Around the World in 80 Books discussion

Cutting for Stone
This topic is about Cutting for Stone
166 views
Group Reads Discussions > Discussion for Cutting for Stone

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Diane, Armchair Tour Guide (new) - rated it 5 stars

Diane | 12805 comments Start discussion here for Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese.


message 2: by Diane, Armchair Tour Guide (new) - rated it 5 stars

Diane | 12805 comments From Readinggroupguides.com:

An epic novel that spans continents and generations, Cutting for Stone is an unforgettable story of love and betrayal, compassion and redemption, exile and home that unfolds across five decades in India, Ethiopia, and America.

Narrated by Marion Stone, the story begins even before Marion and his twin brother, Shiva, are born in Addis Ababa’s Missing Hospital (a mispronunciation of “Mission Hospital”), with the illicit, years-in-the-making romance between their parents, Sister Mary Joseph Praise, a beautiful Indian nun, and Thomas Stone, a brash, brilliant British surgeon. Mary and Thomas meet on a boat out of Madras in 1947; she follows him to Ethiopia and to Missing, where they work side by side for seven years as nurse and doctor. After Mary dies while giving birth to the twins --- a harrowing, traumatic scene on the operating table --- Thomas vanishes, and Marion and Shiva grow up with only a dim sense of who he was, and with a deep hostility toward him for what they see as an act of betrayal and cowardice.

The twins are raised by Hema and Ghosh, two Indian doctors who also work at Missing, and who shower Marion and Shiva with love and nurture their interest in medicine --- part of the deep, almost preternatural connection the brothers share. They are so close that Marion, as a boy, thinks of them as a single entity: ShivaMarion.

Marion and Shiva come of age as Ethiopia hovers on the brink of revolution, and their lives become intertwined with the nation’s politics. Addis Ababa is a colorful, cosmopolitan city: the Italians have left behind cappuccino machines, Campari umbrellas, and a vibrant expat community. But they've also left a nation crippled by poverty, hunger, and authoritarian rule: Ethiopia in the 1960s and 1970s is both bolstered and trapped by its notorious emperor, Haile Selassie, and rocked by violence and civil war.

Yet it is not politics but love that tears the brothers apart: Shiva sleeps with Genet --- the daughter of their housekeeper and the girl Marion has always loved. This second betrayal, now by the two people this sensitive young man loves most, sends Marion into a deep depression. And when Genet joins a radical political group fighting for the independence of Eritrea, Marion’s connection to her forces him into exile: he sneaks out of Ethiopia and makes his way to America.

Marion interns at a hospital in the Bronx, an underfunded, chaotic place where the patients are nearly as poor and desperate as those he had seen at Missing. It is here that Marion comes to maturity as a doctor and as a man. It is here, too, that he meets his father and takes his first steps toward reconciling with him. But when the past catches up to Marion --- nearly destroying him --- he must entrust his life to the two men he thought he trusted least in the world: the father who abandoned him and the brother who betrayed him. The surprising, stunning denouement both arises from and reenacts the major themes of Cutting for Stone: love and betrayal, forgiveness and self-sacrifice, and the inextricable union of life and death.

In Cutting for Stone, renowned physician Abraham Verghese has given us a remarkable reading experience that explores the lives of a memorable cast of characters, many of them doctors; the insight the novel offers into the world of medicine, along with its wealth of precise detail about how doctors work, is unparalleled in American fiction. Verghese is so attuned to the movements of the heart and of the mind, so adept at dramatizing the great themes of human existence, and he has filled this world with such richly drawn, fascinating characters, that Cutting for Stone becomes one of those rare books one wishes would never end, an alternate reality that both rivals and illuminates the real world readers must return to when the book is closed.

Discussion Questions:

1. Abraham Verghese has said that his ambition in writing Cutting for Stone was to “tell a great story, an old-fashioned, truth-telling story.” In what ways is Cutting for Stone an old-fashioned story --- and what does it share with the great novels of the nineteenth century? What essential human truths does it convey?

2. What does Cutting for Stone reveal about the emotional lives of doctors? Contrast the attitudes of Hema, Ghosh, Marion, Shiva, and Thomas Stone toward their work. What draws each of them to the practice of medicine? How are they affected, emotionally and otherwise, by the work they do?

3. Marion observes that in Ethiopia, patients assume that all illnesses are fatal and that death is expected, but in America, news of having a fatal illness “always seemed to come as a surprise, as if we took it for granted that we were immortal” (p. 396). What other important differences does Cutting for Stone reveal about the way illness is viewed and treated in Ethiopia and in the United States? To what extent are these differences reflected in the split between poor hospitals, like the one in the Bronx where Marion works, and rich hospitals like the one in Boston where his father works?

4. In the novel, Thomas Stone asks, “What treatment in an emergency is administered by ear?” The correct answer is “Words of comfort.” How does this moment encapsulate the book’s surprising take on medicine? Have your experiences with doctors and hospitals held this to be true? Why or why not? What does Cutting for Stone tell us about the roles of compassion, faith, and hope in medicine?

