Fantasy Romance discussion

Romance > My Sister's Keeper

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
I guess this book would fall under romance. Anyway, this discussion is for people who want to discuss My Sister's Keeper by Jodi Picoult.

message 2: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
The book was so sad!! The mother was sooooo annoying though. I got the impression that she didn't really care about Anna until she died, that she only wanted Anna there for the things she could do for Kate.

message 3: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
I know! It was like, "Oh my God, Kate, your bleeding! Anna, give her your blood!"

message 4: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (last edited Aug 27, 2009 09:40AM) (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
The dad was a liar. But I liked Isobel's general attitude, like the phone number and such. It was kind of funny.

message 5: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) this is not a romance book.
i read it and loved it.
i think that Anna did not have to give her blood. DID YOU GET THE WHOLE THING WITH HER BEING BORN JUST TO SERVE AS A BLOOD SENDER AWAYER?????!!!!!!

message 6: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
Actually, it kind of is a romance book because of the subplot between the attorney and the GAL. And shelby, what we were saying is that IF Kate lost some blood, the mom would probably freak and take Anna's blood.

message 7: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod

message 8: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) if i wuz kate i would kill my mom b4 she could get 2 mi!

message 9: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) i now. she wuz sooooooooo mad at her she went to court!

message 10: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
she didn't let Anna do anything, like hockey camp and stuff

message 11: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
lol cause then they would take more than they need

message 12: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) i hated her mom. she should have died

message 13: by Shirin (new)

Shirin (shirin2009) | 204 comments i'm just about to start reading this i don't visit this topic anymore till i finish it.

message 14: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod

message 15: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) HAVE FUN!

message 16: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
yeah, she would die for Anna

message 17: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
kate wanted her to do it

message 18: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
Shirin said I could delete cause it seemed that nobody except her had read it.

message 19: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) i like my sisters keeper. i luved it

message 20: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
I can't believe Anna died. It was so unexpected.

message 21: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) but it made the book good

message 22: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) well would it be as good if she lived? it ties all the tragetly in the book!

message 23: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
it could be as good

message 24: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
short term would have been better for her convenience, but I think long term would have been more interesting.

message 25: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) i think it wuz good the way it wuz made. it puts her out of her misery and lets her sleep in peace.

message 26: by ♫♪Kristenn҉, So... (new)

♫♪Kristenn҉ (9533808008) | 351 comments Mod
Memory loss wouldn't be too bad.

message 27: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) it would not be the same though. her parents the way they still took her kidney and how kate felt about it!

message 28: by Shelby (new)

Shelby (shelby1211) IT IS THE TWIST UV DA BOOK!!!!!!!!!!!!

back to top