The Writing Ninjas' Fan Club discussion
Land of Baxter's Intellect
>
Controversial Books and Censorship in Literature
I think there's a too far, because I prefer to remain innocent. I started reading 'I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings' in January for a project... scarred for life.
Mod
Mod
I'm actually not very experienced with censorship... so I should shut up.
Mod
Something about challenged books just draws me in.
Mod
Mod
Something about challenged books just draws me in."
Yeah. Same. :P
Mod
Mod
AW YEAH, THIS IS THE KIND OF COMMENT I LIKE TO SEE! WHOO!
But if you guys actually want to be disturbed I'd highly recommend Naked Lunch. I mean, it is one of my favorite books of all time, and it succeed in making me just kind of put it down and say, "Why in Gods name do I want to hear this?"
Also, good old Sade. He was a character for the ages. What with his silly 120 Days of Sodom and Justine and whatnot. Good times, good times...
♥ Brigid ♥ wrote: "Omigosh, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings scarred me for life too!!!! I read it when I was 12 for this autobiography project and … yeah. lol. I don't "prefer to remain innocent", though. I liked to ..."
Yeah. By "prefering to remain innocent", I don't mean that I want to be ignorant. I'm aware of lots of the "bad stuff" going on, but I think you can be aware without scarring someone for life. I mean, I was aware of rape before I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings; I just don't think Maya Angelou has to describe it in detail for me to understand.
Yeah. By "prefering to remain innocent", I don't mean that I want to be ignorant. I'm aware of lots of the "bad stuff" going on, but I think you can be aware without scarring someone for life. I mean, I was aware of rape before I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings; I just don't think Maya Angelou has to describe it in detail for me to understand.
Mod
Censorship has no place in books. People pick and choose what books they want to read, that simple.
Mod
I could attempt to write a long rambly-type comment, but I'll just go ahead and say "What Brigid said."
Mod
And on with that rant, I shall leave this topic?
Mod
Well, that's the thing … It's quite easy to say that you don't want to know what it's like to be raped if you've never been raped. But Maya Angelou didn't have a choice. Can you imagine being raped and having to keep all those details in your head forever? It makes sense that, when someone experiences something truly horrible, they want to share with others so that those other people can sympathize. Otherwise, you just have to keep that pain inside your whole life, and you don't get that catharsis (right word?).
♥ Brigid ♥ wrote: "Maxy wrote: "Yeah. By "prefering to remain innocent", I don't mean that I want to be ignorant. I'm aware of lots of the "bad stuff" going on, but I think you can be aware without scarring someone f..."
Yeah, I see what you mean, and I completely understand not being able to keep things in your head. What I'm trying to get at is that I wish there was some kind of warning. Not censorship, but a warning. I was expecting a simple, good biography to read for my English class, so it really caught me off guard when I came upon a detailed sex scene.
Yeah, I see what you mean, and I completely understand not being able to keep things in your head. What I'm trying to get at is that I wish there was some kind of warning. Not censorship, but a warning. I was expecting a simple, good biography to read for my English class, so it really caught me off guard when I came upon a detailed sex scene.
I'm probably coming off as a really insensitive, naive teenager... It's not like I don't feel bad for Maya Angelou, because I imagine that's one of the worst crimes to be a victim of, but I'm not sure that reading that book affected me in the way she wanted it to. Am I making any sense?
Mod
I get what you're saying. I'm just too tired to comment because auditions for Footloose killed me.
Mod
Ilana wrote: "Some books are meant for people who would understand and some books are meant to make people understand. I don't like when teachers at school mistake a book for being the latter."
Or when they put more thought into a book than the author did. When we read Lord of the Flies, we had to analyze practically every sentence that mentioned the conch. The book would say something like "The conch shell sat on the rock beside Ralph." Then we'd have to describe what that symbolized...?
Or when they put more thought into a book than the author did. When we read Lord of the Flies, we had to analyze practically every sentence that mentioned the conch. The book would say something like "The conch shell sat on the rock beside Ralph." Then we'd have to describe what that symbolized...?
Mod
Mod
Mod
Mod
Mod
Mod
I never thought about that, but he probably did. Simon was the least annoying to me.
Mod
Haha. I always wonder how different that book would have been if a bunch of girls washed up on the island...
Mod
"At last Ralph ceased to blow and sat there"
"Ralph continued to blow till his ears were singing with the effort"
"the boys were wet and shrieking"
"Eric bent down and blew softly again"
Got a ship in your pocket?” Simon grinned and shook his head.
"He had fallen asleep after what seemed hours of tossing and turning noisily"
Got a ship in your pocket?” Simon grinned and shook his head.
"Ralph squirted again and missed"
In panic, Ralph thrust his own stick through the crack and struck with all his might.
“Aaa-ah!”
His spear twisted a little in his hands and then he withdrew it again.
“Ooh-ooh—”
“Oh, my bum!” He rubbed his rump ruefully. Jack rolled over. “That was a good game.”
"Ralph found his breath and blew a series of short blasts"
"Once more Ralph found himself making the cupping gesture."
“How did your friend blow the conch?” “He kind of spat, ”said Piggy. “My auntie wouldn’t let me blow on
account of my asthma.
"Jack was bent double"
Mod
Mod
"At last Ralph c..."
There's a ... lot of blowing in that book. XD
Mod
Actually, the part about the spears was supposed to be suggestive though. It was explained in the back of the copy I read. haha. Them killing the pigs is, like, symbolic of rape. I don't know why. O_o
Mod
Mod
Is Brigid dissing Lord of the Flies again? For shame. XD
Acacia wrote: "Is Brigid dissing Lord of the Flies again? For shame. XD"
I brought it up. Hehe. *hangs head in mock shame*
I brought it up. Hehe. *hangs head in mock shame*
"Got a ship in your pocket?” Simon grinned and shook his head."BAHAHAHA. When I was reading the book, my eyes went huge when I read that until I realized what Simon meant.
Mod
"Ship in your pocket". You know. Like, it's in your pants...and sticking out...if you catch my drift.
Mod
Mod
Oooh like an erection? (There's nothing wrong with being blunt, people. Embrace bluntness).
But then it wouldn't be in your pocket, would it? Pockets are on the sides. I'd be very alarmed if a guy's dick was on his side. That would be scary. O_O THAT EXPRESSION SUGGESTS THAT MEN'S PENISES ARE HANGING ON THE SIDE SOMEWHERE! GROSS!
Sorry. I was, ironically, somewhat censoring myself for the younger kids. XDDon't ask me, I don't have one.
HEY BAXTER!
EXPLAIN THIS TO US, POR FAVOR!
Mod
YOU DON'T? HOLY SHIT YOU LEARN SOMETHING KNEW EACH DAY. ;)
YES BAXTER EXPLAIN HOW MEN CAN HAVE PENISES ON THE SIDES OF THEIR LEGS!
The Writing Ninjas' Fan Club
Books mentioned in this topic
The Amber Spyglass (other topics)The Golden Compass (other topics)
The Subtle Knife (other topics)
Seriously, it's like, all I read anymore. Naked Lunch stands as a very interesting one to me with it's attempted censorship. Because that book was all sorts of messed up and disturbing and horrible to read and completely brilliant in every way. It was (I believe) to be the last major censorship trial in America over a book, effectively shattering them.
Still, even today I know plenty of people who wish that book was never published, because of its extreme nature. IS THERE A TOO FAR FOR YOU PERSONALLY!?!?!?!?