What do you think?
Win a free kindle copy of this book!
2 days and 16:59:47
50 copies available
U.S. only
Ordinary Mystics: Psychedelics, Faith, and the Reclaiming of Direct Spiritual Experience
Win a free kindle copy of this book!
2 days and 16:59:47
50 copies available
U.S. only
For thousands of years, humans have met the Divine through sacred mushrooms. Today, ordinary Americans are quietly finding their way back to that practice, in living rooms and churches and clinics, and coming home changed. Researchers at Johns Hopkins, NYU, and a growing number of other institutions have documented these as among the most spiritually significant experiences of participants' lives, ranking them alongside the birth of a child or the death of a parent.
Writing as a scholar who serves a faith community that receives psychedelics as a sacrament, Matt Zemon bridges the clinical lab and the candlelit ceremony. Ordinary Mystics is an invitation to discover an ancient way of meeting the Sacred, and to see what happens when ordinary people encounter it directly.
For readers of How to Change Your Mind and The Immortality Key.
Writing as a scholar who serves a faith community that receives psychedelics as a sacrament, Matt Zemon bridges the clinical lab and the candlelit ceremony. Ordinary Mystics is an invitation to discover an ancient way of meeting the Sacred, and to see what happens when ordinary people encounter it directly.
For readers of How to Change Your Mind and The Immortality Key.
318 pages, Paperback
Published October 1, 2026
About the author
Matt Zemon
12 books6 followersMatt Zemon is Executive Director of the Council on Spiritual Practices, an organization that for over three decades has been dedicated to making experiences of the Sacred more available to more people. He holds a Doctor of Ministry from Pacific School of Religion, specializing in psychedelics in religious practice, and a Master of Science in Psychology and Neuroscience of Mental Health from King's College London.
The author of six books on psychedelics, religion, and healing, most recently Ordinary Mystics: Psychedelics, Faith, and the Reclaiming of Direct Spiritual Experience, he serves an entheogenic faith community and understands direct spiritual experience to be rooted in religious tradition and deserving of legal protection.
Matt is grounded in the conviction that personal healing contributes to collective healing. He writes and speaks as a fellow traveler who does not promote psychedelics as shortcuts or cures.
He speaks regularly at conferences, universities, and religious communities on the intersection of psychedelics, spirituality, science, and law.
The author of six books on psychedelics, religion, and healing, most recently Ordinary Mystics: Psychedelics, Faith, and the Reclaiming of Direct Spiritual Experience, he serves an entheogenic faith community and understands direct spiritual experience to be rooted in religious tradition and deserving of legal protection.
Matt is grounded in the conviction that personal healing contributes to collective healing. He writes and speaks as a fellow traveler who does not promote psychedelics as shortcuts or cures.
He speaks regularly at conferences, universities, and religious communities on the intersection of psychedelics, spirituality, science, and law.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
October 10, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 out of 5 stars
First and foremost, I want to thank the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Ordinary Mystics, and especially Matt Zemon for going above and beyond with his kindness and generosity. After receiving the e-book through NetGalley, Matt personally reached out and offered to send me a physical copy as well. That was such a thoughtful and unexpected gesture, and it genuinely meant a lot to me. Thank you, Matt, for your kindness and for making this reading experience even more special!
This book found its way to me at a time in my life when I am actively on a spiritual path of finding myself, learning, questioning, and trying to understand my own beliefs and connection to the world around me. I am still discovering what spirituality means to me personally, and I find myself increasingly drawn to books that explore the mysteries of human consciousness, ancient traditions, mystical experiences, and the many ways people throughout history have searched for meaning beyond the everyday world we see.
One of my favorite things to read about is other people’s spiritual experiences. I love learning about what people have experienced, how those experiences have shaped their beliefs, and how different cultures and generations have understood the spiritual side of existence.
I was particularly interested in the way Ordinary Mystics explores the intersection of spirituality, psychedelics, faith, and direct spiritual experiences. These are subjects that invite so many questions, and I appreciate having the opportunity to learn about them through different perspectives, personal accounts, and the broader conversations surrounding history and research. I enjoy books that encourage me to look beyond what I already know, consider unfamiliar ideas, and continue searching for a deeper understanding rather than simply accepting that there is nothing more to learn.
What I appreciate most about reading books like this is the reminder that everyone’s spiritual journey is personal.As someone who is still figuring out my own path, I don’t necessarily expect a book to give me every answer. Sometimes, I simply want a book that introduces me to new perspectives, gives me something meaningful to reflect on, and inspires me to keep learning. I want to understand the beliefs of ancient civilizations, explore the experiences of people who have felt a connection to something greater than themselves, and learn how modern science approaches questions that humanity has been asking for centuries.
