Crime, Mysteries & Thrillers discussion
This topic is about
I Let You Go
Archive - Group Reads
>
I Let You Go - March 2016
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Chava
(new)
Feb 27, 2016 02:54AM
This is the thread for I let you go by Clare Mackintosh. Your moderator is Nick
reply
|
flag
Is "I let you go" written in the first person? If it is,then I'm not interested.
I do not believe that this book is available in the States yet.
This looks really good and is not available from my library - "on order". Your comment, Kristen, explains it.
Hi Marion. Strangely, I Let You Go is written from a number of different Points of View. It has first person from the main character and another leading protagonist, but parts are narrated in the third person to link it together. A bit in the style of Gone Girl I wasn't sure it would work but it is actually very clever in that respect and I think it comes off.Kirsten/Suzy: I am afraid being in the UK I didn't check if it is available in the States yet and am surprised it isn't. You can get it for Kindle though at http://www.amazon.com/Let-You-Go-Clar... It is a Sunday Times bestseller over here and is produced by a reputable traditional publisher. They are a bit slow off the mark if this is the case.
Hi all,Group moderator Chava here.
I hear that this book isn't published in the USA yet. The GR page says it was published in November 2014. Nick has done everything right in nominating this book. Usually books come out in the USA first before the rest of the world (Nick is in the UK). We will go ahead with this discussion. It is unfortunate that some people won't have access to this book (yet).
They have copies on order in Toronto at the public library. Hopefully the book arrives soon so that I can participate :-)
Icewineanne wrote: "They have copies on order in Toronto at the public library. Hopefully the book arrives soon so that I can participate :-)"Fingers crossed Anne
I see from Amazon that the hardcover will be released May 3, 2016 in the States! A rare time that I wish I had a kindle. I read either paper print or listen to audio - looks like this is available in German from Audible. :)I will definitely read this when it comes out, but will miss out on this conversation, sadly.
It appears to be available on Audible in the UK Suzy, though a bit expensive? http://www.amazon.co.uk/I-Let-You-Go/...
It is really strange that it has taken so long to publish in the States when it is doing so well this side of the Pond. You can let us know what you think when you eventually do get it
Yes, I will dip back into the conversation after I read it. It's not available in the States on Audible either and it won't let me grab the audio from the UK. I love seeing, however, the enthusiasm for the book (mainly 5 stars) on Amazon.
You would have thought the main idea behind online books would be that they are available from anywhere, in audible or digital format. Crazy when they are just sending a file. Isn't it supposed to be the Worldwide Web? :)
I found 1 copy of this book at my local libary, but I'm still waiting getting to get my hands on the book. I should get it whitin 2 weeks so hopfully I have time to read it and take part in the discussion.
Hmm I got this book a couple months ago and I live in the US but can't remember where I got it. If you guys are interested you can download a pdf copy here to hold you over until your library has it. If you want to download the audio to your computer you will have to first download the VK Saver chrome extension, which is kind of a pain but worth it. The quality of both could be sucky but if it's all you can get right now then maybe it's worth it.
Nick wrote: "Hi Marion. Strangely, I Let You Go is written from a number of different Points of View. It has first person from the main character and another leading protagonist, but parts are narrated in the t..."You can't get it until May. This is the 2nd group I've been in that's picked this book.
You could order a used copy from a 3rd party. But, I think it's better to just try and make sure it is available on both sides of "the Pond".
Chava wrote: "Hi all,Group moderator Chava here.
I hear that this book isn't published in the USA yet. The GR page says it was published in November 2014. Nick has done everything right in nominating this book..."
I don't think he's wrong. I just feel it's inadvisable.
Nick wrote: "You would have thought the main idea behind online books would be that they are available from anywhere, in audible or digital format. Crazy when they are just sending a file. Isn't it supposed to ..."You would think. But publisher's have agreements. It's not technology, it's contracts.
My recommendation is that we postpone this group read till May when the book will be available in the States and Canada.
Suzy wrote: "My recommendation is that we postpone this group read till May when the book will be available in the States and Canada."Terrific suggestion, I second the motion :-)
Chava wrote: "Hi all,Group moderator Chava here.
I hear that this book isn't published in the USA yet. The GR page says it was published in November 2014. Nick has done everything right in nominating this book..."
