Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Những người đàn ông không có đàn bà” as Want to Read:
Những người đàn ông không có đàn bà
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Những người đàn ông không có đàn bà

3.77  ·  Rating details ·  33,394 ratings  ·  3,639 reviews
Bình tĩnh đến kỳ lạ.

Dù trong sách này có người biếng ăn, bị không khí rút đi từng calo và cơ thịt hằng ngày cho đến khi chết một cách xương xẩu; dù có người đi công tác về sớm xô cửa và nhìn thẳng ngay vào mặt vợ mình đang trên một người đàn ông, dù có người đã dành suốt những ngày hè đi học chỉ để đột nhập vào nhà người ta và hít ngửi nách áo của họ...thì bầu không khí ch
Paperback, 270 pages
Published September 11th 2015 by Nhã Nam & NXB Hội Nhà Văn (first published April 18th 2014)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Những người đàn ông không có đàn bà, please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Kate The lines that appear in the book are not part of the actual Yesterday song by The Beatles. The Japanese phonetic translation of:
Yesterday / Is two…more
The lines that appear in the book are not part of the actual Yesterday song by The Beatles. The Japanese phonetic translation of:
Yesterday / Is two days before tomorrow / the day after two days ago
is: Kinō ashita no nichi maedesu nichi go no yokujitsu.
Lynn I don't think it's an actual legit job. That story was about illicit underworld activities, and I got the feeling Schehehazade was hired as a "support…moreI don't think it's an actual legit job. That story was about illicit underworld activities, and I got the feeling Schehehazade was hired as a "support liaison" by the criminal group who was providing the guy a safe house to lie low until the "heat" dissipates. The source of the heat isn't explicitly stated that I can recall, but I think the reader can presume they're trying to evade law enforcement or else another gang. I don't know that it's wise to draw assumptions about the whole culture based on a short story about criminals.(less)
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
3.77  · 
Rating details
 ·  33,394 ratings  ·  3,639 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Oct 31, 2016 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: short-stories
I saw Murakami yesterday. I don't mean that in a metaphorical way: I literally saw him in my home town of Odense, Denmark. He received the Hans Christian Andersen Literary Award and made a few small appearances while he was here, one of which was at our local library. There were only 180 of us there, and I don't think anyone left the room afterwards thinking that the event had been so-so. I, at least, felt dazed and enriched and happy afterwards. We heard him read aloud from a short story (in Ja ...more
Sean Barrs the Bookdragon
Men Without Women is a collection of stories about despairing men and loneliness; it depicts men who try to cope with the sorrows of life after their loved one has departed from them. Unable to move on, the men spend the rest of their days lamenting what they will never again feel.

So this is a sad collection, one that captures the harsh realities of human experience, at least, the experience some people will ultimately feel in the face of rejection. The feelings the men have here are not needy
Elyse Walters
Jul 28, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
I LOVED THESE STORIES!!!! They penetrated through my ears and my thoughts. I was hanging on to every word walking around town completely captivated.

The only thing I didn't like -- only for a couple of minutes-is when switching to a new story... I wasn't ready to transition. Yet, they were 'all' fascinating & amazing!!!

Quick question? Do you think women drive different than men? And...
MEN: do you feel less at ease in the passenger seat with a woman driving - than when a man is?
Andrew Smith
May 24, 2017 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: short-stories
When you delve into a Murakami book you’re never quite sure what you’ll find – will it be surreal and mind bending, like The Wind-up Bird Chronicle, or darkly realistic like Norwegian Wood? Well this collection of short stories certainly has more in common with the latter, though not entirely so.

The title gives away the linking theme, but that’s too simplistic. There’s longing and loneliness here but also a desire to understand, to discover. The tones are often deeply melancholic and are told
“HE WOKE TO discover that he had undergone a metamorphosis and become Gregor Samsa.”

Yes, that's right... Kafka in reverse!

This must be the best opening line that I have seen in a short story for a long while. It is not the first one in this collection, but it certainly grabbed my attention. This collection reminded me why Haruki Murakami is one of my favourite authors.

