Harry Potter discussion
Questions
>
if dumbledore was the dark lord, could harry stood a chance?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Peng
(last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:05PM)
(new)
Oct 12, 2007 05:54PM

reply
|
flag





i got your drift, too, bre, after reading it several times. lol! but i'm just so impressed with dumbledore's wisdom and yet not crossing that line to "evilness" (macgonagall said he wouldn't do dark magic because he was too "noble") and yet we were told in the last book that he was at that brink of planning to rule over the muggles with grindezwald that's why i thought of this topic. voldemort's mistake was not hearing the full prophesy resulting to his marking of harry (as jane stated) but if it were dumbledore he would have known his steps and plan them carefully. i guess that acquisition of knowledge of your enemy was what saved harry and he owed it all to dumbledore. if it was just him in all his actions, it would be just pure luck (as voldemort & the deatheaters so thought).




Then this might make a lot more sense. I don't know about you, but this is getting really confusing.



I won't even speculate. Because if Dumbledoor was a dark Lord, Tom would have never come to Hogwarts (or been under his watchful eye) and may never have become evil. But we don't know...do we ^_^





dumbledore taught him about the horcruxes and every thing else that helped him to deafeat voldemort and besides dumbldore never liked the greater good thing as much as grinlwald wich means he'd problbly be able to love.
plus dumbledore's the greatest wizard.

but harry wouldnt use them for wrong reasons obviously.
so if dumbledore was the dark lord, he wouldnt have told harry about his powers anyway..coz harry could've used them against him later.