Nothing But Reading Challenges discussion

347 views
Previous BRs - Authors; A - D > Austen, Jane - Pride and Prejudice - Informal Buddy Read; Start December 11, 2015 *** REVISIT starts August 1, 2018

Comments Showing 201-227 of 227 (227 new)    post a comment »
1 2 3 5 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 201: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) This totally random but I was looking up something to get for my sister since she’s off to college and look what I found:

https://www.etsy.com/listing/61312307...


https://www.etsy.com/listing/56889563...

https://www.etsy.com/listing/62547144...


How cute are these!! Hopefully the links work


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "This totally random but I was looking up something to get for my sister since she’s off to college and look what I found:

https://www.etsy.com/listing/61312307......"


Believe it or not, I just really started using Esty. I have no idea why I have been sleeping on this amazing site for so long. Thanks for the links! Your sis is going to have a happy birthday, and now I have half the decorations picked out for my new bed room. Those pillows are too cute! :D


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Things are getting good!
Elizabeth: (view spoiler)

Jane: (view spoiler)

Lydia and Wickham: (view spoiler)

Mrs. Bennet: (view spoiler)


message 204: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) Chapter 46-end

Darcy: (view spoiler)

Mr. Bingley (view spoiler)

Elizabeth (view spoiler)

Mrs. Bennett (view spoiler)

Lydia and Wickham (view spoiler)

Mrs. Phillips: Bearer of bad news. She’s such a background character but she just not a good person. Though she is the aunt I feel like she gossips and spreads rumors about her own family.

Lady Lucas: Well all I can say is that she and Mr. Collins are definitely cut from the same cloth.

Collins: (view spoiler)

Mr. Bennet: (view spoiler)

Mr. and Mrs. Gardiner: (view spoiler)


message 205: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) ♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Tahmina wrote: "This totally random but I was looking up something to get for my sister since she’s off to college and look what I found:

https://www.etsy.com/listing/61312307......"


Yeah. I try to stay off the site because i'd be broke if I didn't!


message 206: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) ♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Things are getting good!
Elizabeth: Poor Lizzy! It is just like her to realize that she is falling in love with Darcy because she thinks he doesn’t want her anymore. And of course she doesn’t consi..."


Elizabeth: YES!!! exactly. Though I think its because he already thinks bad about her family. But this is the one instance where he could not say anything since his sister almost made the same mistake.

Jane: I still love her :( sorry will have to disagree on this point. I think she is such a lovely and sweet person. Though you are right that she sets up herself for disappointment she still doesn't let it bring her down.

And as for being a cynic. I totally am too. But when the worst thing I can think of happens I am still surprised and can't believe (My cousin says I am a pessimistic idealist ...... I am not sure how haha)

Wickham:(view spoiler)

Mrs. Bennett: Isn't that the best part of her character. That she is somehow "psychic" and knew everything that was going to happen but somehow is always the victim and surprised by it.

(view spoiler)

Yeah I agree. I think living with her would never be funny but always irritating.


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Things are getting good!
Elizabeth: Poor Lizzy! It is just like her to realize that she is falling in love with Darcy because she thinks he doesn’t want her anymore. An..."


Jane: Oh, don't be sorry for disagreeing, Jane is so sweet and likable. To be honest, I admire people like her because they are strong enough to expect the best knowing they could be disappointed. :)

Wickham: (view spoiler)

I see you finished the book @Tahmina! :D

Can't wait to read your final observations!


message 208: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) ♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Tahmina wrote: "♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Things are getting good!
Elizabeth: Poor Lizzy! It is just like her to realize that she is falling in love with Darcy because she thinks he doesn’t want..."


Yes!!! I'll be around to read your final thoughts on the book!


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Tahmina wrote: "♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Things are getting good!
Elizabeth: Poor Lizzy! It is just like her to realize that she is falling in love with Darcy becau..."

Great! I'll probably finish it this weekend.

