It's not often that I put a reminder in my phone to buy a book as soon as it comes out. But then again, it's not often that you find a book talking to Christians about money - something I've increasingly found myself passionate about. So I was really looking forward to this contribution from Graham Beynon, precisely because there is so much to be said on this subject, and so little written about it.
Perhaps at least partly because of this undue expectation I placed on the book, I was really disappointed with Beynon's offering. Here was an opportunity to inspire Christians to give generously. And here was an opportunity missed.
Undoubtedly, there is little in here that I disagree with. Beynon focuses on her heart, recongising that our approach to money ultimately stems from here. He identifies our attitude as more important than out actions (but doesn't go as far as to clarity that our actions are a pretty good indicator of our true attitude). As would be expected from a GoodBook Company publication, there is plenty of Bible verses and exposition of. But it is the narrow scope of the book that really annoyed me.
- The focus is on the impact that money has on the individual reader, with barely any mention of the local or global community (outside of giving to missions). This is rather indicative of us boiling down the Bible's teaching to become, 'What does it mean for me?' rather than 'What does it mean for us?'
- There is some mention of spending, but only in light of money handling, and nothing on the imapct of our spending. This is typical of the book's focus on the individual, without any thought towards the wider societal and global impact of how we spend our money (e.g. do the clothes we buy enslave or empower those who made them?)
- There is no attempt to learn from the approaches towards money from Christians in other cultures - a bit short-sighted (arrogant even). One wonders what a third-world Christian would make of this book, and therefore how much of what is in here is Kingdom culture rather than British culture.
I found the author at times apologetic for his own money habits, dispassionate about the topic and - save for re-telling stories of others - uninspiring. But I understood this when it became clear that he had been approached by the publisher to write this book, rather than vice versa. Why a publisher would ask a church minister evidently more passionate about subjects other than money to write a book on it is beyond me.
The Christian book market is still missing a 21st Century book on money and generosity that is written from a place of conviction and passion to challenge and inspire us. And given that - as Beynon notes - Jesus said more about money than he did about salvation or sex, it seems that this area of the Christian bookshop's bookshelf, is one that needs a little attention.