SOLVED. YA Romance. I believe it was called Love at First Sight, author unknown. It is about a shy girl and a high school jock falling in love at first sight. Read 1990-1997.

[Ric]

Read it between 1990 and 1997. But it was in the library so I can’t remember the actual publication year. It had dram in terms of mean girls. No other details except it was a sweet romance.

[Becca]

Love at First Sight by Elaine Harper? This one sounds the most likely, but if not:
Love at First Sight by Ann Reit?
At First Sight by Elizabeth Chandler?

[Karen]

Was it from the Sweet Dreams series?

First Love by Debra Spector
First Summer Love by Stephanie Foster

seem to be the best fit in terms of title. I have not read either so I don't know if the plot is a match.

[Kaitlynn]

I agree with the Love at First Sight by Elain Harper. It was written in 1981 but is the 14th book in the series

[Ric]

It is Love at first sight by Elain Harper!! Thank you all!! I just couldn’t get it out of my head!! Now I have to go find a copy!!

[Becca]

Glad to help!