And if you still want to read Crime and Punishment, and don't mind my slow pace, we can start it soon. I totally understand if you don't want to dive into something that heavy right now though. 😃


message 210: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) Hahaha I’m good!! I know your moving so when we finish this just pick the date and we can start the new book. So I’m down!!


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "Hahaha I’m good!! I know your moving so when we finish this just pick the date and we can start the new book. So I’m down!!"

Cool!


message 212: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) https://www.theguardian.com/books/201...

I was reading this random article on P&P ... its a very different take on the characters we read ... and some of them not so nice so read at your own risk!


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "https://www.theguardian.com/books/201...

I was reading this random article on P&P ... its a very different take on the characters we read ... and some of the..."


Thank you! I will check it out.

I am reading, but I was going to wait until I finished to post so I could read your comments and we could freely discuss. Should be done in a couple days. :)


message 214: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) ♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Tahmina wrote: "https://www.theguardian.com/books/201...

I was reading this random article on P&P ... its a very different take on the characters we read ......"


Sounds good!!! Can't wait to hear your thoughts


message 215: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) so checking in!! How is it looking so far?


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "so checking in!! How is it looking so far?"
Sorry! I just finished it last night. I'll post in a few minutes. Thanks so much for checking in and putting up with my slow reading. 😁


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Mr. Collins: (view spoiler)

Mrs Bennet: (view spoiler)

Elizabeth: (view spoiler)

Lydia: (view spoiler)

Mrs. Gardiner’s letter: (view spoiler)

Wickham: The only thing else I am going to say about him is “YUCK!”.

Jane: (view spoiler)

Lady Catherine: (view spoiler)

Elizabeth and Darcy: (view spoiler)

Final thoughts: (view spoiler)


message 218: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) ♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Tahmina wrote: "so checking in!! How is it looking so far?"
Sorry! I just finished it last night. I'll post in a few minutes. Thanks so much for checking in and putting up with my slow reading. 😁"


No Worries!


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "Chapter 46-end

Darcy: Why does he go to see Elizabeth when she gets the letter from Jane? I don’t think Austen explains but curious whether I missed it or it explains it somewhere.

When he happe..."


Darcy: (view spoiler)

Bingley: (view spoiler)

I 100% agree with your assessment of Elizabeth!

Mrs Bennet: (view spoiler)

Lydia and Wickham: (view spoiler)

Mr. Collins: Right?! He is the worst person!

Mr. Bennet: (view spoiler)

Yep, Mr. and Mrs Gardener were the MVPs of this novel.


message 220: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) I think Charlotte will be fine. She seems like she's a person that can tune someone out completely.

Mrs. Bennett: Yup you read that right. And this is a women that does not like entails because it takes money away from her children but is ok with other peoples kids being deprived!

Elizabeth: Its a super cute love story. And its soooo true. I can always tell when other people are flirting or into each other but not when it involves me!

Lydia: Yeah I think she is just dumb sixteen year old who things she got a catch. Everyone is into him and only she got him. And none of the crazy stuff comes out until after she has run off with him. And then to come back home and your mom is so excited for you!! Well I don't know about you but I think any 16 year old would think they did the right thing. I really do think she is a copy of her mother. Who is also selfish and naive.

Gardiner's are the best in this novel.

Lizzie: Yes!!! she was great on that point! And I hope you don't mind me correcting you but this is not a Victorian novel .. which is something I found out two weeks ago!!

Response to Jane is so Elizabeth. Truth to it but also joking.

Ending: This is one of the better endings in her books too. I think you said you have not read the other books so I won't spoil them but a couple of endings were just annoying.


message 221: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) ♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle) wrote: "Tahmina wrote: "Chapter 46-end

Darcy: Why does he go to see Elizabeth when she gets the letter from Jane? I don’t think Austen explains but curious whether I missed it or it explains it somewhere...."


Bingley reason ... ok i like your way of thinking so I am going to go with it!!

