War and Peace
discussion
Any recommendations of other Russian novels?



BenthamFish

Funny, you can read about Shylock and make allowances for Shakespeare's time, but I'm afraid Tolstoy was a cranky old chauvinist - along with all the genius.

Might give it a go anyway. Will check a bunch of reviews for the works you all mentioned and then decide. Then I'll start adding to my evergrowing "to read" pile.
Thanks to all for the pointers.


If you like 1984 and Brave New World, read We by Yevgeny Zamyatin. This is a great distopian novel. Also, Republic of the Southern Cross.



All the above-mentioned novels are quite heavy reads both literary and figuratively. And I am not sure about the quality of their translation as Russian is my first language (well, used to be. Now it is the majesty and grandeur of the English language [that is how Professor Higgins defines it]:-) )I tried to read one of the Pushkin's novels in English just for the sake of scientific curiosity, and it was poorly done, so I gave up. Anyway, all the above-mentioned ones abound in Russian lacunae, and I am not sure how adequate the translation is.
But if you are looking for a light, but still quality read, I would recommend Boris Akunin. His novels about the Russian 19th - 20th century sleuth are well-written, engaging, with certain psychologically depth and multi-dimensional characters. And the main character is a 'Byronesque' romanticist with a finely tuned and extremely perceptive Russian soul as well as astute and brilliant mind.
Jacqueline wrote: "Please - not Anna Karenina. Tolstoy definitely viewed women as lesser beings - the one thing about him that really annoys me. Anna spirals downwards through the book and that is what the story is..."
God, I agree! Finally some guts. He was a curmudgeon who disliked women and treated them like lesser beings truly. Love his genius but not that book. Well said.
God, I agree! Finally some guts. He was a curmudgeon who disliked women and treated them like lesser beings truly. Love his genius but not that book. Well said.

IMHO, Anna Karenina deserves its reputation among many as one of the great novels of all time. Yes, Anna struggles, but, oh, what a struggle, and what a cry Tolstoy placed on his generation and succeeding ones.
One of the critiques I have read along the way said that Tolstoy himself fell in love with this beautiful woman, even when he wanted to not condone all her actions.
Yes, there is an entire parallel story centered on Levin and his wife Kitty, plus other family story lines, such as of Dolly and Stephan.
Please don't let negative perceptions steer you away from immersing yourself in this stunning novel sometime over your lifetime. You may become bored by parts, but that is par for the course in something this big, this sprawling, like life itself.

My life changed then.
I knew then that one could be genuinely and passionately uncertain and that it wasn't disgraceful. It was so refreshing to a young man who was just beginning to wrestle with all of life's questions and who had happened to be brought up in the bombastic certainty that passes itself off as "being spiritual" in Protestant America.



I was very struck by your comments on crime and Punishment and thought it was so energising that a work of fiction could have that much effect on somebody.
I too loved this book, and it really does make you think about how lucky we are (me anyway!)



And I also second Lily's suggestion that we include short story writers in the discussion. Chekhov is a short story genius!



Also anything by Dostoevsky, Turnegev or Chekhov is also a good place to start. You really can't go wrong with Russian literature. Writing seems to flow through their veins.

Couldn't agree more...


My favorite modern Russian novel - and a very modern novel by any standard - is The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov. This book is an absolute delight.

Actually, no, Tolstoy was not a chauvinist for his time and Anna Karenina is symbolic of a woman's plight in the high strata circles of late-imperialist Russia. Tolstoy was highly, highly enlightened for being a Count in Russia... one only has to look at his relationship with such people as Gandhi, who adopted Tolstoy's views of nonviolent pacifism.
The Russian Table of Ranks (clerks, counts, princes, etc) play such an important unspoken role in 18th-19th century Russian lit and is an undercurrent of novels that needs to be investigated so that one can have a better understanding of its role.
It is a severe and quite foolish shame to NOT read AK, or any other masterpiece because of the supposed or alleged negative viewpoints expressed by an author. The art is in the work itself.


So you don't think there are any women around here now who spiral downwards?


A few names just to start with.




A.Pushkin is the greatest Russian poet and must be read only in Russian, as well as Shakespeare's sonnets must be read in English.

I do not think that Solzhenitsyn is/was a great author.
I believe that his success is based on political foundation rather than on his talent.

I do not think that Sol..."
Well I'm only recommending him based on "One day in the life of Ivan Denisovich" so I'm probably not the best judge, but I liked his work.
Political foundations may have ensured his recognition , but I don't think that's the only reason he's successful


Also Dostoyevsky is a must read if you want to grasp Russian classics.

Am still struggling with life and fate but it will hit me soon I expect

Farewell Gul'sary
From Bulgakov I prefer the Heart of a Dog
all discussions on this book |
post a new topic
Crime and Punishment (other topics)
Envy (other topics)
Buddha's Little Finger (other topics)
The Life of Insects (other topics)
More...
Anton Chekhov (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Anna Karenina (other topics)Crime and Punishment (other topics)
Envy (other topics)
Buddha's Little Finger (other topics)
The Life of Insects (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alexander Pushkin (other topics)Anton Chekhov (other topics)
I was hoping for a few pointers as to what to try next, also any advice on translations would be appreciated.