Billed as The True Story of Colorado’s Cold-Blooded Black Widow Murderess, Charmed to Death was made into a FOX TV movie a few years ago. I can’t say I’m sorry I missed it.
The book promises 12 pages of shocking photos! (in black and white) that include a shot of the front of a Steamboat Springs hardware store (gasp!) and the DA and ADA on the case (hide the children!). Not that I buy books for the gory pictures, but that’s false advertising, if you ask me. And I don’t blame the author, who probably had nothing to do with the cover text, but sheesh, this story isn’t really about a “Black Widow” — she had nine husbands, yes, but she only killed one of them, well, maybe two. William Clark Coit, an engineer for Tenneco, was murdered under mysterious circumstances eleven years before, in 1972.
Jill Coit is the criminal of the hour and nutty as they come. She told people not long after she married Gerald Boggs that the couple was expecting. She and Gerry built a fabulous nursery and bought piles of baby clothes. Seven months later, Jill was the slimmest pregnant woman anyone had ever seen.
Jill claimed she went home to New Orleans to have the baby — and returned with a tragic story about her daughter being born and then dying. Most people believed her and gave her plenty of sympathy.
Finally Gerry saw the light. He wanted an annulment.
And then word started spreading around town that Boggs was hubby number nine, that between some of those marriages Jill hadn't always been divorced, and that she’d pulled this I’ll-have-your-baby-if-you’ll-marry-me scam before. And then Boggs turned up dead. In his kitchen. Shot. And beaten with a shovel. Jill blamed Gerry’s mysterious gay lover.
Not your typically clean Black Widow technique.
Oh, did I just ruin the story?
No, not really. You’d have to read this book to get all the bizarre details of this case. And trust me, there are plenty of them.