YA Fanatics discussion

36 views
books that had shameful movie adaptions

Comments Showing 1-50 of 107 (107 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Ruby (new)

Ruby Paslidis | 30 comments Mod
For e.g THE MORTAL INSTRUMENTS


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

percy jackson


message 3: by Lucinda (new)

Lucinda | 45 comments Mod
Definitely Percy Jackson and The Mortal Instruments


message 4: by Annabelle (new)

Annabelle King | 23 comments Lily wrote: "percy jackson"

The Percy Jackson movie was the worst.


message 5: by Ellie (last edited Apr 28, 2015 06:09PM) (new)

Ellie Annabelle wrote: "Lily wrote: "percy jackson"

The Percy Jackson movie was the worst."


I was surprised when they said they were making a second movie! But I think re-creating a world like that from the books would be very hard in the first place.


message 6: by Alexandra (new)

Alexandra (xandi) | 20 comments Ellie wrote: "Annabelle wrote: "Lily wrote: "percy jackson"

The Percy Jackson movie was the worst."

I was surprised when they said they were making a second movie! But I think re-creating a world like that from the books would be very had in the first place..."


It would be hard, but not impossible. You may have to leave some stuff out, but I mean, things happened in the second movie that literally can not happen. It's what makes the whole 5th book in the series.


message 7: by Abi (new)

Abi (booksa144) The Percy Jackson movies are complete and total Crap.


Just Another Bookish Blog (justanotherbookishblog) | 81 comments Percy Jackson, they were awful
*cough* Insurgent *cough* the movie was fine itself, just not compared to el book

and last but not least

Eragon

THE MOVIE WAS ABSOLUTELY AWFUL! =(


message 9: by Abi (last edited May 13, 2015 11:41AM) (new)

Abi (booksa144) Annabelle wrote: "Lily wrote: "percy jackson"

The Percy Jackson movie was the worst."


Yes! Totally! Major things wrong: 1st Movie: Annabeth has blond hair, Percy gets a glowing sign over his head in capture-the-flag.
2nd Movie: SO many things wrong! KRONOS DOES NOT COME BACK UNTIL THE 4th BOOK PEOPLE!
:) Sorry, I rant about these things - Rick Riordan's Percy Jackson and Heroes of Olympus are my favorite books ever! (But the Kane Chronicles are awesome too!)


message 10: by [deleted user] (new)

Abi wrote: "Annabelle wrote: "Lily wrote: "percy jackson"

The Percy Jackson movie was the worst."

Yes! Totally! Major things wrong: 1st Movie: Annabeth has blond hair, Percy gets a glowing sign over his hea..."

oh my god the Kronos thing annoyed the hell out of me.


message 11: by Alexandra (new)

Alexandra (xandi) | 20 comments Yes! Okay, after my dad saw the movie, at the end Luke wakes up in the Cyclopes' cave/lair thing and my dad said, "Well, he's not coming back." He's Luke! He has to come back or else there's no point to anything. Also, I feel like there was a poor attempt to make Kronos seem sooo scary when he was a big, fiery monster. It shouldn't (and wasn't) so simple to stop Kronos, just cutting him up and putting him back into the sarcophagus.


Just Another Bookish Blog (justanotherbookishblog) | 81 comments There were just so many things wrong with the movies /:

Also, no one mentioned that they are all 16 instead of 12, there's no Clarisse, Capture the Flag was messed up, the casino was weird, and there were no pearls to get out of the underworld. That amongst other things.

And thats just for the first movie *sigh*


message 13: by Jet13 (new)

Jet13 | 96 comments I think that the percy jackson and the sea of monsters movie was good. But i haven't seen the first one


message 14: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments *Going back to the Eragon movie here* It was SOOOOOOOO different!!!


Just Another Bookish Blog (justanotherbookishblog) | 81 comments IKR!!! Really disappointing /: BUT people are signing a petition to make a new one! AND AND AND... A 5TH BOOK IS BEING WRITTEN! :D


message 16: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments Wait WHAT?!?!? Woah!


