Sinners in the Hands of a Good God: Reconciling Divine Judgment and Mercy

by David Clotfelter

Are heaven and hell real? How does God's election correspond to our freedom? Why did Jesus have to die? Why doesn't God save everybody? These are questions most believers and seekers have asked, and they are biblically answered by author David Clotfelter. Contrasting the theologies of Jonathan Edwards with George MacDonald, the author reconciles the difficult doctrines of divine judgement and predestination. Sure to be thought-and discussion-provoking message.

Genres: Theology, Book Club, Christian

298 pages, Paperback

First published October 1, 2004

Reviews

[Dr. Jon Pirtle]

I have read not a few books on the difficult doctrines in Scripture--truths of election, definite atonement, the eternality of hell, etc. and I would rank this book alongside the very best biblical expositions of the Bible's own words revealing the goodness of God in all his ways. A masterful, thoroughly biblical book.

[Justin]

Note: The author is a former pastor of mine.

This is a very worthy read for any Christian struggling with the reality of hell. I know more than a few who inevitably struggle with the Calvinism vs Arminianism debate as they approach this topic. That this book would lead us neck-deep into that territory makes a lot of sense. One of the strongest features of this book is Clotfelter's graciousness and humility toward his theological "opponents". He candidly commends the poetry of George MacDonald even while he disagrees strongly with his theology in other areas. I think he represents differing views with accuracy, respect, and humility. The entirety of the book reverberates with the knowing and familiar voice of a pastor readily available to counsel others as best he can: caringly and honestly without a desire to be domineering. The last few pages are among the most memorable for me for their doxological tone.

[Duane]

This is a good look at the Reformed doctrines of the faith. Though I have generally leaned in that theological direction, I have not done much thinking about it recently. I liked the author's honesty and forthrightness. It may be time for me to go back and re-read Packer again.
God is sovereign, perfectly just, and vastly gracious. How sweet the sound.

[Chris Plemmons]

This seemed more like a personal journey of the discovery of the glories of Calvinist doctrine for the auther, rather than a pointed heavenward explanation and meditation on the goodness and perfect justice of God. Doctrinally solid, yet I was left wanting to hear his actual voice more often than his quotes of older bygone pastors.

[Heather]

I absolutely LOVED this book. It will completely crystalize your views of the calling of God to Christ.