I also think the title, Ordinary Mystics, is an interesting reminder to consider the possibility that meaningful spiritual experiences are not limited to a particular type of person or a single religious tradition. The relationship between everyday life and our search for something deeper is a subject I could and have spent hours exploring.
Overall, this was a five-star read for me because it touched on so many subjects I genuinely enjoy learning about. I would recommend it to readers interested in spirituality, ancient beliefs, consciousness, psychedelics, mystical experiences, and the relationship between faith and modern research.
Matt, thank you again for writing about a subject that aligns so closely with my interests, and for the personal kindness you showed by offering to send me a physical copy. That gesture made this book even more meaningful to me, and I am grateful to have it on my bookshelf as I continue my own journey of learning and self-discovery.
First and foremost, I want to thank the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Ordinary Mystics, and especially Matt Zemon for going above and beyond with his kindness and generosity. After receiving the e-book through NetGalley, Matt personally reached out and offered to send me a physical copy as well. That was such a thoughtful and unexpected gesture, and it genuinely meant a lot to me. Thank you, Matt, for your kindness and for making this reading experience even more special!
This book found its way to me at a time in my life when I am actively on a spiritual path of finding myself, learning, questioning, and trying to understand my own beliefs and connection to the world around me. I am still discovering what spirituality means to me personally, and I find myself increasingly drawn to books that explore the mysteries of human consciousness, ancient traditions, mystical experiences, and the many ways people throughout history have searched for meaning beyond the everyday world we see.
One of my favorite things to read about is other people’s spiritual experiences. I love learning about what people have experienced, how those experiences have shaped their beliefs, and how different cultures and generations have understood the spiritual side of existence.
I was particularly interested in the way Ordinary Mystics explores the intersection of spirituality, psychedelics, faith, and direct spiritual experiences. These are subjects that invite so many questions, and I appreciate having the opportunity to learn about them through different perspectives, personal accounts, and the broader conversations surrounding history and research. I enjoy books that encourage me to look beyond what I already know, consider unfamiliar ideas, and continue searching for a deeper understanding rather than simply accepting that there is nothing more to learn.
What I appreciate most about reading books like this is the reminder that everyone’s spiritual journey is personal.As someone who is still figuring out my own path, I don’t necessarily expect a book to give me every answer. Sometimes, I simply want a book that introduces me to new perspectives, gives me something meaningful to reflect on, and inspires me to keep learning. I want to understand the beliefs of ancient civilizations, explore the experiences of people who have felt a connection to something greater than themselves, and learn how modern science approaches questions that humanity has been asking for centuries.
I also think the title, Ordinary Mystics, is an interesting reminder to consider the possibility that meaningful spiritual experiences are not limited to a particular type of person or a single religious tradition. The relationship between everyday life and our search for something deeper is a subject I could and have spent hours exploring.
Overall, this was a five-star read for me because it touched on so many subjects I genuinely enjoy learning about. I would recommend it to readers interested in spirituality, ancient beliefs, consciousness, psychedelics, mystical experiences, and the relationship between faith and modern research.
Matt, thank you again for writing about a subject that aligns so closely with my interests, and for the personal kindness you showed by offering to send me a physical copy. That gesture made this book even more meaningful to me, and I am grateful to have it on my bookshelf as I continue my own journey of learning and self-discovery.
October 1, 2026
I should say at the outset that I know Matt Zemon. I met him several years ago through Ligare, a Christian psychedelic community, and later contributed a Quaker perspective to his book Beyond Words. So I came to Ordinary Mystics already familiar with Matt and with some of the questions that have occupied his work.
My own Quaker background is one reason the central idea of this book resonates so clearly with me. The Quaker tradition was born, in part, from the conviction that direct experience of the Divine is not reserved for priests, theologians, or saints. There is something of God accessible to ordinary people, and religious life begins not merely with believing what we have been told, but with attending to what we encounter.
In that sense, Ordinary Mystics asks a surprisingly familiar question in a very contemporary setting.
This is not primarily a book about psychedelics. It is a book about direct spiritual experience: our human longing not simply to believe what others tell us about the Sacred, but to encounter it ourselves—and then to figure out how to live in relationship with what we have encountered.
Zemon moves between his own sometimes startling mystical experiences, the history of entheogenic practice, the modern scientific study of mystical experience, contemporary psychedelic churches, religious freedom, ceremony, risk reduction, community, and integration. The result is neither simply memoir nor psychedelic how-to nor argument for legalization. He is asking a larger question: What might happen if direct spiritual experience once again became an ordinary and legitimate part of religious life?
From a Quaker perspective, I also appreciate the harder question underneath all of this: how do we discern what such experiences mean? An experience may be profound without necessarily being self-interpreting. Psychedelics may open a door, but there remain questions of preparation, safety, ethical leadership, community, discernment, integration, and ultimately how one lives afterward. The mystical experience is not the destination.
