THE JAMES MASON COMMUNITY BOOK CLUB discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
36 views
Archives - Book Discussions > Sensation Fiction

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lev (new)

Lev Raphael | 23 comments Has anyone read "Lady Audley's Secret"? I stumbled on it and found it amazing! It made me read several more of her titles along with East Lynne and I felt cheated that we only read Gaskell and George Eliot in college, and not these "minor" writers who told such terrific stories.


Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
Lev wrote: "Has anyone read "Lady Audley's Secret"? I stumbled on it and found it amazing! It made me read several more of her titles along with East Lynne and I felt cheated that we only read Gaskell and Ge..."

YES!! I did read it- about 8 months ago, Lev! I also bought East Lynne- but have not read that yet- I found Lady Audley facinating- the suspense,plot characterizations are so ahead of their time!
The zeal in which the main protagonist searches for the truth, his dedication to a lost friend and evil dressed up in furs and "sparkling eyes" are utterly facinating!


message 3: by Shay (new)

Shay | 528 comments I added it to my TBR list. If anyone else is interested, you can download it for free: http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/8954

Noticed it was written a few years after The Moonstone. Did a bunch of detective type suspense books get published in this time frame? Any other authors you would recommend?


message 4: by Lev (new)

Lev Raphael | 23 comments Yes, they did. Sensation novels weren't exactly detective stories, though, but read the 3 Braddon titles Oxford has, and then East Lynne, and then Uncle Silas to see the commonalities.


message 5: by Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB (last edited Sep 07, 2010 07:23PM) (new)

Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
Lev wrote: "Yes, they did. Sensation novels weren't exactly detective stories, though, but read the 3 Braddon titles Oxford has, and then East Lynne, and then Uncle Silas to see the commonalities."

I love the "sensational" novels- I own Uncle Silas as well- I also have the out of print Braddon novels on my Kindle- but Lady Audley's Secret seems a very hard book to match! I was quite taken by it


Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
here is an interesting article on the Victorian Sensation Article

http://www.victorianweb.org/genre/sen...


message 7: by Gini (new)

Gini | 106 comments Shay wrote: "I added it to my TBR list. If anyone else is interested, you can download it for free: http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/8954."

Thanks for the tip! I now have it on my iPhone. (The thing I love best about my iPhone - I am NEVER stranded without a book these days!)


Marialyce (absltmom, yaya) That might be enough of an incentive for me to get an iPhone, Gini. :)


message 9: by Gini (new)

Gini | 106 comments Marialyce wrote: "That might be enough of an incentive for me to get an iPhone, Gini. :)"

I do love mine very much, but having almost a hundred books (I kind of went nuts at the Gutenberg Project website) stored in it for reading at any time is the best.


message 10: by Martha (new)

Martha (marthas48) Gini wrote: "Marialyce wrote: "That might be enough of an incentive for me to get an iPhone, Gini. :)"

I do love mine very much, but having almost a hundred books (I kind of went nuts at the Gutenberg Project ..."


Me, too!! Am no longer EVER caught without a book. I have audio, ebooks & children's books (for the grandkids) on mine. It's awesome!!


message 11: by Shay (new)

Shay | 528 comments I think that there is a converter that will put non-DRM ebooks into the correct code for the Kindle. I thought that Kindles could read the epub code, though. I know that Gutenbuerg has the txt files and I'm almost positive that Kindles can read those.


message 12: by Gini (new)

Gini | 106 comments Martha wrote: "
Me, too!! Am no longer EVER caught without a book. I have audio, ebooks & children's books (for the grandkids) on mine. It's awesome!! "


I have the eReader, iBooks, and Kindle Reader on my phone, so there are three books open in my phone, plus the regular books around the house. Reading is never a problem!


message 13: by Martha (new)

Martha (marthas48) Wonderful, isn't it?! However, I still prefer actual books to an eReader except for the tingling hands when I hold books. :-)


Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
Martha wrote: "Wonderful, isn't it?! However, I still prefer actual books to an eReader except for the tingling hands when I hold books. :-)"

I agree Martha- as much as it is nice to have 1000's of books on my Kindle- they cant compare to reading an actual book- I have recurring nightmares that in the future brick and mortar libraries will become extinct!!!


