Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

Twilight vs Harry Potter > Seth vs Luna Lovegood

Comments Showing 1-50 of 140 (140 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Andy (new)


vs Seth... who doesn't have a picture.

message 2: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Seth! fo sho!

message 3: by Andy (new)

Andy Luna is the best--her and Malfoy!

message 4: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments nope EMMETT

message 5: by Andy (new)

Andy Emmett is not in this convo

message 6: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments he is if i am

message 7: by Andy (new)

Andy wow..

message 8: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments :)

message 9: by Andy (new)

Andy :(

message 10: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments (:)

message 11: by Andy (new)

Andy uhhhh

message 12: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments WHAT

message 13: by Andy (new)

Andy ya

message 14: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Again, ok then. I'd say Luna. But i don't think they'd fight in the first place. Since both are rather nice and consiterate. (spelling??)

message 15: by Andy (new)

Andy ya, but the point is that they are fighting. i say Seth would win, though i want Luna to.

message 16: by Suzie (new)

Suzie Conquest (MsConquest) | 10 comments Luna would win... she'd sic all the crazy invisible flying animals (name..???) on Seth :-)

message 17: by Andy (new)

Andy haha! that'd be awesome!

message 18: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Luna is awesome...but Seth is my favourite wolf. And Luna isn't that great with spells....

message 19: by Andy (new)

Andy blah!

message 20: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Yeah, I know!! I love both of them!! Sus, the invisible flying animals are Thestrals!!

message 21: by Andy (new)

Andy I think she meant Nargles, and Crumple Horned snorkacks.

message 22: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Oh yeah. That makes more sense actually!!

message 23: by Andy (new)

Andy yup...

message 24: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy yah, Nargles make your brain go all fuzzy, that would definitely help, and Luna would definitely win. she is just amazing.

message 25: by Andy (new)

Andy it's hard to say. Seth isn't a good fighter, but Luna would be all like "woah..... your a dog?" ....:P soooo its hard to say.

message 26: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Yeah. She'd be distracted by the dog thing and then look at him and ask: "Do you want some pudding?" and then Seth (like all werewolves who are always starving) would say: "Yeah, you know what? I'm too hungry to fight you." And then they'd be friends.

message 27: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy yah lol, even if they were pitted against each other in a battle ring, the two would find a way to be best friends! :P

message 28: by Andy (new)

Andy i could actually see that happening...

message 29: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Exactly. Pudding brings people together! :)

message 30: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy they'll just bunch up together in front of a fire and eat pudding while reading the Quibbler.

message 31: by Andy (new)

Andy then end up fighting for the sake of our argument.

message 32: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy mmm, well if they fought i would say Luna would win...because i don't know anything about the other guy other than he is a werewolf.

message 33: by Andy (new)

Andy there's not much else to know, except that he's ruthless, because he helped Edward kill Victoria, and Riley. Also, a werewolf would be very hard for Luna to kill.

message 34: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy not really i don't think.

message 35: by Andy (new)

Andy well it would.

message 36: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Yeah. All she has on her side is her strange way of thinking and belief in mythical creatures that don't exist.

Seth has been training. And if he has some trouble, he can always look to his friends for advice even if he wasn't anywhere near them. That's pretty cool.

message 37: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments agreed!

message 38: by Adam (new)

Adam  (adawg) | 116 comments um..... idk.... that ones kinda close

message 39: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Luna has had training, the DA.

message 40: by Jesah (new)

Jesah Yup.

message 41: by Andy (new)

Andy yes she has, but she's still not the greatest.

message 42: by Adam (new)

Adam  (adawg) | 116 comments i changed my mine..... LUNA!!!

message 43: by Jesah (new)

Jesah Thank you Adam!

message 44: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy weeeeeeeeee! LUNA!!

message 45: by Jesah (new)

Jesah Luna!

message 46: by Adam (new)

Adam  (adawg) | 116 comments LUNA IS SOOOOOOO AWESOME! i dont know what i was thinkinh when i said it was a tie..... :P Seth is just one of Jacob and Sams groupies..... PATHETIC

message 47: by Andy (new)

Andy but he's really strong and fast, and could rip luna before she thought of attacking.

message 48: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Seth is not pathetic actually!

message 49: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy but why would he want to attack her?

message 50: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Why not? Seth doesn't know much about her. He could think she's a threat. And then she'd be dead.

« previous 1 3
back to top