What do you think?
Rate this book
Secrets: Stories of Psychiatry from America and Pakistan
160 pages, Hardcover
Published February 10, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
March 23, 2026
I have increasingly come to value the role of psychiatrists who write,not just academically, but personally and reflectively. There is something deeply reassuring in seeing the inner worlds of those who have walked further along the same path I am only beginning to navigate.
Reading Dr. Hassan Manzar first introduced me to this tradition, and now, having read a third book by Dr. Ali Madeh Hashmi, I find myself even more convinced of its importance. I had previously appreciated The Desert of Possibilities and Love and Revolution on Faiz shb, but Secrets: Stories of Psychiatry from Pakistan and America felt particularly intimate and engaging. What stood out most was the originality of thought,the author does not merely recount experiences but reflects on them with honesty, nuance, and intellectual depth.
As a trainee, I often find myself grappling with moments of disillusionment and uncertainty. There are times when the emotional and intellectual demands of psychiatry feel overwhelming, and one quietly wonders whether these struggles are personal shortcomings or part of a larger, shared journey. In this context, the book felt almost like a quiet conversation with a senior—one who is not prescribing solutions, but thinking aloud, allowing space for ambiguity and vulnerability.
What I found most meaningful was the realization that even experienced psychiatrists have faced similar doubts and difficulties. This recognition is, in itself, therapeutic.
Such writings serve an important function: they humanize the profession and narrow the perceived distance between senior and junior psychiatrists. They create a sense of continuity of belonging to a lineage where uncertainty is not erased with experience, but better understood and integrated.
In that sense, this book was not just enjoyable; it was quietly sustaining
Reading Dr. Hassan Manzar first introduced me to this tradition, and now, having read a third book by Dr. Ali Madeh Hashmi, I find myself even more convinced of its importance. I had previously appreciated The Desert of Possibilities and Love and Revolution on Faiz shb, but Secrets: Stories of Psychiatry from Pakistan and America felt particularly intimate and engaging. What stood out most was the originality of thought,the author does not merely recount experiences but reflects on them with honesty, nuance, and intellectual depth.
As a trainee, I often find myself grappling with moments of disillusionment and uncertainty. There are times when the emotional and intellectual demands of psychiatry feel overwhelming, and one quietly wonders whether these struggles are personal shortcomings or part of a larger, shared journey. In this context, the book felt almost like a quiet conversation with a senior—one who is not prescribing solutions, but thinking aloud, allowing space for ambiguity and vulnerability.
What I found most meaningful was the realization that even experienced psychiatrists have faced similar doubts and difficulties. This recognition is, in itself, therapeutic.
Such writings serve an important function: they humanize the profession and narrow the perceived distance between senior and junior psychiatrists. They create a sense of continuity of belonging to a lineage where uncertainty is not erased with experience, but better understood and integrated.
In that sense, this book was not just enjoyable; it was quietly sustaining
Displaying 1 of 1 review