Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Ultimate showdown Harry Potter vs Percy Jackson vs Twilight vs Hunger Games vs Artemis Fowl vs Alex Rider vs His Dark Materials vs Narnia vs Lord of the Rings
message 51:
by
Ruby
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 19, 2011 01:33PM
Harry Potter. Hunger Games. That's all, folks.
reply
|
flag
Valerie wrote: "Percy Jackson cause he's funnier, awesomer and Greek. I like Greek mythology and action and Annabeth."
I love how u added annabeth! I love her too. In fact I like her more than Percy!
I love how u added annabeth! I love her too. In fact I like her more than Percy!
Lord of the Rings set the stage for all these books. J.R.R. Tolkien is the father of fantasy.Lord of the Rings is my favorite though. And Harry Potter is second.
I haven't read the rest so I don't know if I'd like them.
They're all amazing, but my favorite of all is... Harry Potter. :P
Well, I didn't read some of the other books, but I think I'm going to have to go with Harry Potter, Oo
Valerie wrote: "Percy Jackson cause he's funnier, awesomer and Greek. I like Greek mythology and action and Annabeth."Definetly!!!!!!!!!
All I can say is the artemis fowl is my favorite series. The hunger games, Alex rider, and Percy Jackson are good series too.
Luke wrote: "All I can say is the artemis fowl is my favorite series. The hunger games, Alex rider, and Percy Jackson are good series too."What about Harry Potter?? You have to like that...
Out of all those books you've listed I've read the entire Harry Potter series and two Artemis Fowl books. Sincerely, between the two I've read...I really can't pick. Anyways, I can't make a final decision because I haven't read the entire Artemis Fowl series. So that question is one that can't be answered.
That's hard. Harry Potter, His Dark Material and The Hunger Games are my favorite series of all time. I can't really choose between them..
It's real hard to compare these books....like someone said above, it's like comparing apples to oranges. I mean, how can you compare Lord of the Rings(written for older readers) to Artemis Fowl(middle school level)?? I haven't read LOTR yet, but it's definitely on my list.Anyways, if I had to rate my top 2:
Harry Potter -It's was quite an adventure reading this series and watching the movies
Hunger Games -awsomeee!
I haven't read Alex Rider, I don't plan on reading His Dark Material, Narnia was quite good along with the Twilight series.
Why do you make this so HARD!not fair. but here we go.
1.Harry Potter
2.Artemis Fowl
3. Alex Rider
4. Percy Jackson
5.Narnia
6.Twilight
7. Lord of the Rings
I haven't read Hunger Games or His Dark Materials
Potter/Rings. I didn't like any of the other books.
UDITI! YOU HAVENT READ THE HUNGER GAMES! do it. you'll love 'em.
LORD OF THE RINGS!!!!!!!!!! As much as I liked harry potter Lord of the Ringds is more of my style and just saying I really Dislike Hunger Games.
Potter/Hunger Games/His Dark Materials/Narnia (In order of my love)
Harry Potter, Artemis Fowl, Percy Jackson, Hunger Games, Alex Rider (I can't choose among these five. I personally love them all.)His Dark Materials, Narnia, LOTR (I love them, but not as much as those five above.)
see I think LOTR and Narnia are original because two friends (J.R.R. and C.S. Lewis) wrote two of the iconic novels during their lifetime and those were not copied just inspired. I think rest are just copies of each other (in particular Harry Potter and Percy Jackson) so I think I select LOTR and Narnia
I like every series except for Twilight, Artemis Fowl, and Alex Rider.
His Dark Materials and Artemis Fowl for me. Hands down, no competition. Percy Jackson and LOTR immediately after.
The Hunger Games, Artemis Fowl, Percy Jackson and Harry Potter.
Harry Potter, Hunger Games, Twilight, Percy JacksonHarry Potter is like old school, its a classic, can't beat it
Btw does anyone know if there are going to be anymore Percy Jackson movies after the lightning thief?
With Paradise Lost, John Milton tried to create an English epic that could stand beside great world literature, like The Iliad or The Odyssey. Tolkien actually accomplished what Milton set out to do. The Lord of the Rings didn't just launch a genre. It legitimized the value of books for at least two generations of people (so far), and gave English-speaking people their own epic.
