Question I

[Jonetta]

Andy Talbot was Max’s first boyfriend and lover but they separated over her support of Kevin. He was friendly at first but turned a bit nasty later. We know he believed he was protecting William but was that enough to justify what he did to Max? Your thoughts about him and whether he really still cares for her?

[Robin]

I didn't like this guy. He (like Beck) treated Max like trash because she believed Kevin. Then it turns out he set up Kevin to take the fall. I started wondering if he believed (or knew) that Caitlyn killed Lindy.

I don't think he cares for Max at all.

[Sharon]

I don't like Andy and I don't see what Max liked about him. He never had her best interest at heart. The only reason he wanted her was to keep an eye on Max and protect William. He is another one who should have come forward with what he knew to get out all the facts.

[Jonetta]

Andy was Max’s high school first and it should have ended there. I think women tend to romanticize their first love, especially their first lover, and that’s what Max was doing. Then he showed his true colors. He might have had feelings for her as a teen but that’s ended.

He went to extraordinary lengths to protect his friend, William, even breaking the law. I agree that he was only sidling up to Max to find out what she knew and to keep tabs on her.

This man is dangerous and I hope he spends some time behind bars, too.

[Melissa]

Andy is definitely a piece of work. He treated her like dirt probably because he knows she's good at what she does and he didn't want the truth to come out.

[Anita]

I agree with Melissa: Andy was a piece of work. What he did to Max, following her, having her assaulted, was despicable. He should have known that she wouldn't give up until she had the truth, the whole truth.

[Jonetta]

Which is why he did all those things to her. He only stopped a couple of steps from seriously hurting her.