YA Book Addicts discussion
Discussions & Debates
>
Books You Hated
message 1:
by
Jordyn, Organizer Lieutenant
(new)
Jul 24, 2014 04:39PM

reply
|
flag
*




I enjoyed Crossed actually! But i do agree there wasn't really an exact plot to it. I thought I loved all the poetry though(: I think the Matched was somewhat boring

I was bored to death by Robinson Crusoe, but I had to read it since it was assigned school reading and I was a good kid and didn't slack and look for the shortened explanation on the internet.


I don't know why I bothered to read it





Ruby- I agree that the characters were boring. I think iv there were better, more exciting characters it would be a better series.

Sara wrote: "I couldnt even finish Gone because I thought it was so bad. Also, I'm not a big fan of The Fault in Our Stars (it's my opinion ok!!), I feel like I cant differenciate most of John Green's character..."
Yeah, I wasn't really impressed with TFIOS either. It was well-written and stuff, but it wasn't anything special and I felt like John Green mainly wrote it as a tearjerker. And, I mean, what makes the ladies cry more than dying cancer kids?
And yeah, I feel like he keeps using the same characters from Looking For Alaska again and again - even for his short stories. TFIOS is his only book without those characters, but Hazel and Augustus still seem similar... too similar...
Yeah, I wasn't really impressed with TFIOS either. It was well-written and stuff, but it wasn't anything special and I felt like John Green mainly wrote it as a tearjerker. And, I mean, what makes the ladies cry more than dying cancer kids?
And yeah, I feel like he keeps using the same characters from Looking For Alaska again and again - even for his short stories. TFIOS is his only book without those characters, but Hazel and Augustus still seem similar... too similar...

Sara wrote: "Exactly! Sometimes in his books I honestly feel like a bunch of John Greens are having conversations with each other, but they all have that "quirk" to try and make them distinct."
Yep! And most of the time, the dialogue seems too unrealistic. I mean, if you're going to write YA contemporary, at least make the teenagers talk like teenagers. I feel like he puts them in awfully convenient situations so he can justify their intelligence, but it just doesn't work. I see twenty-year-old college kids talk online all the time, and not even they talk like that.
Yep! And most of the time, the dialogue seems too unrealistic. I mean, if you're going to write YA contemporary, at least make the teenagers talk like teenagers. I feel like he puts them in awfully convenient situations so he can justify their intelligence, but it just doesn't work. I see twenty-year-old college kids talk online all the time, and not even they talk like that.


I'm a 35 year old with an advanced degree and even I don't talk like that!! lol Ok, well, my husband and I are kind of pretentious, so sometimes we do, but not all the time!!
I agree about John Green's characters. I loved TFIOS and I enjoy his other books, but his characters are all sooo similar.

@Jessica and Connie - Yeah. I actually did like some of his characters; I liked Alaska a bit and Isaac, but there is always another character that's exactly like them. It gives off the impression that John Green is an incredibly lazy writer - which I'm sure he isn't - and kind of distracts you from the book. Instead of immersing myself in the story I'm reading, I find myself going "Oh, that's Alaska, that's Pudge, there's that well-known road-trip, and - oh look! Another Venn diagram!"
Sara wrote: "I guess that he's trying to show teenagers aren't stupid, but it all seems a bit too pretentious to me. And really, really annoying."
Exactly.
Exactly.

Less bad, but still unlikeable: City of Fallen Angels, City of Lost Souls, Eleanor and Park (couldn't stand the whining)
Too Boring: Matched!
You hated the mortal instruments


The only time in recent memory I have disliked something more was the second book in The Selection series which I did ultimately abandon. I ended up reading the plot online so I could fulfill my weird need to finish the story and save myself from America's waffling at the same time. It got to a point where I no longer cared what decision she made as long as she could make one.

I did something similar to what you did with The Selection series, but with the Shatter Me trilogy. I liked the first book, but the second one was going too slow for me, and I was getting bored of the main character's voice. So I went and looked up what happened.
Ruby Red by Kerstin Gier
It's time travel, something that I love. And it's in the UK! How could I not like it?
Sadly, it was awful. The main character Gwen was extremely annoying and the plot was soooo unoriginal. I mean, the most important people in a certain group are named after gems? Never heard that before...
It's time travel, something that I love. And it's in the UK! How could I not like it?
Sadly, it was awful. The main character Gwen was extremely annoying and the plot was soooo unoriginal. I mean, the most important people in a certain group are named after gems? Never heard that before...


This book beats all of your other books! try a girl who is kidnapped from an airport by a drugged coffee (sounds interesting right?..well its not!) turns out she's kidnapped cause the stranger who kidnapped her is in love with her and wants to marry her!..she tries to get away for a while then instead ends up falling in love with him and gets super depressed when she's rescued!..sorry im ranting but this book was awful!! and just plain weird

To all twilight fans do not see the spoiler
(view spoiler)
You people might hate me for this but what can I say. *shrugs* I did not like twilight.["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>


Lol well it worked for me!
I also really hated Before I fall and didn't even finish because the main character sucked so much. Same with The Girl of Fire and Thorns.
Oh I had to stop that book too I couldn't even finish it

Before I Fall was horrible.
I think the girl of fire and thorns was the one I couldn't finish
I actually like Before I Fall I thought it was pretty cool..
I thought before I fall was just okay
Books mentioned in this topic
Robinson Crusoe (other topics)The Catcher in the Rye (other topics)
A River Runs Through it and Other Stories (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
City of Bones (other topics)
More...