If you are looking for a book filled with general (and generally applicable) advice on how to be a better leader, you might find yourself a bit disappointed with Front-Line Leader. Sure, some of the advice that Gorder, President and CEO of Scripps Health, gives will work across different business types, for example:
(*) regularly get to know your employees on a personal level
(*) tell personal stories to illustrate your points (instead of just using corporate buzz words and lingo)
(*) ask employees for their advice and opinions and then actually make improvements based on them
(*) hold employees, especially managers, accountable for hitting their numbers and keeping their department's happy
And, yes, I absolutely appreciated Gorder's positive attitude about and respect for his employees. It is clear that he considers his job as CEO at Scripps Health to be a sacred responsibility. He is invested and committed to doing whatever he can to support his people. I definitely respect that.
But there is a lot here that is very specific to running a hospital and providing health care--and, even more frustrating, the reason that so much revolves around the health profession is because SO MUCH of this book is about Gorder. Honestly, it didn't take me fifty pages to realize this was basically one long extended resume. While I did feel like I had a good grasp on his personality after finishing the book, I was also so ready to be done with all the examples of how Gorder improved things at Scripps Health. One of my least favorite chapters, called "The Credibility Factor," was so distasteful to me for this very reason; it was just an overly-detailed description of his experiences during disaster relief efforts (in New Orleans after Katrina and in Haiti after the earthquake). I understand that aiding in these natural disasters helped Scripps establish credibility with the community and government, but I certainly didn't need Gorder's disaster relief play-by-play to understand this point. Eventually it was just overkill (and maybe just a tad self-indulgent?).
With that said, I would add that I really respect Gorder's work ethic. I enjoyed the chapter on holding people accountable, since it is clear that he also holds himself to a high standard. I also appreciated the chapter on building loyalty and engagement from the middle; Gorder is talking about (and to) a whole lot of overlooked but capable people, and it just makes sense for managers and leaders to take advantage of this often untapped resource. (Actually I just read another interesting and informative book, Unlocking Potential: 7 Coaching Skills That Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations, that offered similar advice.)
Overall, I enjoyed this short book. Unfortunately, though, because every one of Gorder's points is supported only by examples from his own life experiences--most of them from his time at Scripps--ultimately, the scope of Front-Line Leader ended up being too narrow, in my opinion. It still might be worth a read, though, especially if you are in the health care industry.