Polls for Our Souls discussion

117 views
Book Chat > Overrated book that is really bad vs a really good book that deserves its rating

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

missyfabioulous | 19 comments Overrated: Red Queen series -avg. rating 4.03

Good book: mistborn trilogy -avg. rating 4.41


Emily Just Emily*~* | 52 comments Overrated: (this is when I anger people) The Hunger Games

Good Book: .....everything on my bookshelf that other people look at like "whoa. really?"


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Overrated - (Agreed on) The Hungry Games & Temptation

Good book - Fire (2nd book to the graceling series) & The 5th Waves Series


Emily Just Emily*~* | 52 comments Yes, I am not alone!


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

☻LOL☺


missyfabioulous | 19 comments ♥Fire♥ wrote: "Overrated - (Agreed on) The Hungry Games & Temptation

Good book - Fire (2nd book to the graceling series) & The 5th Waves Series"


yass I love the Graceling series!!! mainly the first two books ;)


missyfabioulous | 19 comments ♥Fire♥ wrote: "Overrated - (Agreed on) The Hungry Games & Temptation

Good book - Fire (2nd book to the graceling series) & The 5th Waves Series"


"The Hungry Games" lol


Emily Just Emily*~* | 52 comments We call them the "hangry games" in our house.
Fire I think you had asked me a question in your friend request but I clicked everything too fast, I'm sorry.


message 9: by Ash (new)

Ash | 30 comments Then Night Circus (DESPISE)
Rating 4.03

vs.

Three Dark Crowns (LOVE)
Rating 3.85


Emily Just Emily*~* | 52 comments oh sad, the Night Circus is one of my favorite books:( To each his own though!


message 11: by annesofie (new)

annesofie (ananasofie) | 204 comments overrated - all the bright places. 4.20

deserved - all the light we cannot see :) 4.31


message 12: by Halima (new)

Halima (hallythemartian) | 20 comments I absolutely hate Everything Everything (4.11) and Thirteen Reasons Why (4.04).

On the other hand, I love Eleanor & Park (4.12) so much and it deserves that rating.


message 13: by Mel (new)

Mel | 8 comments Overrated: Little Women (4.03), The Perks of Being a Wallflower (4.21)

Deserved: We Are Okay (4.02), Mystic River (4.19)


message 14: by Erica (last edited May 18, 2017 03:56AM) (new)

Erica | 28 comments Overrated: Perks of Being a Wallflower (4.21)

Deserved: Six of Crows (4.46) and Crooked Kingdom (4.63)


Emily Just Emily*~* | 52 comments Mel wrote: "Overrated: Little Women (4.03), The Perks of Being a Wallflower (4.21)

Deserved: We Are Okay (4.02), Mystic River (4.19)"


Mystic River was one of my favorite reads from this year. Rock on.


message 16: by Louise (new)

Louise | 101 comments Overrated :Heartless rating 4.08
Vs

Deserved: A Court of Mist and Fury rating 4.73


message 17: by K. (last edited May 18, 2017 09:41AM) (new)

K. (keiiksm) Louise wrote: "Overrated :Heartless rating 4.08
Vs

Deserved: A Court of Mist and Fury rating 4.73"


Agree with the overrated one. <3

Overrated: The Problem with Forever (4.01)
Amy & Roger's Epic Detour (4.05)
Don't Let Me Go (4.11)

Deserved: Six of Crows Duology
Salt to the Sea (4.37)
The Serpent King (4.22)
We Are the Ants (4.24)
The Song of Achilles (4.26)


message 18: by Superbambi (new)

Superbambi | 285 comments Erica wrote: "Overrated: Perks of Being a Wallflower (4.21)

Deserved: Six of Crows (4.46) and Crooked Kingdom (4.63)"


Aw no, I loved that book.

Overrated: And then there were none, by Agatha Christie (4,23)

Deserved: Diary, by Anne Frank (4,10)
Noah, by Sebastian Fitzek (4,04)
The lies of Locke Lamora (4,30)
A Woman in Berlin: Eight weeks in the conquered city: a diary, by Anonymous (4,30)


message 19: by Louise (new)

Louise | 101 comments Taylor wrote: "Overrated: Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children
Deserved: A Court of Mist and Fury"


I so agree with you


message 20: by annesofie (new)

annesofie (ananasofie) | 204 comments Overrated: All the Bright Places (4.20), The Perks of Being a Wallflower (4.21)

Deserved: All the Light We Cannot See (4.31), I'll Give You the Sun (4.14), Harry Potter (4.44), The Little Prince (4.28)


message 21: by annesofie (new)

annesofie (ananasofie) | 204 comments the perks wasn't necessarily bad it was just sooo underwhelming to me


message 22: by [deleted user] (new)

I think the outlander books are ocerrated. They are so slow, and often boring in my opinion.


back to top