of power, inequality, and democratic engagement.
The central premise is that taxation is not merely a technical or economic matter but a deeply political issue—one that touches on questions of justice, collective responsibility, and the limits of state authority. The authors explore how taxes have been both a tool for building modern states and a focal point for dissent, negotiation, and conflict between governments and the governed.
The book begins with the revolutionary moment of 1789, when the abolition of privileges and the call for a fair tax system were central to the new democratic ideals. From there, it follows key episodes in French history—such as the expansion of direct taxes in the 19th century, the creation of the income tax in 1914, post-war fiscal consolidation, and contemporary debates around tax evasion and fairness.
Each chapter examines how different social classes and political movements have responded to taxation. Wealthy elites often sought to preserve fiscal privileges or exploit legal loopholes, while working- and middle-class citizens oscillated between reluctant acceptance and outright resistance, especially when taxes were perceived as unjust or poorly redistributed.
A major theme is **fiscal consent**—the idea that for taxation to be legitimate, citizens must perceive it as fair and tied to collective benefits. The authors show how public attitudes toward taxes have been shaped by political representation, state services, wartime sacrifices, and shifting ideologies of solidarity and merit. When the perception of fairness erodes, so too does willingness to pay.
The book also delves into various forms of **tax resistance**, from peasant revolts and legal challenges to more recent forms of protest, such as the *gilets jaunes* movement. These episodes are analyzed not as irrational or anti-social behavior, but as expressions of political agency and contested citizenship, revealing how taxation is experienced differently across social and territorial lines.
Another key focus is on the growing gap between fiscal rhetoric and reality, particularly in recent decades. The authors critique neoliberal reforms that promise lower taxes while eroding public services, as well as the rise of tax avoidance by multinational corporations and wealthy individuals. These trends, they argue, have undermined public trust and widened social inequality.
Written in accessible yet scholarly prose, the book combines archival research, statistical data, and sociological insight. It draws connections between past and present, showing how historical struggles over taxation continue to resonate in modern debates about justice, redistribution, and the role of the state.
Ultimately, *Les Batailles de l’impôt* is not just a history of taxes—it is a history of democracy itself. It reveals how the question of who pays, how much, and for what lies at the heart of the social contract, and how the legitimacy of power is always shaped, in part, by how taxation is imposed, contested, and justified.
The central premise is that taxation is not merely a technical or economic matter but a deeply political issue—one that touches on questions of justice, collective responsibility, and the limits of state authority. The authors explore how taxes have been both a tool for building modern states and a focal point for dissent, negotiation, and conflict between governments and the governed.
The book begins with the revolutionary moment of 1789, when the abolition of privileges and the call for a fair tax system were central to the new democratic ideals. From there, it follows key episodes in French history—such as the expansion of direct taxes in the 19th century, the creation of the income tax in 1914, post-war fiscal consolidation, and contemporary debates around tax evasion and fairness.
Each chapter examines how different social classes and political movements have responded to taxation. Wealthy elites often sought to preserve fiscal privileges or exploit legal loopholes, while working- and middle-class citizens oscillated between reluctant acceptance and outright resistance, especially when taxes were perceived as unjust or poorly redistributed.
A major theme is **fiscal consent**—the idea that for taxation to be legitimate, citizens must perceive it as fair and tied to collective benefits. The authors show how public attitudes toward taxes have been shaped by political representation, state services, wartime sacrifices, and shifting ideologies of solidarity and merit. When the perception of fairness erodes, so too does willingness to pay.
The book also delves into various forms of **tax resistance**, from peasant revolts and legal challenges to more recent forms of protest, such as the *gilets jaunes* movement. These episodes are analyzed not as irrational or anti-social behavior, but as expressions of political agency and contested citizenship, revealing how taxation is experienced differently across social and territorial lines.
Another key focus is on the growing gap between fiscal rhetoric and reality, particularly in recent decades. The authors critique neoliberal reforms that promise lower taxes while eroding public services, as well as the rise of tax avoidance by multinational corporations and wealthy individuals. These trends, they argue, have undermined public trust and widened social inequality.
Written in accessible yet scholarly prose, the book combines archival research, statistical data, and sociological insight. It draws connections between past and present, showing how historical struggles over taxation continue to resonate in modern debates about justice, redistribution, and the role of the state.
Ultimately, *Les Batailles de l’impôt* is not just a history of taxes—it is a history of democracy itself. It reveals how the question of who pays, how much, and for what lies at the heart of the social contract, and how the legitimacy of power is always shaped, in part, by how taxation is imposed, contested, and justified.
Displaying 1 of 1 review