message 15: by Connie (new)

Connie Faull | 19 comments Rick wrote: "I agree Martha- as much as it is nice to have 1000's of books on my Kindle- they cant compare to reading an actual book- I have recurring nightmares that in the future brick and mortar libraries will become extinct!!! . :-)"

There was an article I read on the internet about a new machine that a library in California had last year (not sure if it still has it). If the library didn't have the book you were looking for, you could enter that book into this machine and it would retrieve the file and print the whole book for you, even bind it. Then you could either check it out from the library, or choose to purchase it. Maybe that is the way libraries and even the B & M stores will be going. (personally, I do prefer ebooks. To me, it's about getting lost in the story, not the feel of a book, but that's just my personal opinion. Plus I work in the environmental dept of a law firm and I just hate the thought of all the wasted paper used for books that are never sold) :)


message 16: by Shay (new)

Shay | 528 comments I love ebooks. I was late to buy an ereader, which is weird because I love new gadgets. I prefer ebooks because I have OCD and all ebooks are as pristine as the day you got them. My husband hates me buying books because even if I do reread them, I usually end up either getting a new copy or getting it from the library. If a book smells weird, looks weird, seems dusty, I won't read it. It makes me sick, so I just go and get a new one. So, it's not uncommon for me to have multiple copies of a book that I regularly reread. (I have four or so copies of the Grapes of Wrath, the Odyssey, the Illiad, etc.)


message 17: by Martha (new)

Martha (marthas48) I might adjust to it. Part of it could be the small screen on my iPhone. Anyway, I am happy for the convenience ... spent a lot of time at appointments today with my son so it was nice to be able to read while waiting without having to carry an extra book.


message 18: by Emma (new)

Emma | 73 comments Just curious, but what exactly is a "sensational" novel? Sorry, feel really naive for asking...


message 19: by Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB (last edited Sep 12, 2010 03:44PM) (new)

Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
Several mid-century phenomena led to the popularity of the Sensation Novel:

the abolition of the stamp duty on printing paper in 1855,
the concomitant increase in the circulation of newspapers,
an increase in numbers of readers in mid-Victorian Britain,
the dramatic increase in the number of circulating libraries,
new weekly and monthly (often illustrated) literary magazines
high-interest, serialised fiction to maintain a stable readership.
notorious trials such as that of the poisoner Palmer,
tabloid journalism,
reforms in divorce procedures
public education
Thus, writing in 1863, H. L. Mansel castigated the new subgenre as "preaching to the nerves instead of the judgment" (357). Since early in his anti-Sensation diatribe Mansel refers to "A pale young lady in a white dress" (358), we can be certain that his chief target is Wilkie Collins, whose The Woman in White (1860) initiated the Sensation mania. The typical practitioner of the new form, contends Mansel, aims at creating excitement alone in order "to supply the cravings of a diseased appetite" (357) prevalent in the recently augmented reading public: "No divine influence can be imagined as presiding over the birth of his work; no more immortality is dreamed of for it than for the fashions of the current season. A commercial atmosphere floats around works of this class, redolent of the manufactory and the shop" [357].

Although Wilkie Collins may well have been "The King of Sensation," the royal family of this new subgenre was by no means small, the most popular writers including

Charles Reade,
Ellen Price (Mrs. Henry Wood)
Ouida (Marie Louise de la Ramée)
James Payn
William Black
Mary Elizabeth (M. E.) Braddon ("The Queen of the Circulating Libraries")
Edmund Yates
Henry Kingsley
Although the form is often spoken of as a phenomenon of two decades, its influences may well be detected in works written after 1880, including the novels of Thomas Hardy (whose first effort, Desperate Remedies is very much in the Sensation vein), George Moore, Robert Louis Stevenson, and George Du Maurier, whose diabolical Svengali in Trilby (1896) is very much a Collinsian villain, except for his lack of gentlemanly status.