Here are some tasters:

Drive my Car
””… Performing allowed me to be someone other than myself. And I could revert back when the
Jul 21, 2017 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2017
"That's what it is like to lose a woman. And at a certain time, losing one woman means losing all women. That's how we become Men Without Women."
-- Haruki Murakami, Men Without Women


This is a soft Murakami. A lot of his novels are dreamlike, but this one seems more like an emotional smell than a memory. There just isn't a lot to grab onto. It reminded me of petting a sea anemone flower at a local aquarium. I knew I was doing it. I was even thrilled a bit as I was doing it. It just didn't registe
Sep 22, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Ja prosto obožavam ovog čoveka!
Savršeno, na njegov svojstven način upakovano.
Svaku sam priču doživela kao jedan mali roman.

❤ Imam osećaj da su njeno i moje srce nečim čvrsto povezani. Kad se njeno srce pomeri, ono sa sobom povuče i moje. Kao dva čamca vezano konopcem. Čak i da želim da presečem tu vezu, sečivo kojim bi se ona dala preseći nigde ne postoji. ❤

Aug 10, 2018 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Seven stories. All about pitifully isolated men, struggling with the loss of women in their lives, coming to terms, although at a snail's pace, with death and heartbreak - some even failing miserably at that. It seems to me, Murakami has been writing about them forever.

Merging all the characters that Murakami, over the years, breathed life into, we invariably discover a man, always the same man, the ultimate loner. Murakami has given him new names and effaced older ones. But there's no question
Jun 09, 2017 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Υπάρχουν δύο τρόποι να κοιτάξει κανείς τον Μουρακάμι: μέσα από το βλέμμα της δημόσιας, άμυαλης γνώμης, που σχηματίζεται αυθαίρετα, και θέλει τον Μουρακάμι εσαεί ηττημένο υποψήφιο νομπελίστα. Και υπάρχει και η άλλη, του αναγνώστη που θα δει τον Μουρακάμι μέσα από τα μάτια αυτών που αγαπάνε την γραφή του.

Αυτή η συγκρατημένη γραφή του, κάτι το μελαγχολικά ψυχρό πολλές φορές στον τρόπο που οι ήρωές του κινούνται και μιλάνε, ακόμα με κάνει να εκπλήσσομαι με την αναγνώριση που έχει παγκοσμίως. Αν και
Loved it! I always love Murakami, even his less than perfect works but this is an excellent addition to his oeuvre. I generally prefer his novels to his short fiction but these stories are wonderful.

The stories all center around the loneliness of the male protagonists. There are missed connections and losses and a general inability to connect or stay connected to anyone, especially women. But these men seem generally isolated and lonely. Even their male friendships tend to center around lost or
Jun 17, 2017 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Dreams are the kind of things you can—when you need to—borrow and lend out.

You know how, for many people, reading books is like travelling without leaving the comfort of their living rooms? For me, reading Murakami is like returning home after a long and exhaustive trip. His prose, his style, all the little well known things that make up his stories, feel like a cozy, dim-lit room with dark corners and telephones that ring menacingly, like an unfortold dark turn of events, in the middle of the
Mutasim Billah
Jan 31, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: japan, short-stories
"But when I look back at myself at age twenty what I remember most is being alone and lonely."

Ahh Murakami and his endless alienated, lonely male characters! Men Without Women is a collection of short stories by Haruki Murakami that came out in 2017 (not to be confused with Hemingway's short-story collection of the same name). Here, we have seven stories with male characters, each with varying degrees of despair, dread or loneliness from the lack or loss of women. There are themes of grief, betr
Oct 31, 2015 rated it really liked it
Mua cuốn này đúng vào mùa Nobel công bố các hạng mục. Năm nay bác già lại trượt cái giải văn chương, không bất ngờ gì mấy. Bác là một thiên tài kể chuyện, không thể phủ nhận gì về điều ấy nhưng chỉ thế thôi là chưa đủ. Bác vẫn "thiếu", vẫn chưa thể đạt tới tầm của giải Nobel (mặc dù thiết nghĩ bác đã đạt tới tầm của một số người từng đoạt giải Nobel).
Trước ngày công bố, Svetlana Alexievich dẫn đầu trong danh sách của các nhà cái, cuối cùng bà ấy ăn giải thật. Thực sự thì chưa từng nghe tên bà ấy
Sam Quixote
Haruki Murakami’s latest short story collection is also my least favourite of his so far. Out of the seven fairly longish stories, only one of them was half-decent while the others ranged from bleh to agonisingly dull.