5. There are a number of dramatic scenes on operating tables in Cutting for Stone: the twins’ births, Thomas Stone amputating his own finger, Ghosh untwisting Colonel Mebratu’s volvulus, the liver transplant, etc. How does Verghese use medical detail to create tension and surprise? What do his depictions of dramatic surgeries share with film and television hospital dramas --- and yet how are they different?

6. Marion suffers a series of painful betrayals --- by his father, by Shiva, and by Genet. To what degree is he able, by the end of the novel, to forgive them?

7. To what extent does the story of Thomas Stone’s childhood soften Marion’s judgment of him? How does Thomas’s suffering as a child, the illness of his parents, and his own illness help to explain why he abandons Shiva and Marion at their birth? How should Thomas finally be judged?

8. In what important ways does Marion come to resemble his father, although he grows up without him? How does Marion grow and change over the course of the novel?

9. A passionate, unique love affair sets Cutting for Stone in motion, and yet this romance remains a mystery --- even to the key players --- until the very conclusion of the novel. How does the relationship between Sister Mary Joseph Praise and Thomas Stone affect the lives of Shiva and Marion, Hema and Ghosh, Matron and everyone else at Missing? What do you think Verghese is trying to say about the nature of love and loss?

10. What do Hema, Matron, Rosina, Sister Mary Joseph Praise, Genet, and Tsige --- as well as the many women who come to Missing seeking medical treatment --- reveal about what life is like for women in Ethiopia?

11. Addis Ababa is at once a cosmopolitan city thrumming with life and the center of a dictatorship rife with conflict. How do the influences of Ethiopia’s various rulers --- England, Italy, Emperor Selassie --- reveal themselves in day-to-day life? How does growing up there affect Marion’s and Shiva’s worldviews?

12. As Ghosh nears death, Marion comments that the man who raised him had no worries or regrets, that “there was no restitution he needed to make, no moment he failed to seize” (p. 346). What is the key to Ghosh’s contentment? What makes him such a good father, doctor, and teacher? What wisdom does he impart to Marion?

13. Although it’s also a play on the surname of the characters, the title Cutting for Stone comes from a line in the Hippocratic Oath: “I will not cut for stone, even for patients in whom the disease is manifest; I will leave this operation to be performed by practitioners, specialists in this art.” Verghese has said that this line comes from ancient times, when bladder stones were epidemic and painful: “There were itinerant stone cutters --- lithologists --- who could cut into either the bladder or the perineum and get the stone out, but because they cleaned the knife by wiping their blood-stiffened surgical aprons, patients usually died of infection the next day.” How does this line resonate for the doctors in the novel?

14. Almost all of the characters in Cutting for Stone are living in some sort of exile, self-imposed or forced, from their home country --- Hema and Ghosh from India, Marion from Ethiopia, Thomas from India and then Ethiopia. Verghese is of Indian descent but was born and raised in Ethiopia, went to medical school in India, and has lived and worked in the United States for many years. What do you think this novel says about exile and the immigrant experience? How does exile change these characters, and what do they find themselves missing the most about home?


message 3: by Diane, Armchair Tour Guide (new) - rated it 5 stars

Diane | 12805 comments Love this book! So glad to be finally reading it.


Mmars | 77 comments I read this not long ago and look forward to your comments and the opportunity to discuss it.


Jennifer | 109 comments Just getting started, but already loving the writing!


Allyson If you love this book, I just read "My Own Country" which is about his experiences immigrating to the US and his experience in treating AIDS in Tennessee before anyone knew much about it. It is very well written and another one that is hard to put down.

My favourite character in this book had to be Ghosh. I just smiled whenever he spoke. Perhaps, it was the narrators interpretation of his voice, but what a loveable character.

I found this book to resonate with me from the aspect of being an expat, living out of your home country. I am American, but due to my husband's job, we have lived all over the world for most of our adult lives. However, our moves have usually been by choice and assisted by my husband's company. I can't imagine arriving in a brand new country, completely on my own, especially if it's because I am being forced to leave my home country. I loved hearing an immigrant's perspective of his arrival in the US, even if some of his experiences were negative.

I think I could read this book a thousand times, yet still find something new to love. I have to say my favourite passage from the book is the story about owning your slippers, your family, your weaknesses. An important, but difficult lesson.


Anny | 97 comments For sure, without Ghosh and Hema vivacious antics the book would've been very dark and gloomy indeed! Thomas Stone had little or non-existent personality and Sister Mary barely had a line spoken in the whole book.


Sarah | 662 comments Not much discussion yet, but I though I would check in to see everyone's thoughts. Read the book a couple years ago. Great book. I am a nurse and enjoyed the health care aspect of it as well as the story. It was recommended to me by a doctor I work with. I have loaned out this book and still have not gotten it back. I want it back so I can loan it to more of my colleagues at work:-)


Mmars | 77 comments I was particularly impressed by how understandable he made surgical procedures and human anatomy. As a lay person I really appreciated that.

