I edited this book for Ms. Silks, and sometimes I found myself laughing out loud. Descriptions are clear and evocative, and I love the characters. They are relatable, and the banter between Emma and Eric is often quite amusing.
As the summary states, this is a fake engagement trope. Emma has had a crush on Eric, friend of her older brothers, for as long as she can remember. Eric has always seen her as a “little sister,” but that’s not the case anymore. Emma's overbearing older brothers, Julian and Tristan, decide she needs to get away from her father, who's in the late stages of cancer. Death is imminent, and they feel Emma is too emotionally involved. First of all, what? Nevertheless, they convince Eric to join their deception to get her out of town. They exaggerate an issue having to do with when Eric and his sister were kidnapped almost 30 years ago, telling Emma that Eric needs help locating the man who kidnapped them. He doesn't. He knows exactly where John Huntz is.
Eric doesn't like lying to Emma, but he needs to have a pretend fiancée to inherit the family farm, and he decides having her to himself will allow him to convince her to play the part. At the same time, Emma is frustrated that her brothers refuse to give her any "real" cases at Silver Securities. If she were engaged, she would become a partner. So, they agree to move forward with the scheme. Of course, Emma has secret plans to make Eric fall in love with her because she's been in love with him since the moment she met him (in elementary school).
One of the requirements of Eric’s grandfather is that they need to announce their engagement at the town harvest celebration. I loved this description of the festival: “The Big Barn glows under the soft shimmer of string lights, casting a golden haze over the wooden beams and hay bales lining the walls. The scent of apple pie and freshly cut straw drifts through the air, wrapping around me in a blanket of home. Sunflowers sit in oversized mason jars, their bright faces turned toward the warm glow. Ribbons in deep autumn colors sway gently with the breeze slipping through the open barn doors, as if the night itself is celebrating with us.”
And the similarities between Emma and Eric cracked me up. When Emma sees Eric walking past her office: “I lurch to my feet, ready to investigate, but my damn rug betrays me. My foot catches, my balance evaporates, and I slam into the wall like a human cartoon. My cheek presses against the glass as I watch him stop outside the conference room.” When Erice receives an early morning phone call: “One second, I’m blissfully dead to the world, and the next, I’m flailing, nearly rolling onto the floor in a mess of tangled blankets and misplaced dignity.”
Emma has some great moments, like when she sees Eric shirtless: “My gaze drops to his bare chest again, and my brain collapses in on itself like a dying star.” And when confronted by her nemesis, the woman who wants Eric for herself, Emma does something that literally had me laughing out loud: “And in one glorious, unfiltered moment, I vomit all over her designer cowboy boots.”
There are some really poignant parts too. Emma, thinking she has finally broken through Eric’s defenses (he’s afraid of betraying the trust of her brothers), is thrilled that he’s finally giving her the kind of attention she desires. But then, he discovers she’s a virgin, and “Before I can respond, he snatches my jeans off the hay bale and starts dressing me like I’m a doll he needs to put away. His hands are careful but quick, zipping me up and fastening my buttons like it’s some kind of damage control.” This was heartbreaking. And yet, Emma doesn’t give up so easily. She’s determined.
I had some problems with the explanations for how things worked in the story (i.e. legal issues, Caroline, Eric's indebtedness to Huntz). Unfortunately, I can’t go into details because I don’t want to ruin the story for anyone. Some of the questions I had were relatively unimportant (because they don’t affect the overall plot, and honestly, sometimes I can be dragged into tangents), but there are some loose ends—which I’m told will be addressed in the next book, featuring Misty and Blake.
Ultimately, I recommend this book. Emma’s fantasizing about Eric for all of these years, which was tangentially relayed in other books in the series, is finally realized. In this book, we learn much more about Emma and about Eric, and I like what I learned. I'm looking forward to reading more about Eric's (and now Emma's) hometown, Lords Valley, PA., and the people who live there.