Kino is the ok story where a recently heartbroken man opens up a bar and plays host to a strange man who comes in every week, reads a book and drinks his booze. Its focus meanders quite a bit from Kino to the stranger to some random woman and then back to the stranger, though it’s
Feb 24, 2019 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: read-2019, modern-lit
I read a lot of Murakami when I was younger but I have not read a new one since deciding that I couldn't face 1Q84. So this is the first I have read in the four years since joining GoodReads, and although I found these stories enjoyable to read, I don't think they are his best work and they won't change anyone's mind about him. I recall one GoodReads friend saying that Murakami is incapable of describing female characters without mentioning their breasts, and yes, there are plenty of those gratu ...more
Jan 03, 2015 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2015, lit-jap
Hay autores que cuando te enteras que van a sacar un libro nuevo lo celebras por todo lo alto. Esperas, cuentas los días, y corres el mismo día de su publicación para por fin tenerlo en tus manos. Lo observas, le das la vuelta, lo abres por la mitad y lo saboreas un poco más antes de ponerte manos a la obra con su contenido. Hombres sin mujeres es el último libro publicado de Haruki Murakami en nuestro país. En esta ocasión, Tusquets nos traen una colección de siete relatos, relatos, que conserv ...more
Aya Hamza
I don't read lots of short story collections because most of them feel too rushed, but in this one every single story is well written and complete.
I read many short stories by Murakami and really enjoyed it, but never read a complete collection by him. Now, I want to dive into the rest of his collections!
The stories are beautifully written. Murakami has such a way with words. He never disappoint me!
The stories themselves are amazing. There is no plot to them, but as usual Murakami writes chara
Betsy Robinson
I am a Murakami fan (I’ve loved his novels), so I was surprised that I didn’t love this collection of short stories. I know they are said to be “new work,” but some of them seemed immature, and I wondered if they were earlier pieces that had been pulled out of a bottom drawer. Here are briefs written right after I finished each story—a very uneven mix:

“Drive My Car” is really a story about how we are all actors, briefly playing roles, then resuming something else which is different each time we
Ocell de foc
Nunca sé cómo valorar los libros de Murakami. Si hay una cosa que tengo clara, y que puedo admitir, es que no soy capaz de apreciar el arte de muchas de sus obras. Probablemente sea porque es un escritor de otra generación mucho más adulta que la mía y me cuesta sentirme identificado con los personajes de sus historias (a excepción de Tokio Blues, de momento).

Lo que sí puedo apreciar, sin duda, es un gran arte en su forma de escribir, con líneas muy claras, con un simbolismo refinado, y que siem
Leo Robertson
Quick! Name a famous Murakami! Haruki will be the first, sure, but please don't forget about Ryu, Takashi, and I'm sure there are others. LIKE, it's not even like Ryu and Takashi are like, a famous 90s Honda CEO and the inventor of sashimi respectively; they're both ALSO famous ALIVE artists with the surname MURAKAMI! There may be many other talented artistic geniuses named Murakami, but my copy of this book brazenly disavows their cultural existence with its shiny fucking font declaring MURAKAM ...more
Oct 11, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2018, japan

