This was received as an ARC in exchange for an honest review — thank you for the gifted eARC.
Book: Never Just a Fantasy
Genre: Rom-Com
Rating: 4⭐️
4/5 Relationships
4/5 Characters
4/5 Plot
3🌶
*:✿˚⋆ SPOILER FREE REVIEW *:✿˚⋆
I didn’t do much research before picking up this book — I simply read the synopsis and jumped right in. I went in without any strong opinions or expectations, and honestly? I really liked it.
Set in the Caribbean, this story absolutely delivers on that summer-bubble vibe. While there are moments where the narrative dips into more serious territory, it largely remains lighthearted, which I loved. The tone and humor strike a great balance, offering plenty of banter and playful teasing without venturing too deeply into heavy emotional territory. It felt perfectly aligned with the story and genuinely refreshing. The easy back-and-forth jabs between Luke and Mia gave off strong rom-com energy and were such a joy to read.
Mia and Luke are both incredibly relatable in their emotions and inner monologues, making them easy to love. They’re exactly the kind of people I’d want to vacation with — funny, adventurous, and willing to push themselves to try new things, even when it scares them or takes them out of their comfort zone. Through their shared experiences, they gradually peel back the layers of each other’s pasts, hobbies, aspirations, and fears, while also discovering things about themselves that they’ve long ignored or brushed aside due to past struggles. Being with one another creates a safe space for growth, acknowledgment, and healing, which allows their appreciation and feelings for each other to develop naturally.
Throughout the book, you can clearly see their feelings steadily grow. While there is tension, it isn’t the fast-burning, restrained kind. Instead, it’s slow, steady, and openly acknowledged by both of them — tempered by mutual respect and a genuine desire not to push the other for answers. Rather than forcing clarity, they give each other the space to untangle their emotions and truly understand what they’re feeling. This approach makes the eventual payoff feel earned and deeply satisfying. Their chemistry never feels forced or awkward, which I really appreciated.
The main conflict stems from the temporary nature of their vacation and the question of whether what they’re building can become something more. I especially loved that the conflict didn’t rely on miscommunication. Instead, it focused on uncertainty — on not being used to love, on questioning whether they’re allowed to want it, and on wondering if the other person feels the same. Even better, this uncertainty isn’t dragged out unnecessarily. They address it quickly and maturely, as adults should, effectively diffusing the conflict before it becomes exhausting. What remains is the very real and relatable question of whether they can allow themselves this happiness given their circumstances.
The book ends on a sweet, warm note, with a charming epilogue that offers a small glimpse into the future.
Overall, this was a truly cute rom-com that did exactly what it set out to do: leave you smiling and feeling content. It’s the perfect summer read, but it also works wonderfully as a way to escape winter for a little while. Short, sweet, light, and cozy — this book was a delight, and I’ll definitely be keeping an eye out for future rom-coms by A.W. Gunn.