Terminalcoffee discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Feeling Nostalgic? The archives
>
Why?????
Well, that's just silly! Miss Marple is supposed to be a deceptively sweet, woolly old lady who has observed people for years and so knows character, and the propensity for murder, when she sees it.How is the young and lovely Miss Garner appropriate for this particular role?
Extremely odd choice. I agree Barb, Hollywood's obsession with youth is past credible. Diane Lane would have made a much more age appropriate choice, but must not have the box office appeal of a Jennifer Garner.
Jim wrote: "Extremely odd choice. I agree Barb, Hollywood's obsession with youth is past credible. Diane Lane would have made a much more age appropriate choice, but must not have the box office appeal of a ..."Also Diane Lane can act, Jennifer Garner, not so much. . .
Seriously? Marple always struck me as older. I am also opposed to this choice.Even with the age consideration, Diane Lane is sexier anyway, regardless of age.
I think Scarlett is pretty in a very classic way, but I'm not all over it like most people are.We all know that I just can't find SJP attractive.
I'll just sit and stare at my Rachel Weisz instead...[image error]
There are just so many choices that could have been. It seems they are putting themselves behind the 8 ball to start out.
You should see the rabid fans who are upset over Katherine Heigl being cast as Stephanie Plum for the book series being made into a movie.
I do agree though. Poor casting choice.
Marple is supposed to be older. They went with a what-if of "what would she have been like as a younger woman?" while ignoring the part about her wisdom coming from experience. It's Disney deciding Marple needs an origin story to show where she got her wisdom.
I kind of can't stand Jennifer Garner. She's so glowingly pretty I feel like I have to squint to look at her. Her face makes me uncomfortable. That movie with Ricky Gervais and the lying kind of rubbed it in.
To be fair, I do think she's pretty when she smiles that very big smile of hers. Her smile is absolutely stunning. The rest of the time, her features look a bit awkward, as if not everything fits on her face correctly if that makes sense.I have nothing against her though. Just not sure how she fits this particular role.
BunWat wrote: "Jim wrote: "Extremely odd choice. I agree Barb, Hollywood's obsession with youth is past credible. Diane Lane would have made a much more age appropriate choice, but must not have the box office..."Well I was going to go with Helen Mirren, but thought you could probably make Diane Lane look a little older, and maybe Miss Marple could have been a younger looking older lady since I wasn't quite sure of her age.
Either way Jennifer Garner seems like an odd choice.
I think it may be Jennifer Garner's own production company pitching it, so she may have decided she wants to play her and that's that.Interestingly, according to something else I read, Angela Lansbury was just 59 when she first played Miss Marple.
BunWat wrote: "I'm not sure I'd ever buy Helen Mirren as dithery and ineffectual even if she was supposed to be faking."Good point.
Yeah, no, not Helen Mirren. Or Judy Dench. How about that actress who is Emma Thompson's mom, in real life. She's Nurse Pomfrey in the Harry Potter movies, she played Bridget Jones' mom, and she was the mother in Sense and Sensibility, too.
Gemma something...
Gemma Jones.
Oh! And! By the way, Jennifer Garner is NOT ENGLISH. Stupid, stupid idea...
Well yes, there's that too. Maybe she only became English with age.
BunWat wrote: "I'm not sure she would be a great choice to play someone who pretends to be dithery and easily confused in order to lull people into a false sense of security..."Hey, that's Columbo's shtick!
Jennifer Garner was perfect in Juno. I think she's one of those people who responds to a good role. But no, not Miss Marple.
I heard Justin Beiber is going to play James Bond, too.
BunWat wrote: "Sarah Pi wrote: "Well yes, there's that too. Maybe she only became English with age."Sneep!!
You know, Christian Bale freaks me out every time he opens his mouth IRL and an English accent c..."
The guy from House does that, too. Always weird.
Mod
I want to see Justin Bieber just TRY to grow that mustache! I know, he's not Belgian, either. :)
BunWat wrote: "Sarah Pi wrote: "Well yes, there's that too. Maybe she only became English with age."Sneep!!
You know, Christian Bale freaks me out every time he opens his mouth IRL and an English accent c..."
Except Christian Bale likes to give interviews in the accent of the movie he's promoting. So he was speaking American English when he did the interviews for Batman. That's part of why his British accent sounded so strange when he switched movies and started using it again. And why does he sound almost Cockney? I always expect a more genteel accent.
Mod
Mod
Lobstergirl wrote: "Obama's American accent is not half bad, for a Kenyan."Indeed.
Mod
Larry wrote: "Lobstergirl wrote: "Obama's American accent is not half bad, for a Kenyan."Indeed."
Especially a Kenyan-Indonesian.
Mod
Yeah, but I like him, so I think it's cute. :)(Jeremy Northam, NOT Kevin Costner!)
Mod
BunWat wrote: "Jim wrote: "Extremely odd choice. I agree Barb, Hollywood's obsession with youth is past credible. Diane Lane would have made a much more age appropriate choice, but must not have the box office..."Ohhh, but Helen Mirren would. She is a seriously foxy sextegenarian (sp?).
Heidi wrote: "BunWat wrote: "Jim wrote: "Extremely odd choice. I agree Barb, Hollywood's obsession with youth is past credible. Diane Lane would have made a much more age appropriate choice, but must not have..."Julie Christie, too...
Mod
BunWat wrote: "But Miss Marple isn't supposed to be sexy."I know... I was responding more to your mention of age appropriateness, mixed with everyone else's requirement of sexiness. Frankly, I think Maggie Smith would be a perfect Ms. Marple.
Stacia learned how to read last week wrote: "You should see the rabid fans who are upset over Katherine Heigl being cast as Stephanie Plum for the book series being made into a movie."I always envisioned Sandra Bullock as Stephanie and Queen Latifah as Lula!
This is the Jen I actually love! However, I have to agree with Bun on Geraldine McEwan as Ms. Marple. PERFECT!
Mod
[image error]
Mod
I don't think I saw Sliding Doors but it was lame in Emma. It killed me to see her in that role because Jeremy Northam was so perfect for George Knightley.
BunWat wrote: "Gemma Jones could work, definitely."And she has a nice rack.
Lobstergirl wrote: "BunWat wrote: "No it doesn't. Her accent in Sliding Doors was very good."
I don't think I saw Sliding Doors but it was lame in Emma. It killed me to see her in that role because Jeremy Northam wa..."
I didn't like the 1996 version of Emma at all. Toni Collette as Harriet Smith was poorly cast as well.
I don't think I saw Sliding Doors but it was lame in Emma. It killed me to see her in that role because Jeremy Northam wa..."
I didn't like the 1996 version of Emma at all. Toni Collette as Harriet Smith was poorly cast as well.
Mod
Yes.
Mod
Are we missing any Emmas?
Misha, Joan Hixon will always be my perfect Miss Marple too!
Miss Marple IS Helen Hayes in my mind.
I'd love to see Joan Plowright as "Miss Marple."
Heidi, that says a lot about Ms. Hayes, since she only played the character twice!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
http://www.avclub.com/articles/oh-for...