That's what I find most compelling about this book: Mysticism need not belong only to saints, monks, clergy, or unusually gifted spiritual seekers. The capacity for profound encounter may be far more ordinary than many of our traditional religious institutions have taught us to expect.
For those of us exploring the intersection of psychedelics and religious life, Ordinary Mystics gives language and structure to a conversation that is rapidly taking shape. But its central question extends well beyond psychedelics:
What would our lives look like if the Sacred were something we experienced rather than merely something we believed in?
My own Quaker background is one reason the central idea of this book resonates so clearly with me. The Quaker tradition was born, in part, from the conviction that direct experience of the Divine is not reserved for priests, theologians, or saints. There is something of God accessible to ordinary people, and religious life begins not merely with believing what we have been told, but with attending to what we encounter.
In that sense, Ordinary Mystics asks a surprisingly familiar question in a very contemporary setting.
This is not primarily a book about psychedelics. It is a book about direct spiritual experience: our human longing not simply to believe what others tell us about the Sacred, but to encounter it ourselves—and then to figure out how to live in relationship with what we have encountered.
Zemon moves between his own sometimes startling mystical experiences, the history of entheogenic practice, the modern scientific study of mystical experience, contemporary psychedelic churches, religious freedom, ceremony, risk reduction, community, and integration. The result is neither simply memoir nor psychedelic how-to nor argument for legalization. He is asking a larger question: What might happen if direct spiritual experience once again became an ordinary and legitimate part of religious life?
From a Quaker perspective, I also appreciate the harder question underneath all of this: how do we discern what such experiences mean? An experience may be profound without necessarily being self-interpreting. Psychedelics may open a door, but there remain questions of preparation, safety, ethical leadership, community, discernment, integration, and ultimately how one lives afterward. The mystical experience is not the destination.
That's what I find most compelling about this book: Mysticism need not belong only to saints, monks, clergy, or unusually gifted spiritual seekers. The capacity for profound encounter may be far more ordinary than many of our traditional religious institutions have taught us to expect.
For those of us exploring the intersection of psychedelics and religious life, Ordinary Mystics gives language and structure to a conversation that is rapidly taking shape. But its central question extends well beyond psychedelics:
What would our lives look like if the Sacred were something we experienced rather than merely something we believed in?
Review of advance copy received from Author
Although Matt quotes Some’, “words are mere representations,” he somehow manages to give words a pulse.
With eloquence, curiosity, and a generous spirit, he weaves together his lived experience, historical research, and current data, inviting us not simply to read, but to wander alongside him.
Matt takes us gently into his own journey, holding our hand as we travel through the questions, discoveries, and mysteries of consciousness. He even recognizes the ever-present temptation of the ego—to walk faster, to get somewhere, to arrive—when perhaps the invitation is simply to be here.
And then, beautifully, he turns toward us as equals and calls us what we are: “archaeologists of consciousness.”
I experienced every sip of this book as nourishment. I giggled. I teared up. I learned. I paused. I felt something stir in me. And through it all, I could feel the authentic passion of Matt’s work and life—the tenderness, curiosity, and courage he so candidly shares through the many layers of his own evolution.
This book did not simply give me something to think about. It gave me something to feel.
Thank you, Matt, for this offering, this invitation, this journey.
And I will never eat a blueberry so frivolously again.
From one spiritual mutt to another—
thank you.
Nan Hudspeth, Somatic Psychotherapist
With eloquence, curiosity, and a generous spirit, he weaves together his lived experience, historical research, and current data, inviting us not simply to read, but to wander alongside him.
Matt takes us gently into his own journey, holding our hand as we travel through the questions, discoveries, and mysteries of consciousness. He even recognizes the ever-present temptation of the ego—to walk faster, to get somewhere, to arrive—when perhaps the invitation is simply to be here.
And then, beautifully, he turns toward us as equals and calls us what we are: “archaeologists of consciousness.”
I experienced every sip of this book as nourishment. I giggled. I teared up. I learned. I paused. I felt something stir in me. And through it all, I could feel the authentic passion of Matt’s work and life—the tenderness, curiosity, and courage he so candidly shares through the many layers of his own evolution.
This book did not simply give me something to think about. It gave me something to feel.
Thank you, Matt, for this offering, this invitation, this journey.
And I will never eat a blueberry so frivolously again.
From one spiritual mutt to another—
thank you.
Nan Hudspeth, Somatic Psychotherapist
October 1, 2026
Ordinary Mystics is a deeply personal and thoughtful exploration of the intersection of psychedelics, spirituality, faith, and direct experience of the sacred. Matt Zemon begins with his own psychedelic experiences but expands the conversation into the larger human history of seeking transcendence through meditation, prayer, ritual, and altered states of consciousness. He also takes seriously the importance of preparation, safety, facilitation, integration, and community, giving the book a depth that goes well beyond just a personal account.
