I must preface my comments with the caveat that I am an old retired guy, who never served in the armed services and have never read anything devoted to leadership before this book. This is the story of personal evolution of Native American who grew up in rural New Mexico under largely subsistence conditions and enlisted in the army two days after finishing high school. Being his first plane flight, first time away from mom, first time out of the NM/Mexico environs, it is difficult to imagine an 18 year old this fully committed to doing the right thing. The degree of self-correcting introspection in this story is outstanding and easily its strongest point. The author tracks his 21 year professional journey from green private to Sargent Major, the highest non-commissioned rank in the army's elite forces. The author continually illustrates his educational progress with the errors that lead to each step forward in his thinking process. There are several descriptions of actual training and war zone missions that are particularly illuminating to the uninitiated like myself. These are professional soldiers and the degree of planning, attention to detail and post mission analysis is incredible. The author illustrates very well the concept that leadership involves leading and attending to (caring for) both those above and below you in the chain of command. He is always pointing out his own mistakes and the practicalities of what made one of his superiors better than another. Especially important was how each leader dealt with failures. The teams were always trying to improve their approach to the next mission. In this regard, the effectiveness of the After Action Review (AAR) really stood out as a process applicable to any organization. After each mission the team carefully reviewed the events and each member was permitted complete freedom to identify problems, own errors and suggest solutions without recriminations.
For me, it's a bit late in the game to benefit from this excellent guide but I would recommend it highly to anyone starting out or wanting to hone their skills. I would also strongly recommend this as required reading for anyone working in teams responsible for the health and well being of others. The text itself is a bit dense at times slowing down the read. The author is clearly trying to teach the reader and some of the slowness arises from natural and necessary pedagogical redundancies. This is not a shoot-em up, but a real life story of an evolving leader with great observational and analytical skills.