Harry Potter discussion
Personal Preferences
>
marauder's map or invisibility cloak?`
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Anj_bookster
(last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:06PM)
(new)
Oct 13, 2007 06:13AM
invisibility cloak- it has been very very useful to harry since the beginning to the end of the story..
reply
|
flag
*
How many times have you wanted to be a fly on the wall? The invisibility cloak all the way.
I want both the invisibilty cloak and the maruader's map. They are both useful.
The invisibility cloak would be the most useful. Since for the most part you wouldn't need to know if someone is approaching if you could just walk past them unnoticed anyway.
i'd rather have the marauder's map, hands down if you knew where everything was and everyone, you could easily hide or scare them. and all those secret passages!
Both would come in very handy for me right now, but I think the invisibility cloak would be a little more useful within the next couple weeks.
The invisiblility cloak-- I want to know how the people I work with really talk about me when I'm not around . . . at least I think I want to know that . . .
I'd want the invisibility cloak because you could use it after going to Hogwarts. I mean, yes, Mrs. Weasley would probably use the map to keep an eye on her kids so she would know what they where doing, but I'd want the cloak. ;)
I agree with Meghan, at school I would choose the map but at home, the cloak.
yeah i agree with Meghan too.
I'd go with the Invisibility Cloak.
I agree with McKenzie, the map in school and in the home the invisibility cloak.
Invisibility cloak it's ok, but I rather choose the marauder's map so I can know where is everbody
I agree with McKenzie too. Besides, I would rithar keep something that was mine by right (the cloak) than somebody else's stuff (the map). The map should belong to Lupin.
Invisiblility cloak. You can just find the person. Plus you can use the invisibility cloak anywhere. The map can only be used at hogwarts so when you graduate, byebye.
invisibility cloak...? I guess, but I would love to know where everyone was. But actually, if the cloak worked for me like it did for Harry, then no doubt about the cloak.
well, since i don't sneak around in overly crowded places.....i would definitely take the invisibility cloak.
Invisibility cloak - The Marauder's Map can only be used in Hogwarts. Invisibility Cloak is for everywhere. Besides, it's one of the gifts of Death in the Tale of the Three Brothers - and probably the most sought after item.
Invisibility Cloak
Mod
Novin wrote: "The Invisibility Cloak is for sure much more useful. "
Definitely. i.e, PRANKS!
I'd have to say the Marauder's Map since knowing me I won't really like to sneak around...except making people trip would be fun...hmm...I'm stuck between.
Mod
"
Definitely. i.e, PRANKS!"
=D
Hmmm...while I was at school the Merauders Map for sure - but it would be useless when I left unless I because a teacher (not likely, I hate children). So I guess the Cloak!
Mod
Totally the invisibility coak!! It would be so cool to be invisable!!!
maurderers map, because if you had that you wouldn't need to be invisible
Novin wrote: "Awww!THAT'D BE REALLY MEAN FOR A TEACHER TO HAVE THE MAP! X("Not if it was a cool teacher! Or I could be Hagrid's assistant. Hehe.
cloak, you'd have it forever specially since the map is useless outside of hogwarts
im not gonna lurk around herbology my whole life
Cloakcause wat if the map riped or hogwarts got reconstucted??
cloak rox
:DDD
Lorna wrote: "Hmmm...while I was at school the Merauders Map for sure - but it would be useless when I left unless I because a teacher (not likely, I hate children). So I guess the Cloak!"Thats so mean! U were a kid once!
oh and after you and all ur friends leave hogwarts, theres no one left to watch that u would no!
Novin wrote: "Swati wrote: "Novin wrote: "The Invisibility Cloak is for sure much more useful. "
Definitely. i.e, PRANKS!"
=D"
i am a child!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kirit wrote: "Lorna wrote: "Hmmm...while I was at school the Merauders Map for sure - but it would be useless when I left unless I because a teacher (not likely, I hate children). So I guess the Cloak!"Thats s..."
Lol sorry...I suppose what I mean is that I'm not good with children.
Ohhhhok
lol
Invisibility Cloak, all the way! How cool would that be? You could sneak around all you want and not get caught. Hehe. :)
marauders map bcuz i could see where my friends were, where my mother was if i was sneaking something like eating in the living room w/o a tray, and like i could see where anyone is and be like i know where you were at blank. but don't think i'm a stalker cuz i'm not, i just think it would be cool :)
Tulah wrote: "marauders map bcuz i could see where my friends were, where my mother was if i was sneaking something like eating in the living room w/o a tray, and like i could see where anyone is and be like i k..."heyy tulah!!!!
but isnt the map only for hogwarts?
lol
i would definetly want both of them cause if u had both of them u could see where people are and u could sneak up on them but if u just had the cloak u wouldnt know where people would be and if u just had the map u only know where people are and u cant like sneak up on people or follow them around or something
If you lived out your entire life in Hogwarts, then I'd want the Maurader's Map. But since the invisibilty cloak works anywhere in the world, that is the most useful of the two objects.
That's basically what I said.It's a shame we can't pick both. Look at the mischief James Potter Sr. made with the just the cloak! It made it possible to create the map! Then look at all the stuff Fred and George did with just the map. Harry had both, so just think of everything he could have done if his greatest ambition in life was to create as must havoc as possible while at Hogwarts.
