In this colorful tale set in 1457—the year the Scottish Parliament banned golf (in the first recorded reference to the game)—renowned golf architect Bob Cupp brings to life the origins of a pastime that has transfixed us for centuries.
In the Middle Ages, St. Andrews was famous for its cathedral, its university, and for the game developed out in the linkslands by bored shepherds using balls and clubs. One of these, Caeril Patersone, is sufficiently skilled to compete for the title of champion, but in this quest he must contend with not only his competition but also a conniving financier in league with a sordid nobleman, not to mention the ravishing girl they have enlisted to further their interests. The Edict is rich in history about both golf and the community that defined the sport-a delight for anyone ever touched by the magic of the game.
2.5 stars This book is a perfect example of a good idea plus mediocre execution. It is supposed to be historical fiction based on early Medieval golf. Personally, I am not a golfer or fan; however, I love historical fiction in a Medieval setting. The actual story is quite weak and is mixed with narrative that reads like nonfiction. I am not sure if some of the characters were real people, and I don't care enough to research. At least a dozen pages are dedicated to a play-by-play of a Medieval golf tournament. If you are a golf fan, maybe you would enjoy this. I am obviously not the target audience.
Bob Cupp is most well-known as a golf course architect, but here he's written a fun little book set in golf's prehistory. The story behind the title, The Edict, is this: The first written mention of golf is in an edict given by King James II and the Scottish Parliament in 1457 banning golf and football. This was meant to encourage archery practice, and make the Scots more effective militarily. What Cupp has done is imagine what golf was like in the years leading up to this ban, and craft a story around what might have been.
Don't bother if you're not interested in golf, and particularly if you don't know much about golf. The story framing the historical events is weak. If you like golf, you'll probably understand much more than I possibly could, and it's a short enough read to probably be a decent amusement.