Hooray for Books and Reading discussion
The Spark
>
3. Main Message
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Chelsea
(new)
Mar 25, 2018 03:43PM

reply
|
flag
*

Having said that, though, I took away from this book that we should never give up on children and that "experts" don't always know what they're talking about. "Experts" in the past have pushed everything from blood-letting to lobotomies, so that ought to tell us something!
I took from this book the idea that so much is possible with kids that are able to perform and learn new behaviors that are seen as acceptable. She had learned methods that had worked with her students, and was very successful. I again was in awe at her tremendous methods that she was able to use. I didn't get the feeling that any of her methods were caused with pain. As Cindy has said, "I took away from this book that we should never give up on children and that "experts" don't always know what they're talking about. "Experts" in the past have pushed everything from blood-letting to lobotomies, so that ought to tell us something! "
I've thought the same thing Cindy, in that learning how their outcome was would be. From what was written, the success was phenomenal and do all the kids and patients have such similar and amazing results. Would like to know how they all did and did all of them do so well.


"Her son is extremely rare, and parents need to be extremely careful before pulling kids out of therapy. I don't think the vast majority will have the success she did, simply because their kids are not savants and most parents are not willing to or capable of going to the lengths she did. Yes, absolutely listen to your gut and your mother's intuition, but do it in partnership with the experts (like she did with her friend). I do think her focus on kids' strengths was good, because discouragement is good for nobody, and it makes so much sense to teach kids in ways they'll be best able to understand. Unfortunately, this is really only possible with extremely small class sizes or individualized help, so it's not hard to see why it's difficult to get kids who need it this sort of help."


Going on - what works for me, might not work for you. Tagging into Angela's as well. These are not fool proof, but it is impressive that the results are so great with what they have. Pretty cool.
Note to Ruth: Feel free to chime in here. I've been thinking a lot of you and as a parent your challenges. We have Barb, Chelsea, Susan, and Amy as teachers in our group and have heard some of their points, Angela as a sister. Wouldn't mind hearing from Ruth if you feel prompted and/or inspired. Thanks - CJC