Harry Potter discussion
FanFiction & Other Series
>
More Fake HP! (Don't look at this if you haven't already read the fake one)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Meghan
(last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:09PM)
(new)
Oct 16, 2007 08:35AM

reply
|
flag

I have no clue who wrote it, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't J.K. Rowling. Peng sent it to me. I was really hesitant to read it because I thought I'd be betraying the real story. But I started it and it was really pretty good. The real one is tons better. J.K. really did a good job with the real one.
One reason I read it was because I was so sad that the real one was over. I didn't want it to end. Really, the other one isn't really that bad. I'll tell you now though that I am a true Harry Potter fan! I LOVE IT TO DEATH! That is why I had to read what another person thought would happen in seven. They got some things really close too. (It was written before the real one)


you are bloody right about the draught of living death, meghan. that got me really scared for harry's life. and i so, so hate snape for making him drink that. and i have this like-dislike thing with draco there being good in occlumency but unwilling to help harry. geeezzzzzz!

I also could tell by about the first chapter that it wasn't Joe's writing. The first bit was a lot like it, but it totally changed.
I thought that they based that fake Harry on Daniel Radcliff, if you take my meaning. I also thought that some things in the fake hp were based more on the movies then the other books.


I don't know how wrote it. I heard it from a bunch of different people, but none of them told me who the people were. Jo is sueing them for millions.




before i read the book i did some looking... one website has a direct quote from JK saying that she didn't write the book but she supports this website because she is glad she touched people with the characters so much that she loves that they want to continue the story. she also said no legal action was going to take place and that the fake book 7 was written before the original even hit the stores. i liked the fake one... i liked that harry didn't have to get hit with the killing curse... AGAIN just to get rid of the horcrux. but i get what you all are saying... there is a lot of snogging.


Is harry a 7th horcrux in this book as well as the real one?
and of course the remaining piece of soul remaining in voldemort.
my husband says the tiara, but us that in this book??? but that still just makes 5 and not 6.
of course it is possible that i am totally insane . ..
and in the REAL hp7 they are the diary, the ring, locket, cup, nagini, tiara, harry, yes????
diary, ring, cup, locket, harry, tiara, voldemort

he didn't throw it.... if you remember when he is talking to his family and friends in his mind dumbledore tells him that he showed Hermione how to jinx it to fly into the veil

THAT SOUNDS GREAT!! YOU SHOULD START THAT! You can have everyone write like a paragraph and then we can all work from there! someone needs to start "the last 19 years" ending