Dumbledore's Army discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
51 views
Closed and ArchivedTopics > PJO compare to HP

Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tiffany , Is not active as of this current moment but is proud of you guys (new)

Tiffany  (tiffanyyy_wang) | 1972 comments Mod
NOT WHICH ONE IS BETTER! NO ARGUING HERE!


oıɔoɹ/rocio♥ (lalis26) PJO?


message 3: by Swati , Is not active as of this current moment (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 2208 comments Mod
I love them both, but HARRY POTTER FOREVER!


message 4: by Swati , Is not active as of this current moment (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 2208 comments Mod
Some reason..


message 5: by Swati , Is not active as of this current moment (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 2208 comments Mod
*glares* I guess you're right.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

ROWLING!!!! (Sorry, but by saying JK you were just ASKING for the Rowling....)

I will always love the Harry Potter series over ANY OTHER, even if it was considered the greatest in the world, Harry Potter will always be my favorite. It has something special about it....PJO was just a good series. HP was something extraordinary.


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

......

I can't really say I have any reasons for that though. There are plenty of excellent series with a similar sense of humor (that I enjoy immensely), but they just don't have the same pizazz as HP. Harry Potter is in a completely different category of it's own.


message 8: by Tiffany , Is not active as of this current moment but is proud of you guys (new)

Tiffany  (tiffanyyy_wang) | 1972 comments Mod
Percy is better than Harry.


message 9: by Tiffany , Is not active as of this current moment but is proud of you guys (new)

Tiffany  (tiffanyyy_wang) | 1972 comments Mod
And Annabeth was waayyy better than Hermione. I'm comparing the CHARACTERS, NOT THE BOOKS.


message 10: by Diana (new)

Diana I decided that PJO is my favorite of all time. I can see how they are both awesome, though. You can't really compare the books; they are two totally separate things.

I agree that the character Percy is better than Harry, and Annabeth better than Hermione. I also think Percabeth is better than the relationships in HP.


message 11: by Swati , Is not active as of this current moment (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 2208 comments Mod
Nah, I think I liked Harry and Ginny more than Percy and Annabeth. I think.


message 12: by Tiffany , Is not active as of this current moment but is proud of you guys (new)

Tiffany  (tiffanyyy_wang) | 1972 comments Mod
Whatever. At least Annabeth and Percy weren't DRUNK. Well, Percy was....


Rachel (aka. Kaiserin Sisi) (looney-lovegood) | 265 comments Who was drunk? When was this?


message 14: by Pandy (new)

Pandy | 637 comments Tiffany thinks Harry and Ginny were drunk when they named Albus Severus.


message 15: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Uh....


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

I like HP better than PJO but Percy better than Harry and Percy and Annabeth better than Harry and Ginny.


Rachel (aka. Kaiserin Sisi) (looney-lovegood) | 265 comments I like everything about Harry Potter better, but I still love PJO.



Rachel (aka. Kaiserin Sisi) (looney-lovegood) | 265 comments Pandy wrote: "Tiffany thinks Harry and Ginny were drunk when they named Albus Severus."

Well, that makes sense!


message 19: by Pandy (last edited Oct 09, 2009 02:33PM) (new)

Pandy | 637 comments It does, doesn't it? :)


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

I like PJO more than HP
I know its crazy but its more interesting


message 21: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Wafa wrote: "I like PJO more than HP
I know its crazy but its more interesting"



SACRALIDGE!!!!!!
*kills*


message 22: by *Sklip* (new)

*Sklip*  (stalkerninja) | 146 comments I love both of them!¡!¡!¡!¡


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

Zoe *AKA Arachna Malfoy* wrote: "Wafa wrote: "I like PJO more than HP
I know its crazy but its more interesting"


SACRALIDGE!!!!!!
*kills*"


ummmm ... wat?!?! are u trying to kill me zoe?!?!?!?!?! BUT NICO WHO IS MY GOOD FRIEND WILL MAYBE BAIL ME OUT FROM THE UNDERWORLD! ALTHOUGH HADES DOESNT LISTEN TO HIM MUCH!!! IN THAT CASE ... *hides*


message 24: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments HA! I AM A DAUGHTER OF HADES!!!!!!!!!!!


*motions*

BRETHREN OF THE UNDERWORLD, RISE AND AID YOUR SISTER!!!

um...I said AID YOUR SISTER!!!!

*dead people melt out of the ground*

HA!

Dead person: Bad girl. You're grounded.

Me: WAAT?
*sulks*


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

i love nico! i didnt like briana!
haha! when him and percy were shadow traveling he was like ... "with great power comes great need to take a nap. wake me up l8tr"


message 26: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Wafa wrote: "i love nico! i didnt like briana!
haha! when him and percy were shadow traveling he was like ... "with great power comes great need to take a nap. wake me up l8tr""


U mean Bianca?


message 27: by [deleted user] (new)

Watever
I read the books awhile ago


message 28: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Wafa wrote: "Watever
I read the books awhile ago"


lol me too


message 29: by *Sklip* (new)

*Sklip*  (stalkerninja) | 146 comments lol, my fav demi-gods are Nico de Angelo and Luke Castellan


message 30: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Nico is kewl. So is Luke. I like Thalia too, but she shouldn't have become a hunter of Artemis.


message 31: by *Sklip* (new)

*Sklip*  (stalkerninja) | 146 comments But Zoë (Zöe?) had to die, it was in the prophecy!!!


message 32: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments it's Zoë. I should know; that's my real name.


message 33: by *Sklip* (new)

*Sklip*  (stalkerninja) | 146 comments Bwah haha!!! I was right the first time.


message 34: by [deleted user] (new)

i dont like percabeth
i cried when luke died!!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 35: by Tiffany , Is not active as of this current moment but is proud of you guys (new)

Tiffany  (tiffanyyy_wang) | 1972 comments Mod
Percabeth is better than Bald Potta and Ginny.

HP is better than PJO overall.


message 36: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Mary wrote: "Wafa wrote: "i dont like percabeth
i cried when luke died!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Why? He was the bad guy!"


But he repented. It was sad that he had to kill himself. :'(

Also, I imagined him really hawt.

But the guy who played him in the movie was ugly.


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

it was sad in the book since like when he was about to die he was like to annabeth, did u love me?!!? it was sad
they needed a hotter luke in the movie! they guy in it was okay


message 38: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments Wafa wrote: "it was sad in the book since like when he was about to die he was like to annabeth, did u love me?!!? it was sad
they needed a hotter luke in the movie! they guy in it was okay"


Yeah I know...:'(

And they totally needed a hotter Luke. I imagined him sooooooooooooooooooooooo much hotter than the actor dude.


message 39: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments ☂ That Girl Named Jenn ☂ wrote: "Zoe *AKA Arachna Malfoy* wrote: "Wafa wrote: "it was sad in the book since like when he was about to die he was like to annabeth, did u love me?!!? it was sad
they needed a hotter luke in the movi..."


yeah. He also needed a scar.


message 40: by [deleted user] (new)

i loved the flying converse!!!!!


message 41: by Zoë the Awesome (new)

Zoë the Awesome (malfoy_luver) | 472 comments lo yea


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.