I guess you never run out of books to read. I've read good chunk of Japanese books. Ryu, Higashino, Kirino, Dazai, Nakamura, Minato, Mishima, but never got into Haruki Murakami. Just a hunch that he wouldn't be my thing.
Out of a whim I picked this short story collection to atleast know what all the fuss is about and I think I'm about to read his whole bibliography now. For one thing, i see Japanese being real crazy about Beatles in every single book.
As the title says, this collection has bunc
Paul Secor
Men Without Women is the second collection of Murakami's short stories that I've read. The first, The Elephant Vanishes, was the reading equivalent of receiving a mixtape of wonderful music which I'd never heard before. Reading each of them was like being caught up in a delightful whirlwind that took me to somewhere I had never been before.
Men Without Women was an altogether different experience. The stories, even though they might have had disturbing subject matter in some cases, left me feelin
Oct 07, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: i-love-love-love
This was my first delve into Murukami's works, and I thoroughly the experience. This is a wonderful collection of short stories, all based on men suffering from varying degrees of loneliness, despair and grief, because of the loss of a woman, or a lack of them in their lives. Murukami is certainly a master wordsmith, and his characters are dynamic and interesting, and the amount of depth he goes into with the actual character development, is truly astounding. A couple of the stories, I just coul ...more
Mar 11, 2018 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: stories
A somewhat disappointing book of short stories by Murakami. I suppose that this will be the last of his books that I shall read. After a great start, Murakami seems to have become a bad emulator of Murakami. Those quirky little things like the disappearing cat that once entertained me now stroke me as non sequetors that merely frustrate me. Seven stories that neither left an impression nor entertained. They shall quickly fade.
Aug 02, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
I always love Murakami's work. I sometimes do not understand it fully but his flow of words, his use of metaphor, and his writing is mesmerizing. Putting together seven short stories in this book, underlines this most talented author. Each one of them is a story of a man alone, without a woman to be their guide through life. Told in his usual mysterious style and with always a nod to humor, Marakami presents the reader with lots to think about as he takes us on this journey that his male charact ...more
Franco  Santos
Para los hombres sin mujeres, el mundo es una mezcolanza vasta e intensa, es la otra cara de la Luna en su totalidad.
Qué buenos relatos. Los mejores, a mi gusto, son Yesterday, Un órgano independiente y Hombres sin mujeres. Me parecieron sublimes. Son cuentos que no olvidaré fácilmente.
Matthew Quann
It’s that special time of year where I return to the works of Haruki Murakami to see how I feel about the guy. For those of you who have been following my slow reading of Murakami, I loved the first novel I read by him, 1Q84, was ho-hum about The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle , considered abandoning Murakami after really disliking Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage , and had my faith restored when I listened to What I Talk About When I Talk About Running .

So, having felt the ebb a
Well, he's no Tove Jansson. (Sorry, an inside joke).

There's a lot of homage going on here, at least by the titles of the stories. Two recall The Beatles: Drive My Car and Yesterday. Readers of Murakami will know this is not the first time he has gone down that well. In fact, the couplet I once had a girl/or should I say, she once had me could serve as the starting point for about everything Murakami writes.

But there's also a tip of the cap to Middle Eastern Literature (Scheherazade), Hemingway
Jul 09, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Murakami lo hace una y otra vez. Quizás mucha gente se haya cansado de leer sobre soledades, personalidades perdidas, bares llenos de whisky y los mismos elementos de siempre.
Sin embargo, yo le admiro poder construir tanto con poco. Los mismos elementos, las mismas ciudades y las mismas caras invisibles llenan estos relatos que se juntaron en un libro más de Murakami, otro acercamiento al tratamiento de la soledad, de la cotidianeidad japonesa y de cómo es no tener a quién amar, estar confundid
Paul Fulcher
Aug 21, 2017 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2017
Suddenly one day you become Men Without Women.

That day comes to you completely out of the blue, without the faintest of warnings or hints beforehand. No premonitions or foreboding, no knocks or clearing of throats. Turn a corner and you know you're there already there. But by then there's no going back. Once you round that bend, that is the only world you can possibly inhabit. In that world you are called 'Men Without Women.' Always a relentlessly frigid plural.

Only Men Without Women can compreh
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »

Readers also enjoyed

  • The Eighth Day
  • The Gun
  • Parade
  • Deep River
  • Hardboiled & Hard Luck
  • Blue Bamboo: Japanese Tales of Fantasy
  • Sayonara, Gangsters
  • The Gate
  • Revenge
  • The Saint of Mt. Koya
  • A Quiet Place
  • A Cat, a Man, and Two Women
  • The Penguin Book of Japanese Short Stories
  • 春の庭 [Haru no niwa]
  • May We Shed These Human Bodies
  • The Lonesome Bodybuilder: Stories
  • A Permanent Member of the Family
  • Manazuru
See similar books…
Murakami Haruki (Japanese: 村上 春樹) is a popular contemporary Japanese writer and translator. His work has been described as 'easily accessible, yet profoundly complex'. He can be located on Facebook at:

Since childhood, Murakami has been heavily influenced by Western culture, particularly Western music and literature. He grew up reading a range of works by Am
“So in the end maybe that’s the challenge: to look inside your own heart as perceptively and seriously as you can, and to make peace with what you find there. If we hope to truly see another person, we have to start by looking within ourselves.” Takatsuki” 38 likes
“Music has that power to revive memories, sometimes so intensely that they hurt. But” 26 likes
More quotes…