Wow, I’m out of order in reviewing my Digimon books. XD Kind of fitting, though, since I didn’t really buy the books in order back when they were in stores - this one was the first I bought, together with Zero Two volume 1. Not surprising, because while I loved Adventure, it was a series where things got really good AFTER the first arc, unlike Tamers which was good from the start, and Zero Two which started good before taking a turn for the worse halfway through. This volume here focuses on the conclusion of the Vamdemon arc, and the beginning of the Dark Masters one. I enjoyed both arcs, but the Vamdemon arc slightly more. So what’s to say on the book?
The pros:
-As usual, the art is the main plus the book has going for it. The drawings are incredibly detailed, and adhere so closely to the show’s look that you’d never guess it was originally manhua and not manga - I was surprised to learn that myself. (In case you’re curious about the difference, manhua are Chinese comics, while manga are Japanese. The words sound similar due to being transliterations, and when you compare styles, there are slight visual differences, though manhua are often manga-influenced)
-The Dark Masters’ debut is rather trimmed down from the anime, having all four of them encounter the Chosen at once, rather than the Chosen encounter one after another. The (Japan only) novelization does something similar, having the kids immediately face Metal Seadramon upon returning, and not encountering the other three until afterwards, plus the four are never all together in the same scene. In other words, a more brisk adaptation, but the opponents are no less badass.
The cons:
-Pumpmon and Gotsumon’s episode is almost completely gone. I know this is an awful petty thing to take issue with, but I liked the episode, so it’s disappointing to see it cut.
-The kids’ parents are omitted. Again, I know it’s an adaptation, but I do wish we could have seen the kids’ families in the manga, if only for some character development.
-And as always, corny dialogue like that which plagued the anime, which is why I dislike the dub so much, is present here.
That said, though, I still do like the book on the whole. It does a good job at adapting the series’ second-last arc (and beginning of the final), and the art is always spectacular, even when it reuses model sheets from the anime. A good book for any Digimon fan, but be ready to spend a considerable deal getting it.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5