Oops... I might you feel affection for Mrs. Bennett and Lydia!! Dang!! i'm good :)

I imagine the 1995 version of Mr. Bennett. He was just so likable and lovely. And I personally like Mr. Bennett. I just wish he was more involved.


message 222: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) And final thoughts:

1. I heard on a podcast that they thought Charlotte's character was gay?? Do you see that? I just see her as a person, in today's society, who just doesn't want the family life and its ok. Not that she can't be presented in that way in modern adaptations I'm just saying I don't actually see her being like that.

2. Another discussion I usually see is Darcy on a spectrum of autism. I also don't see that. I just see him as a person that might be socially awkward or socially uncomfortable.

3. Elizabeth hating women: Elizabeth dislikes certain women. I can see that. But they are so awful that you can't blame her. But I was listening to podcast (maybe the same one maybe another one who knows!! I listen to a lot) says that she seems to only like girl characters are submissive and fit the vision of "what women should behave like for that period. And how much more harsh she is to Charlotte when she marries for money but not on Wickham when he pursues a girl... Here I can see it a little but again not really. I mean Charlotte marries a crazy and a complete jerk for financial stability. And the girl wickham pursues we don't know much about.


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "And final thoughts:

1. I heard on a podcast that they thought Charlotte's character was gay?? Do you see that? I just see her as a person, in today's society, who just doesn't want the family life..."


See, on all three of those points I feel like they are viewing it from a "present day" lens instead of considering the times.

1. I think it's a little condescending to label Charlotte as gay just because she takes a pragmatic approach to marriage. Why does she have to be anything other than a woman who knew what she wanted out of marriage and went for it. And I agree with your earlier point that she may actually be happy with Collins because she is good at tuning people out. They may actually be a good, if not perfect, match for each other.

2.Again with the labeling. I know that is something people love to do, but some times people are just people and they have strengths and weaknesses when it comes to interacting with others. I'm not saying he was or wasn't on the spectrum, but without the author expressing that, I don't think he needs a label.

3. I also thought Lizzy was harder on Charlotte than she was on Wickham, but I thought that was because she knew and loved Charlotte so she had higher expectations of her than some guy she just met. Plus she was enamored with Wickham and that clouded her judgement.
And once again with the labeling. Why does she have to be a "woman hater" just because she likes being around a certain type of woman. People like who they like, dang! Lol

And thank you for the correction. I was unsure when I called it a Victorian novel, but I was too lazy to Google. lol
Now, thanks to you (and Google), I know it was a Georgian novel. Or at least it was set in the Georgian period. :)


message 224: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) 1. I see her as pragmatic too. Just like this needs to be done and this is how I can achieve it. Ok go!

2. Agreed!!

3. Thats a good point too! She is closer to Charlotte but I think she also know Collins better too and realizes hes annoying!

I don't really mind it if someone takes a work and then adapts and interprets it in whatever way they want. I feel like there is just enough evidence for them to interpret it that way if they wanted too. But I don't see how they can be certain that its what was going on. And the author is dead so you can't ask her. You can't say it with 100% certainty. And I think that's what bothers me the most when people think their viewpoint is correct.

Anyway i love this story and I feel like every time I have read I've learned something new and every time I seem to learn something new from the book. I had no idea it was Georgian Novel!! So now I know that. Haha. I just knew that it wasn't Victorian!

Thanks for the doing the BR it has been so fun!


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "1. I see her as pragmatic too. Just like this needs to be done and this is how I can achieve it. Ok go!

2. Agreed!!

3. Thats a good point too! She is closer to Charlotte but I think she also know..."


I had a lot of fun too!

I ordered Crime and Punishment because the paperback cost the same as the ebook. It should be here in a couple days. Still down to read it?


message 226: by Tahmina (new)

Tahmina (tpopal) Yeah sure. I have to order mine too. I completely forgot and I thought I had a copy ☹️ anyway I’ll let you know when I get it and then we can plan a date to start


♥♡¢σσкιє♥♡ (Krystle)  (kookiekrysp88) | 69 comments Tahmina wrote: "Yeah sure. I have to order mine too. I completely forgot and I thought I had a copy ☹️ anyway I’ll let you know when I get it and then we can plan a date to start"

Sounds good 😁


1 2 3 5 next »
back to top