What I really appreciate is how Zemon writes as a fellow traveler rather than someone claiming to have all the answers. He explores what happens when people move from simply believing in the sacred to experiencing it directly, and how those experiences might deepen faith and transform the way we live. Ultimately, Ordinary Mystics is about the enduring human search for meaning, connection, and a direct encounter with something greater than ourselves. Thoughtful, provocative, and beautifully written, this is a book that will stay with you long after you turn the final page.
What I really appreciate is how Zemon writes as a fellow traveler rather than someone claiming to have all the answers. He explores what happens when people move from simply believing in the sacred to experiencing it directly, and how those experiences might deepen faith and transform the way we live. Ultimately, Ordinary Mystics is about the enduring human search for meaning, connection, and a direct encounter with something greater than ourselves. Thoughtful, provocative, and beautifully written, this is a book that will stay with you long after you turn the final page.
October 2, 2026
There is a difference between believing in the Sacred and encountering it.
Matt Zemon brings psychedelics, spirituality, science, ceremony, and religious freedom into the same room and asks a powerful question: What if mystical experience is not reserved for saints, monks, shamans, or prophets? What if it belongs to ordinary people too?
That question hits home for me.
Much of what I explore personally, and through the Presence Project, is this movement from inherited belief into lived experience. From talking about connection to actually feeling it.
What I appreciate most is that Matt does not stop at the breakthrough.
The experience is only the doorway.
Does awe become love? Does insight become courage? Does connection become service? Do we live differently because of what we touched?
That is the real test.
Ordinary Mystics is intelligent, timely, deeply human, and part of a conversation I believe we desperately need.
Highly recommended for anyone who senses spirituality should be more than something we believe.
It should be something we experience.
Matt Zemon brings psychedelics, spirituality, science, ceremony, and religious freedom into the same room and asks a powerful question: What if mystical experience is not reserved for saints, monks, shamans, or prophets? What if it belongs to ordinary people too?
That question hits home for me.
Much of what I explore personally, and through the Presence Project, is this movement from inherited belief into lived experience. From talking about connection to actually feeling it.
What I appreciate most is that Matt does not stop at the breakthrough.
The experience is only the doorway.
Does awe become love? Does insight become courage? Does connection become service? Do we live differently because of what we touched?
That is the real test.
Ordinary Mystics is intelligent, timely, deeply human, and part of a conversation I believe we desperately need.
Highly recommended for anyone who senses spirituality should be more than something we believe.
It should be something we experience.
October 1, 2026
Ordinary Mystics is a strong argument in support of sacred psychedelic practices, informed by Matt Zemon's personal experiences and cross-cultural insights. In his view, when sourced reasonably and consumed in the proper settings, these medicines are safe, deeply beneficial, and serve as a genuine conduit to the Almighty. The book also offers readers valuable advice on risks and circumstances to avoid. I highly recommend Ordinary Mystics to any serious reader curious about the spiritual and societal role of entheogens today.
October 1, 2026
For an ineffable subject the author does an exquisite job painting a replica of what it feels like to sit in these communities. Thank you for this important piece of work.
October 1, 2026
Finally, a manifesto for the revolution of consciousness! Thank you Matt for your incredible passion for and dedication to this mission 🙏🏻🧘♀️🪄💥 💪🏻🧠🚀
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Tracing his own path from grieving son to spiritual seeker, and using that arc to explore why psilocybin mushrooms in particular have become such an unlikely bridge between neuroscience and the sacred. He pulls in research (Harvard Divinity School's Good Friday Experiment, the Johns Hopkins finding that a majority of participants rank their psilocybin experience among the most meaningful of their lives) to make the case that mystical experience isn't reserved for saints and ascetics anymore, it's available, and it's happening to ordinary people at scale. The title does a lot of work here: it's about how those states are showing up in living rooms and therapy offices across the country. A fitting continuation of the questions Zemon has been asking since Psychedelics for Everyone, now turned inward.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I listened to Ordinary Mystics as an audiobook and appreciated the unique perspective it offered. I especially enjoyed how the author incorporated historical, cultural, and scientific context to support many of his ideas. Seeing similar themes and experiences explored across different cultures and throughout history made the book more engaging and gave me a lot to think about.
While I found the concepts interesting, there were times when the book felt repetitive, and not every idea resonated with me. Overall, I think it’s a worthwhile read for those interested in spirituality, consciousness, and exploring mystical experiences from a broader perspective.
While I found the concepts interesting, there were times when the book felt repetitive, and not every idea resonated with me. Overall, I think it’s a worthwhile read for those interested in spirituality, consciousness, and exploring mystical experiences from a broader perspective.
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews