I make no secret of my love for the Shadow, whom I generally describe as 'Batman if he weren't a scared little boy' or, for variety's sake, 'Batman with better tailoring'. But the main story here, Seven Deadly Finns, is a bloody weird take on him. Where his current outings tend to leave him in his original noir era, the eighties DC run set him loose on the modern world, with a flying car replacing the autogyro, the pistols upgraded to Uzis, and a motley new crew of agents supplementing the survivors of his old team. Which would be odd enough even before you get in the creative team of Helfer and Baker. Andy Helfer's best known to me as the editor of the lighthearted classic Justice League International, and while Kyle Baker has done some more overtly serious stuff since, the art here is very reminiscent of the work he was doing around the same time on his comedy books Cowboy Wally and Why I Hate Saturn. So even before you get into the emphatically larger-than-life story, with its outlandish crooks, monkey butler and baffling Rasta subplot, the whole business is teetering on the edge of being played for laughs. And without his air of menace, there are panels where the Shadow is just a guy in a hat and a coat, and it doesn't make sense that he can do the things he does. Yet elsewhere, especially when he's a shadow or a silhouette or a close-up, Baker utterly conveys the elemental power of the man - and either artist or letterer does some of the best 'maniacal Shadow laughter' effects I've ever seen in the comics. Taken as a whole, I honestly don't know whether this worked or not - but it certainly wasn't dull.
(I didn't read the collection itself, but the original singles - and the ads &c are a reminder of what an amazing time the late eighties were for DC. They have ads for the original DC publication of V for Vendetta, 'The Killing Joke', the launch of Morrison's Animal Man. Also, lest we allow the goggles to be too rose-tinted, such utterly forgotten new books as The Weird, New Guardians and Wanderers. Oh, and the announcement that a Watchmen film is coming "soon". Well, geologically speaking...)