I remembered little of Ethiopian history and needed to research it. I didn't know that Italy had taken it over. Also didn't know that Haile Selassie had been revered in the Rastafarian movement and that he'd been quite a good emperor in his early years. Unfortunately his reign after Italy was kicked out ended in corruption and the usual military muck (sigh) that too often seems to come to long reigns in small country. Power corrupts.


Debby Smith | 59 comments Allyson wrote: "If you love this book, I just read "My Own Country" which is about his experiences immigrating to the US and his experience in treating AIDS in Tennessee before anyone knew much about it. It is ve..."

I appreciate your points. "My Own Country" is so different and yet riveting in its own way.
The complexity of "Cutting for Stone" is exciting. I felt that the flavors of the setting in Ethiopia were excellent. I have not been to Ethiopia, but from my other African experiences, I sensed that the descriptions rang true.


Angie Reisetter | 115 comments This novel is so huge, and there's so much to discuss! I want to respond to the question about it being an old-fashioned story, though. It actually did feel old-fashioined for me. The narration was detached, somehow, not trying to paint a picture or emote, but just telling a story. While it took detours to other characters, it always returned to Marion, sticking to his story from birth to his career in Ethiopia. And it had an over-arching theme, I thought, of forgiveness. Betrayal and forgiveness, but also forgiveness of events that perhaps were not exactly betrayal. And not just for Marion. Hema has to forgive Stone, something that seems impossible at the beginning. Genet has to forgive Rosina and her father. And yes, Marion has a lot of forgiving to do. So I guess it's this big, overarching theme and the style of the storytelling that made it feel old-fashioned to me.


message 12: by Mj (last edited May 26, 2014 10:41AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mj | 22 comments I read this book in 2011 after a long hold at the library. I can't make a lot of comments on the discussion questions as my memory of specifics has left me. What I do remember is how lyrical I thought the writing was, how much I enjoyed the character development and the plot development (it isn't all that often that both are done so well in the same book) and I learned a lot about medical techniques and what was surprising to me was how much I enjoyed that aspect of the book even though I am not in a field even closely related to medical.

I have recommended the book to many, many people and frequently encourage readers on GR to keep going (in other discussion groups, I've noticed that around the 300-400 page mark people sometimes want to abandon the book.) I reiterate how well everything comes together and how much I enjoyed it. I gave the book a 5 star rating. I tried to provide a link to my review if anyone was interested but couldn't figure out how to do it.

I will follow the discussion and see if anything jogs my memory that I can add to.


Zaide Williams (zaidewilliams) | 3 comments This was a book that has stayed with me long after I put it down. Gorgeous writing, and plot and imagery that almost borders on magical realism. Everything fresh, unique, and affecting. High, high on my list.


Jennifer | 109 comments Just finished - what an amazing book. Loved the characters and the story.


message 15: by Diane, Armchair Tour Guide (new) - rated it 5 stars

Diane | 12805 comments I am so glad I finally read it. It has been on my tbr list since it came out. Absolutely wonderful.I hated for it to end.


Alana (alanasbooks) | 101 comments I read Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide earlier this year and it goes into great depth about the enormous need for help with fistulas in the developing world, particularly in Africa, so I was very attuned when Shiva began being interested in that aspect of medicine.

I was curious what the historical truths of those medical advances were: obviously the author is a physician so he knows his stuff: I became curious as to who really DID do the first successful liver transplant, etc, as that is an important aspect of the novel.

Yes, the themes seemed to be focused on forgiveness, growing into oneself, learning about the world beyond your sphere, friendship, betrayal, etc. There are so many layers of depth to all of those in this book that it's hard to really summarize them. I think it's one I will have to re-read in a few years to get even more out of it, at an older stage in my life.


Tracy (tracyrittmueller) Angie wrote: "This novel is so huge, and there's so much to discuss! I want to respond to the question about it being an old-fashioned story, though. It actually did feel old-fashioined for me. The narration was..."

I agree that one of the things it's about is forgiveness, and also about the cost of forgiveness--there is a price to be paid before we are forgiven (the concept of redemption or atonement.

And that's only one of the themes working through this rich and complex story. One of my favorite contemporary novels.


Tracy (tracyrittmueller) Alana wrote: "I read Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide earlier this year and it goes into great depth about the enormous need for help with fistulas in the deve..."

I agree. And I want to reread it in a few years, too. (Books that go on my re-read list are rare!) Also, Because of its complexity, I think this is a very difficult book to discuss in a forum like this.


Karen (karinlib) | 509 comments Verghese is such a wonderful writer. It took me a bit to get into Cutting for Stone, but once I did, I could not put it down. I also read The Tennis Partner, which was a good read. I often wish Verghese would write more books (I understand why he doesn't), because he is one of my favorite authors.


back to top