I had mixed feelings about this guide to performing more (and more meaningful) mitzvot, aimed at potential converts and less religiously observant Jews. I liked the concept of discussing the underlying issues for each of the selected mitzvot, why we should care about them, how they enable us to respond to issues that arise in our day-to-day lives, followed by steps/options for engaging with those issues through Jewish values, rituals, and traditions. I especially appreciated Artson’s chapter on visiting the sick, with practical advice for making such a visit in a genuinely helpful and meaningful way. His advice in that chapter was insightful, engaging, and reflected the best practices for chaplains.
But there are some aspects of the book that didn’t work for me. First is the physical format of the book: it’s the cumbersome size (and high price) of a coffee table book, whereas if it were printed in trade paperback size it would be less expensive and easier to carry around, more inviting for people who are trying to make a change in their lives. Second, the topics don’t have a logical flow: environmentalism is #2 and preventing animal cruelty is #14. The highly ritualistic grouping of kashrut, Shabbat, and prayer are interrupted by social concepts like freeing captives and avoiding gossip. And the first mitzvah is the polarizingly political “love Israel,” which, because it’s presented without offering any way to love and support the country while still criticizing the actions of its government (as we Americans do for America), it may make the entire book a non-starter for some readers.
I know a lot of rabbis recommend this book, and I can understand why, but while I loved specific chapters, it was more of a mixed bag for me.