I highly appreciated Nealon's debut novel, Snowflake, that I remember reading in 2022. That's why I was highly anticipating her second novel, and I feel honored to be able to review it before its release in April this year.
Everything That Is Beautiful recounts the story of the Foley family and Niamh, a childhood friend of the Foley children. It's told from three different points of view: Niamh's own, Helen Foley's (the mother), and Kate Foley's (the youngest daughter). The women couldn't be more different from each other, but they share a secret that other members of the family know nothing about. The event that gives some structure to the novel is Maria Foley's wedding, but then we get numerous flashbacks to the past.
It's an incredible story about a family that is far from perfect, but very much appears to be from the outside. We get to know a big cast of characters who are fully themselves, and we slowly get to discover the event that disturbed Niamh's, Helen's, and Kate's lives.
I found myself very invested in this beautifully written novel. I appreciated the way the author created a microcosm of interesting people whose personalities develop throughout the story. I liked how Irish it felt, and how hurling felt important to the plot. I especially warmed up to Kate's character, but then Helen grew on me as well — both of their arcs were beautifully crafted. It was very interesting to read how the father figure (and a sports legend at the same time) was explored with much nuance. My main criticism is that we didn't get enough of Niamh's side of the story; I wish we got to see more detail about how the "event" really affected her emotionally. Also, the time jumps felt a bit confusing at times.
Overall, I truly loved this book and would recommend it to anyone. It's another example of how families can be messy, even (or especially) those who look perfect from the outside. However, I wish this book had been longer, and the plot a little bit more developed.
Thanks to NetGalley and Manilla Press for the ARC of this novel.