Ira B. Nadel in the Dictionary of Literary Biography, Volume 18, has attributed the success of Collins among a crowded field of practitioners of the new form to his "expert plotting with carefully described settings" (62), so evident in the novel that appears to initiated the public's mania for Sensation Novels, The Woman in White (1860). T. S. Eliot and Dorothy L. Sayers regard Collins's second best-seller in the genre, The Moonstone (1868), as the first detective novel in English, although Edgar Allen Poe initiated the crime-and-detection story two decades earlier. Whether one is considering Ellen Price Wood's East Lynne (1861) or M. E. Braddon's Lady Audley's Secret (1862) or Collins's early Sensation Novels, one will find the pattern of "criminality and passion beneath respectable surfaces" (Kalikoff 120); often, the Sensation Novel features a beautiful, clever young woman who, like Magdalen Vanstone in Collins's No Name (1862), is adept at disguise and deception —such women are doubly dangerous and generate social instability because they possess and threaten to use secret knowledge. Other strategies employed by Sensation authors include the exposure of hypocrisy in polite society, intentional and unintentional bigamy, adultery, hidden illegitimacy, extreme emotionalism, melodramatic dialogue and plotting, and the brilliant but eccentric villain with gentlemanly pretensions. Reginald C. Terry in Victorian Popular Fiction, 1860-80 employs the term "detailism" to describe yet another aspect of the Sensation Novel, its rigorous realism that catered to a contemporary "taste for the factual" (55) in its descriptions and settings, a feature that novelists such as Collins skillfully blended with the exciting "ingredients of suspense, melodrama and extremes of behaviour" (55). In addition, Terry notes how the plots of such novels often utilized "the apparatus of ruined heiresses, impossible wills, damning letters, skeletons in cupboards, [and] misappropriated legacies" (74). P. D. Edwards adds yet further "ingredients" to the Sensation formula: "arson, blackmail, madness, and persecuted innocence (usually young and female), acted out in the most ordinary and respectable social settings and narrated with ostentatious care for factual accuracy and fulness of circumstantial detail" (703). To all of these features we should add the realistic and sympathetic investigation of individual psychology and an exploration of the female psyche in the manner of George Eliot and Charlotte Brontë. The prevalence of these "ingredients" in the popular fiction of the 1860s and 1870s suggests that the Sensation Novel drew its energy from a popular mid-Victorian reaction to middle-class stodginess and prudery, a reaction that continued well past 1880 and is evident in such late Victorian works as Du Maurier's Trilby (1894) (whose arch-villain, Svengali, is reminiscent of the highly manipulative criminal master-minds of Collins, but lacks their breeding) and Stevenson's Dr. Jeckyll and Mr. Hyde (1886).

P. D. Edwards notes that the term "Sensation Novel" was originally applied disparagingly to a broad range of crime, mystery, and horror novels written in the early 1860s: "A writer in the Literary Budget, November 1861, asserted that the term originated in America" (1860). The subgenre was effectively defined in a two-year period by the novels of Wilkie Collins, Ellen Price Wood, and Mary Elizabeth Braddon, first serialised in the new literary magazines before appearing in the triple-decker format favoured by the lending-libraries. Reginald C. Terry in Victorian Popular Fiction, 1860-80 contends that B. F. Fisher's in the 16 February 1861 number of the London Review is the earliest reference to "sensation novelists" in a discussion of a current trend in American literature, "although in a general way 'sensation' had been applied to Wilkie Collins in 1855 reviews of Antonia and Basil" (181).

The question of identity is integral to this [The Woman in White] as to other sensation fictions. Mistaken identity, hidden identities, are the staple of Collins's No Name (1862) and Armadale (1866), and Mary Braddon's Lady Audley's Secret (1862), and are often concerned with questions of inheritance, with legal identity, but the language of psychology allowed other dimensions of the question to be addressed. What precisely constitutes identity comes into question as the workings of memory are investigated, and found to be lacking [in The Moonstone (1868)]. [Marshall, "Psychology and the sensation novel," 58-59]
The features commonly associated with the publishing phenomenon of the 1860s known as the Sensation Novel include the following:

bigamous marriages
misdirected letters
romantic triangles
heroines placed in physical danger
drugs, potions, and/or poisons
characters adopt disguises
trained coincidences
aristocratic villains
heightened suspense detailism
These narrative features, common to most Sensation Novels of the early '60s, were soon parodied:

This Journal will be devoted chiefly to the following objects; namely, Harrowing the Mind, Making the Flesh Creep, Causing the Hair to Stand on End, Giving Shocks to the Nervous System, Destroying Conventional Moralities, and generally Unfitting the Public for the Prosaic Avocations of Life. (mock advertisement "The Sensation Times, and Chronicle of Excitement" in Punch, 1863; cited in Hughes 3)
The parodist promises the public graphic accounts of violent crimes, corporal punishments, and animal cruelty, as well as a Sensation Novel (presumably in serial) full of "hitherto undreamed of" atrocities and written by an "eminent" writer shortly to be released from a penitentiary. The novels that are the subject of this lampoon are not immediately obvious, but were undoubtedly all available for a modest annual "lending" fee at Mudie's Library or in the bookstalls of most railway stations.
(continued in next post)


message 20: by Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB (last edited Sep 12, 2010 03:44PM) (new)

Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
In The Maniac in the Cellar (1980), Winifred Hughes associates the rise of the Sensation Novel in the early 1860s with the continued popular taste for the Gothic Novel of the previous century (particularly the goosebump gothicism of Ann Radcliffe and the more gruesome gothicism of Matthew G. "Monk" Lewis, the historical romances of Sir Walter Scott, the oriental tales of Lord Byron) and the more recent Newgate Novel, as pioneered by Harrison Ainsworth, Edward G. D. Bulwer-Lytton, and Charles Dickens. Conservative critics, she contends, regarded this new subgenre, as exemplified by the early '60s novels of Wilkie Collins, Ellen Price Wood, and M. E. Braddon, as "brash, vulgar, and subversive" (6). In his autobiography, novelist Anthony Trollope went so far as to label the Sensation Novel "unrealistic" by the mid-1870s in that he held "The novelists who are considered to be anti-sensational are generally called realistic" (1883: Vol. 2, p. 41; cited in Hughes, p. 39). He might well have added "dramatic," "theatrical," or "melodramatic" to his indictment since a number of Sensation writers acted and wrote for the stage, and since novels such as East Lynne and Lady Audley's Secret proved popular with audiences when adapted for the theatre.

According to Hughes, "what distinguishes the true sensation genre as it appeared in its prime during the 1860s is the violent yoking of romance and realism, traditionally the two contradictory modes of literary perception" (16). If we take the early novels of Collins as our locus classicus, we can see that the new subgenre indeed fused opposites, both possible and improbable, solidly English and yet exotic, sordid and yet respectable, refined yet violent, scientific and yet superstitious, documentary and yet far-fetched, realistic and yet romantic, rational and at the same time absurdist, but above all romantic and suspenseful, "a kind of civilized melodrama, modernized and domesticated — not only an everyday gothic, minus the supernatural and aristocratic trappings, but also a middle-class Newgate, featuring spectacular crime unconnected with the usual criminal classes. [Hughes 16]

George Augustus Sala in "On the 'Sensational' in Literature and Art" (Belgravia, IV, 1868, p. 455), undoubtedly trying to legitimize the extreme form that had recently appeared, attributed the founding of the Sensation Novel to no less a figure than Charles Dickens. Although some of Dickens's later works, especially The Mystery of Edwin Drood (1870), exhibit some of the tendencies of Sensation fiction, in his last novel he was more likely responding to the new form, as produced by his apprentice and associate at All the Year Round, Wilkie Collins, rather than merely aping it. Collins and Reade, however, may have borrowed their aesthetic theory from Dickens, dwelling, as Bleak House remarks, upon "the romantic side of familiar things." A holdover from an earlier generation of writers, Dickens so strenuously objected to the explicit sexuality and social radicalism of Charles Reade's Very Hard Cash (1863) that he adopted the (for him) unusual expedient of publishing a disclaimer at the conclusion of the novel's final instalment in All the Year Round. Lillian Nayder estimates that Dickens was correct in assuming that Reade's candour lost him readers "in droves" (Pilgrim Letters 10: 237), "perhaps as many as three thousand" (Nayder 137). Whereas, moreover, in Dickens, plot —no matter how convoluted or complicated — and character — no matter how eccentric or whimsical — are always enlisted in the service of theme, in much Sensation fiction plot and incident —rendered complicated for their own sakes — predominate because the writer's chief intention is to delight and horrify rather than to instruct and reform. Typically, no sooner has a Sensation writer solved one mystery or resolved one dilemma for us than he or she must introduce another in order to escalate suspense. "The difficulty with this [pattern], of course, is that climax becomes the routine, subjecting the reader to an endless roller-coaster effect that eventually loses its thrill" (Hughes 19).

