PJ undergrads who have this as a textbook will be miserable. Experienced PJs, in graduate study, will find something of value, as the authors state in the Preface, “the book is designed to act as a stimulus for further discussion and reading,” but you’ll have to wade through the academic jargon. If, when you get together with journalism buddies, you toss around terms like indexicality, locative, iconicity, disintermediation, intersectionality, and discuss photographs relative to Hegel conception of beauty, then this is the book for you. Authors Jennifer Good and Paul Lowe begin by dissecting the terms photojournalism, documentary, news, and art. That’s a tip off that the discussions involve a lot of navel gazing. Here’s a taste: “When a higher, abstracted and timeless metaphysical interpretation is foregrounded in place of this historical reality, its political urgency can be reduced and the focus taken away from any imperative to redress the specific injustice.” (p. 52) Make no mistake, Dr. Good & Dr. Lowe have aimed Understanding Photojournalism at other journalism professors under the guise of producing an introductory text. To really benefit from this book requires a much deeper understanding of photojournalism’s entire history plus a good grasp of who’s who in the field today. The laughable glossary at the end underscores that the book is intended as entry-level. The first entry is “35mm.” No student ready to engage “in a critique of iconic imagery as historically reductive and ideologically suspect” should need to look up the meaning of 35mm.
These criticisms are unfortunate because their intent is good and the topics are relevant to photojournalism education. While I can’t say that I enjoyed this book, I did find points to ponder and even fresh aspects to consider such as, for instance, whether work carried out by photojournalists working for humanitarian organizations carries more moral weight than the same work carried out for a news organization. Nevertheless, there are other better resources for every topic covered in this book.