Amid all the words expended on football (soccer) in Britain, there is perpetration of myths, propagation of fantasies, and wishful thinking galore. But every now and then something comes along to cut through all that to present reasoned and sceptical analysis – this is one such book. Taylor seems to have read every piece of scholarly writing there is about British football, and drawn it into a considered synthesis balancing the material against itself and his own important research (his history of the Football League from 2005 is particularly good) to present a careful state of the play analysis. What's more, he has got beyond the narrow English focus of much writing about football to draw into his analysis Scotland, Wales and Ireland as well. Even more satisfying is that he has also avoided the more common trap of equating football with the professional leagues. He has, instead, drawn clear distinctions between professional, amateur, and recreational football, when taken alongside his sensitivity to gender and 'race' and ethnicity, means that this is likely to become the definitive but sacrificial history of British football for quite some time. Taylor has done us the service of drawing together the strands of historical scholarship about British football, and in doing so given us something to work from and argue against.