However, as Hughes is quick to point out, Collins's handling of "drawn-out mystification or impending menace" (19), particularly in The Moonstone, is so masterful and so controlled and metred out that the reader revels not so much in successive rises as in the final denouement, which harmonizes all competing narratives and executes Nemesis character by character. No sooner had the new subgenre won a popular following than M. E. Braddon and other Punch writers, as we have seen, lampooned it. Hughes makes a convincing case (based on that presented by H. J. W. Milley in "The Eustace Diamonds [run serially in the Fortnightly Review in 1871] and The Moonstone" [run serially in All the Year Round in 1868], Studies in Philology, October 1939, pp. 651-63) for Trollope's The Eustace Diamonds as a parody of Collins's The Moonstone, complete with a young lady's falling under suspicion of having stolen her own jewels, two robberies, and a bumbling detective. At about the same time, the prospect of the royalties from producing a best-seller probably inspired young architect Thomas Hardy to write his own Sensation Novel, Desperate Remedies. Published anonymously, the potboiler utilizes many of Collins's strategies, albeit far less effectively: "murder, blackmail, illegitimacy, impersonation, eavesdropping, multiple secrets, a suggestion of bigamy, [and] amateur and professional detectives" (Hughes 173) are all present. Even those scholars and critics who assert that Hardy was one of the most original prose-fiction writers of the latter part of the nineteenth century must concede that, as the plots of even some of greater novels such as The Mayor of Casterbridge and Tess of the D'Urbervilles attest, Hardy never quite lost his taste for Sensation, even if the reading public had tired of it after 1880. In particular, Hardy had a fondness for such standard Sensation strategies as the instalment closings known as "curtains," strongly delineated characters. numerous coincidences upon which the plot seems to hinge, bigamous or secret marriages, illegitimacy, and the "return-from-the dead" scenario, even providing what H. L. Mansel in 1863 had termed "some demon in human shape" (360) in the person of Alec D'Urberville.


message 21: by Emma (new)

Emma | 73 comments Wow, thank you so much for all that information. Now, I actually understand the previous posts. :) And it sounds like a subgenre of literature that I would really enjoy. I am so looking forward to reading Collins!


message 22: by Shay (new)

Shay | 528 comments Emma wrote: "Wow, thank you so much for all that information. Now, I actually understand the previous posts. :) And it sounds like a subgenre of literature that I would really enjoy. I am so looking forward t..."

Read at least The Moonstone and The Woman in White and, assuming you've read Dickens, read Drood.


message 23: by Emma (new)

Emma | 73 comments I have both the Woman in White and the Moonstone on my shelves. I began the first couple chapters of The Moonstone a month ago, but got distracted by Northanger Abbey :) I definitely plan on going back to it. And I cannot wait to read the Woman in White. Drood is also on my TBR list, but I feel that I should at least read something of Dickens before starting. Do you have a recommendation for a first Dickens?


Rick-Founder JM CM BOOK CLUB  | 7274 comments Mod
Emma wrote: "I have both the Woman in White and the Moonstone on my shelves. I began the first couple chapters of The Moonstone a month ago, but got distracted by Northanger Abbey :) I definitely plan on goin..."

Shay is correct- her two Wilkie Collin's recommendations are top notch! also check our Collin's The Law and the Lady- I really loved that one too! The Law and the Lady by Wilkie Collins


message 25: by Shay (new)

Shay | 528 comments I think almost any Dickens would be good, pick the one you most want to read. I think that all except The Mystery of Edwin Drood are pretty consistent with the "Dickens style". Do not read Mystery of Edwin Drood first, it's unfinished and not representative of the body of his work. The novel Drood, though, is written around the time of his final reading tour and the writing of The Mystery of Edwin Drood. I don't think it's necessary to read it first though.


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.