Luv 4 the Cullens discussion

142 views
Why does Bella kiss Jacob

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Alli (new)

Alli (alli28) | 12 comments well he cares but he's a lot better at not showing it


message 2: by Rachel (new)

Rachel (rschor95) I agree... I thought that it was a good idea. it added like 100 pages to the story if you think about it.... But at the time, I thought that it was really stupid. Then she broke her hand and then he got pissed and then everyone was mad at each other. besides Bella at Edward.


message 3: by Imaani (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:21AM) (new)

Imaani (peach_mouse) | 14 comments I think it was good to add the Jacob drama. It was funny when she broke his hand, and it was funnier when Charlie encouraged it! And everything that Jacob says to convince Bella to choose him is true. Edward is too hard to be with, and Jacob is right there. But I LOVED Jacob's ending in Breaking Dawn. It brought all of his issues with Bella together.


message 4: by Rachel (new)

Rachel (rschor95) Well, I think that (no offence (I know I spelled that wrong) to the people who like him) he is an ass hole. but that's just me.


message 5: by Shauna (new)

Shauna Martinez | 1 comments Well jacob would be hard to be with to not jus edward
imaani!plus edward has the attraction for bella and he left her flat on her face before.Then jacob finally had a chance to be with bella he took it!!!
If you really think about it bella could have ended up with jacob if edward hadent come bak


message 6: by Claire (new)

Claire (clairemoelis) why cant she like somone human! seriously! i know shes supposed to be a stupid "danger magnet" but that is complete bull shit.


message 7: by Alli (new)

Alli (alli28) | 12 comments she does talk (complain) a lot about how everyone wants her to be with someone human. well, not not jacob, who's like "i'm human" and she has to remind him that he's not really.


message 8: by Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (last edited Mar 20, 2009 02:32PM) (new)

Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments Godilovebooks wrote: "why cant she like somone human! seriously! i know shes supposed to be a stupid "danger magnet" but that is complete bull shit."

I know! Its retarded! She HAS to fall for edward, in my opinion, she could have fell for Mike!! Well... ok not mike!


message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

bella kisses edward cuz she thinks that he will like go off into battle with respect for edward cuz as edward puts it she is such a bad liar she will believe anyone with a little bit of talent

btw I HATE JACOB!!!!!!


Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments Ya edward left bella for her own good, even if it broke her heart!! Still he loved her, jacob is just really jealous i think!


message 11: by Imaani (new)

Imaani (peach_mouse) | 14 comments I was thinking about it, and maybe Bella did it because she felt bad for Jacob? She knows he is in love with her and he has to watch her be with his enemy.
Also she couldn't be sure he would come back from the battle. I think she just wanted to make sure they left on some kind of positive note.

BTW, hilarious comment on Mike, Breanna.



Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments Imaani wrote: "I was thinking about it, and maybe Bella did it because she felt bad for Jacob? She knows he is in love with her and he has to watch her be with his enemy.
Also she couldn't be sure he would com..."


Thanks:D LOL! But ya, your right! She probably just felt really bad about leaving jacob behind and falling for edward instead. But she needed to choose...


message 13: by Hope (new)

 Hope yeah I mean she might love him but its not the same kind of love. she saw the truth before, she realized that they had a family love but then she kissed him (which was stupid) and he kind of pushed her into changing her mind.Whereas she truly loves Edward.


Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments Hope :) wrote: "yeah I mean she might love him but its not the same kind of love. she saw the truth before, she realized that they had a family love but then she kissed him (which was stupid) and he kind of pushed..."

Ya!! And it really isn't his place to try and force her to love him! Bella needs to really choose who!!! You don't see Edward going and forcing Bella to love HIM!! But you are so right!


message 15: by Imaani (new)

Imaani (peach_mouse) | 14 comments Breanna wrote: "Hope :) wrote: "yeah I mean she might love him but its not the same kind of love. she saw the truth before, she realized that they had a family love but then she kissed him (which was stupid) and h..."

Well, in all fairness, Edward didn't really need to FORCE Bella to love her. I agree that Jacob might have been going too far, but Bella was so blinded by her love for Edward that she never gave Jacob a chance. I think he kissed her just to see if it would spark anything. In Jacob's mind, he was probably thinking that Bella and Eward were going a bit fast.


Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments Imaani wrote: "Breanna wrote: "Hope :) wrote: "yeah I mean she might love him but its not the same kind of love. she saw the truth before, she realized that they had a family love but then she kissed him (which w..."

That is true, its not like Jacob saw a Bella/Edward romance everyday! So ya from Jacob's point of view, they were going fast, so maybe Jacob just wanted to get even with Edward by kissing Bella!


message 17: by Hope (new)

 Hope maybe... but I still think it was rude to trick her...


Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments Sokay, but ya hope, it was really kinda rude to trick her like that!


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

Shauna wrote: "Well jacob would be hard to be with to not jus edward
imaani!plus edward has the attraction for bella and he left her flat on her face before.Then jacob finally had a chance to be with bella he to..."



Me like ur pic




message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

I liked it when bella broke her hand hitting jacob Ha Ha sucks for her!


message 21: by Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (last edited Apr 25, 2009 08:26AM) (new)

Rainrocks^o^(aka Breanna) (RainRocks) | 13 comments I wanna be a mongoose wrote: "I liked it when bella broke her hand hitting jacob Ha Ha sucks for her!"

Ya! That was hilarious!! does suck though! Oh, btw, i love my pic too! Thanks


back to top