I decided not to give this a rating because it was a mixed bag, ranging from 1-star to 5-star stories, and it didn't seem fair to lump them all together.
In general, I'd consider this a 2-star book. The variegated quality of writing, a need for better editing, and a lot of discrepancies in style (en vs. em dashes, curly vs non curly quotes, etc) drag down the average, but I'll give reviews for a few specific stories below.
"Muse" by Amanda Montandon - 1 star
A muse cat consoles an author.
This was the hardest for me to get into, so I'm going to follow Thumper's mother's advice.
"Chosen One" by Spearman Burke - 3.5 star
Crewman finds himself responsible for a cat and takes his responsibility very seriously.
Great concept and colorful setting. I'm hoping to see clearer character definition and stronger revision choices in future writing, but a great intro to these characters and place.
"Voyage of the Porth Ia" by Ted Begley - 2.5 star
How do you solve a rat problem on ship? Mother Goose knows how.
Hilarious idea, the execution just needed work. Stronger pacing and giving the reader a chance to catch on to the joke would have made this a stronger read, but I still thought it was funny.
"An Unexpected Cargo" by AC Young - 3 star
A crew comes to the aid of a distressed ship and investigates them for illegal trafficking.
Strong world building and themes, and an interesting premise. Needed trimming for some info dumping and passive voice, but I was genuinely invested in the racial tensions the author set up, which in some works just feel forced.
"Cat Math" by A. Kristina Casasent - 2.5 star
Crewmember's stowaway cat comes to the rescue.
This story had some really fun one liners, and I am obsessed with the cat being trained to get coffee from a vending machine. Also, always love learning some new profanity. Rated lower because the story felt slow to start ( I wanted more cat! ) and a lot of the world building information felt shoehorned in.
"Midshipman Molly" by David S. Bock - 2 star
A cat must deliver emergency supplies to trapped crewmembers.
I had trouble getting into this one, too. I wasn't bought into the characters before the accident, so I didn't really care if Molly saved them. I did enjoy the sections from the cat's POV, though. Cat POV is always a delight.
"Cats! In! Space!" by Moze Howard - 4 star
The cat captain of a cat crew learns a thing or two... maybe.
The narrating voice for this was hilarious--Garfield meets Sgt. Carter from Gomer Pyle. The plot was a little weak at points, but I had a hard time caring because I was having too much fun.
"Rats on the Ship" by D. J. Swift - 5 star
Ship cat comes to the rescue when something spooky is going on.
SO GOOD. The plot was fascinating and worldbuilding was strong without being over-explained. I definitely hope to see more from this author in the future!
"Red River Boots" by Matt Green - 3 star
Stranded alone on a ship, cat stands its ground against all invaders.
I had trouble getting into the human sections of the story--I felt like there was backstory I was missing. But the cat POV sections were great. (see above--always a delight!)
"Constellations" by M.C.A. Hogarth
Crew makes up new constellations while waiting for rescue.
I couldn't buy into this story and consequently had a lot of time following the plot. I think I got lost, because I never found a cat in this story?