Hi Chava, people are requesting this group read be put back to May when the book is available in the States. I have no problem with that, tbh. It may be a bit of a small discussion if we go ahead now. Suzy and Icewineanne both suggest this as a way forward and I am happy to comply.
Okay, I've broken down and bought this used and should receive it between the 10th and the end of the month.
Good work Kirsten, I hope you're not disappointed but I don't think you will be. Looks like the discussion continues as planned for this month then
Nick wrote: "Chava wrote: "Hi all,Group moderator Chava here.
I hear that this book isn't published in the USA yet. The GR page says it was published in November 2014. Nick has done everything right in nomina..."
Sorry, we are just going with this as BOTM for March. We can't chop and change the dates of BOTMs. It is unfortunate, but remember that these threads don't go away. You can still comment in later months if you wish.
I suggest in future that you see if the book you want to vote for is available in your area before you vote for it.
Chava
OK, that's fine Chava. Anyone made a start yet? What are your first impressions? It's a strong opening chapter I think, sets the tone well and Clare does possess the ability to make you shudder. I confess I read the book in just over a week so I know it pretty well...
I'm starting the audiobook as soon as I finish the really long one I'm stuck on now. I tend not to like British thrillers but I hope this one doesn't disappoint me.
Farren wrote: "I'm starting the audiobook as soon as I finish the really long one I'm stuck on now. I tend not to like British thrillers but I hope this one doesn't disappoint me." OK hopefully you'll enjoy it!
I've finished this book and I seriously enjoyed it. There were a couple of twists that took me by surprise which I loved. I can't wait for people to finish so I can discuss it with you all!
Glad you enjoyed it Lorraine. Any particular word you would use to describe it: Chilling is maybe the one I would use
I made it through 15% today and have already decided to quit. I don't DNF a book often but I'd hate to rate it badly just because I'm not in the right type of mood to read it. I just made me sleepy while I drove and that's not good lol
Not for everyone I guess. I felt the same way listening to The Road and that's meant to be a modern classic. Some books dont always translate well to audio
Nick wrote: "Glad you enjoyed it Lorraine. Any particular word you would use to describe it: Chilling is maybe the one I would use"Chilling is pretty spot on. I really enjoyed the trip inside Ian's mind. It was an awful trip, obviously, but it was so interesting to see this perspective. Normally when you're given that much access to a characters mind you wind up feeling quite emphatic. That most certainly did not happen in this case and I actually felt quite disgusted as I read it. It made me wonder though if that sort of perspective is more common than we realize, and that thought concerns me. I do like books and stories that make me question the real world once I've finished the book.
Can you believe that people actually live through the scenario between Ian and Jenna? That mindset and fear, dogged determination and desperation, the violence both physical and mental. For me, the case itself was completely out-shadowed by this relationship.
It starts as one story and turns into something completely different. My wife was put off by the start because we have a young daughter and it inevitably gets you thinking how terrible you would feel in that sort of hit-and-run scenario, but I've told her to persevere because all is not what it seems. Writing a book from several different characters' viewpoints is quite unusual, in my experience, but I think it works well. As you say, you can see the way Ian's warped mind works, in particular.
I just finished this book and my verdict is that it was ok, I can’t say that I loved it but I can’t either say I hated it. The story was good but I lost interest somewhere in the middle and didn’t really care what was happening. Towards the end my interest picked up again. I don’t quite know how i feel about the ending. The main characters where interesting but I feel the story between the two police officers didn’t bring anything to the story, why describe their relationship so much. I would have liked the author to describe more Jenna and Patrik than Rays life in general. I liked the writing style, the different points of views where easy to follow you always knew who was talking. I didn’t find the story chilling in any way and I have to admit that I guessed the outcome for the most part after the first time Ian ” opens his mouth”.
I agree totally about the police officers. I think because Clare worked for the police she wanted to give an insight into how relationships can be effected when people work long hours, but I didn't buy into the attraction of the two officers to each other or Ray's personal story in general. The story was much stronger when focused on Jenna and Patrik. I also question whether things would have been so easy for Jenna after the truth came out. Surely she had a public duty to tell the truth earlier, and there could still be legal repercussions about the fact she didn't? I'm keen not to give away any spoilers so I will stop there, but perhaps when a few more people get involved we can discuss all aspects. Thanks for your comments, Nina