Just Another Bookish Blog (justanotherbookishblog) | 81 comments SO EXCITEDDDD! :D


message 18: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments X3333


message 19: by Rabecka (new)

Rabecka (mrtickles) Divergent and Insurgent were horrible. Not in general just compared to the books.


message 20: by Phoenix2 (new)

Phoenix2 Eragon is definatelly one of the worst book adaptions, ruined the whole thing! The Hobbit movies weren't that good either.


Just Another Bookish Blog (justanotherbookishblog) | 81 comments Eragon was absolutely awful! :(


message 22: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments I remember watching it and saying that it was SO wrong. I think there was something to do with how Eragon met Murtagh(I think that's his name, it's been a long time.) and other stuff.


message 23: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments Eragon and Percy Jackson movies but Chris Columbus said he`s redoing them and making both 2 series.


message 24: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments Caroline (JustAnotherBookishBlog) wrote: "SO EXCITEDDDD! :D"

i know me too.:]


message 25: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments Really? REALLY?


message 26: by Gabi (new)

Gabi Benevides (gabibenevides) I don't know how I feel about all these tv shows of my fav books... they never really follow the plot (pretty little liars and got are a great example of it)

so I just stop myself from being excited hahaha


message 27: by Gabi (new)

Gabi Benevides (gabibenevides) I don't know how I feel about all these tv shows of my fav books... they never really follow the plot (pretty little liars and got are a great example of it)

so I just stop myself from being excited hahaha


message 28: by Gabi (new)

Gabi Benevides (gabibenevides) I don't know how I feel about all these tv shows of my fav books... they never really follow the plot (pretty little liars and got are a great example of it)

so I just stop myself from being excited hahaha


message 29: by Gabi (new)

Gabi Benevides (gabibenevides) my phone posts some comments 2 or 3 times, that's so annoying... sorry about that :)


message 30: by Jet13 (new)

Jet13 | 96 comments seventh son aka the spooks apprentice(the book version by joseph delaney)


message 31: by Phoenix2 (new)

Phoenix2 beautiful creatures and vampire accademy weren't that good either


message 32: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments Kaala wrote: "Really? REALLY?"
ha ha. yes really


message 33: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments Cool! They better be good.


message 34: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments The Divergent movie was pretty good! But Insurgent was aweful!! I went back to the Theatre +5 times to see Divergent but practically dreaded going back to see Insurgent! Neil was a way better director, he didn't change like anything from Roths book unlike the producer of insurgent. I was so confused after watching Insurgent like, how could I miss all that in the book? Then, I could finally breath again when I saw that everyone else was pissed off too. (atleast the people who read the books)


message 35: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments Kaala wrote: "Cool! They better be good."
i bet you a million dollars they`ll be good. theirs no doubt. Chris is a great director.


message 36: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments Desiree wrote: "The Divergent movie was pretty good! But Insurgent was aweful!! I went back to the Theatre +5 times to see Divergent but practically dreaded going back to see Insurgent! Neil was a way better direc..."

true. it was nothing like the book. the book was way better.


message 37: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments It was kind of funny how mad the fandom got though XD


message 38: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments yeah


message 39: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments it`s nice to see that for once someone reply`s a minute later. usually the group reply's a day later.


message 40: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments The struggle is real


message 41: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments ya think


message 42: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments Maybe everyone else has social lives?


message 43: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments yes but we all live in different countries. that is a disadvantage.


message 44: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments for an Caroline lives in Australia i live in new york .


message 45: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments Oh yeah I guess thats an important factor too. Your so lucky you live in NY. I'm canadian :/


message 46: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Zavala (Brandizavala3) | 98 comments cool my cousins live in Ontario, Canada


message 47: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments Coool I'm a Albertan


Just Another Bookish Blog (justanotherbookishblog) | 81 comments Brandi wrote: "for an Caroline lives in Australia i live in new york ."

I don't live in Australia o_o! I'd like to though XD


message 49: by Des (new)

Des (desrachelle) | 26 comments Loool


message 50: by Kaala (new)

Kaala Silvermoon | 134 comments You can still reply quickly if you're on at the right time XD


« previous 1 3
back to top