Harry Potter is the best! Not just because it's the one I'm most obsessed with, but I liked the writing style all the action and there wasn't like a love triangle! I hate those. I do LIKE romance but not love triangles. Also I like all the different things like werewolf's and vampire's and wizard's and stuff. Sure there are those things in A LOT of other books but I just think that J.K Rowling used them all and made it so that it wasn't confusing. Like a lot of other books do. They explain it but not in much detail and it starts to get confusing. So I would say HANDS DOWN HARRY POTTER!!!
the hunger games is the best!!!!!
the hunger games is the best!!!!!
the hunger games is the best!!!!!
the hunger games is the best!!!!!
Asmaa wrote: "narnia is extremely boring! *gags* X-P"
ya it is
ya it is
I would say Lord of the Rings, but then, I just started the Fellowship.Percy Jackson was awful.
I really liked Harry Potter for several years, but as I've gotten older (and it's only been like 1-2 years!), I've liked it less and less.
I like Narnia.
Haven't read the rest, and don't want to.
Harry Potter, Hunger Games, Twilight, Percy Jackson. In order
Come on people, Lord Of The Rings is like the Bible for these other books.
~Haelee~ wrote: "idk about narnia and LOTR. they definetely classics, but I found them boring because they didnt have enough action. In LOTR, the battles werent very descriptive and they only lasted for about a pag..."You said that battles in LOTR last for 1 page?
Are you serious?
The battle of Pelenor fields only is about 30 pages long, have you even read it?
Hunger Games because of everything
Hunger Games tops them all. HP comes in an extremely close 2nd though
It was between the hunger games, harry potter, or lodI will pick lord of the rings.
Jarred wrote: "I feel all of these comments have been written by people under the age of 15. Someone really said Harry Potter is a classic? Up there with Dracula, The Once and Future King, and The Odyssey? Give..."
In 100 years these books will be the classics not saying those others aren't good cause I read a few and liked them but these ones interest me more
Love all the books hard to chose which one I like the best but is would have to be
Percy Jackson -Harry potter-artimis fowl. All tied for first
Alex rider - hunger games - narnia. Tied next
with twilight dead last
Haven't read the others but soon will
Connor wrote: "I don't understand the people saying that Harry Potter won't be a classic. It might not be now, but just you wait for a couple decades. The HP series is the biggest literary phenomenon of all tim..."Biggest literary phenomenon? While I love HP and think it'll stick around, it has no grounds for being the biggest literary phenomenon. That place is held by J.R.R. Tolkien and The Lord of the Rings.
I've read "the lion the Witch and the wardrobe" of The Narnia series and all of The Harry Potter and Twilight series, i Just finished reading the Twilight Graphic Novel part one and because of that, i would have to say twilight. In order:1) Twilight Saga
2)Harry Potter Series
3) Narnia.
Aretemis fowl Percy Jackson, twilight and lord of the rings
harry potter or hunger games
twilight sux.harry potter rox.
percy jackson is pretty good.
havent read artemis fowl or his dark materials or alex rider.
narnia and lord of the rings are a bit boring.
hunger games rox.
Never read His Dark Materials, The Hunger Games, or Alex Rider
1. Artemis Fowl, NO COMPETITION.
2. Lord of the Rings.
3. Percy Jackson.
4. Twilight.
5. Harry Potter.
6. Narnia.
1. Artemis Fowl, NO COMPETITION.
2. Lord of the Rings.
3. Percy Jackson.
4. Twilight.
5. Harry Potter.
6. Narnia.
OMG HARRY POTTER!! The only thing that comes somewhat close is percy jackson!!
oh and of course Hunger games is with percy jackson but nothin beats harry potter
Brooke wrote: "Never read His Dark Materials, The Hunger Games, or Alex Rider1. Artemis Fowl, NO COMPETITION.
2. Lord of the Rings.
3. Percy Jackson.
4. Twilight.
5. Harry Potter.
6. Narnia."
You haven't read The Hunger Games Shame on you and those do beat Harry Potter.
I haven't read Lord of The Rings so I can't justifiably say. But the from the other ones, I'll have to say nothing else stands a chance compared to Harry Potter. It's hard to compare anything with something that comes so close t being the ultimate writing for people in our times.
Josh wrote: "So, it just occurred to me that while the Twilight vampires would kick any other vampire's ass (because they're OP), avada kedavra, or maybe reducio (if that's the right spelling) would probably ta..."Haha! Well said :)
Derek wrote: "Sorry to Lord of the rings fans, but it had wayyyyyyy to much detail. The books could have been 2 hundred pages and still made as much sense!"Haha!! :)
well HUNGER GAMES IS THE BEST ...ALEX RIDER IS AMAZING
PERCY JACKSON IS AWESOME
HP IS COOL
HIS DARK MATERIALS IS BORING
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
