This book suffers from the same malady common to every anthology I've ever read: inconsistency. This is unsurprising considering what the editors of anthologies do: take published essays and chapters of books ripped out of their original context and paste them together in a new context. Writers usually write with one context or audience in mind, so to remove their piece from its original context and audience and present it in a new one is a major limitation in these types of books.
There is a nice variety of readings in this book, and the editors have done well in finding a diversity of views that run the gamut. Their introductions and conclusions before and after each part are excellent. It appears that the editors have done their best - and their best is impressive - but there is too much of a hodge-podge feel to embrace this book. Read it to learn about a range of views in Christian ethics, but don't expect to be swept away by the book.
Eh. Boring topic admittedly, but some of the selections were just too removed from their context to have any real impact. There are a few good essays however, and it's certainly worth cherry-picking through.
Pure theory, philosphy, and in some cases rhetoric. But, it is a GREAT preface to the Volumn II book, which actually has the applications for these theories and methods.