♥!The Young Adult Book Club!♥ discussion
Book Talk
>
Overrated Books/Series
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Leahxx
(new)
Nov 19, 2013 04:48PM

reply
|
flag
*



are overrated to me. I didn't like the Carrier of the Mark AT ALL. It was HORRIBLE. The writing was like that of a middle school kid, the main character was annoying and unrelatable, and the supporting characters were like cardboard cut-outs. The House of Night series.... I ultimately liked the first book, the second one was ok, but after the third book I just gave up on the series. What started out with potential to be a good series, became crappy quickly because the main character couldn't be faithful to her boyfriend. And even after he broke up with her, I heard from someone still reading the series that the guys continue to pile up.... so, yeah, the main character of the House of Night series was the real buzz kill for me. I'm still deeply intrigued with the world the authors created, but I just can't stand Zoey.



are overrated to me. I didn't like the Carrier of the Mark AT ALL. It was HORRIBLE. The writing was like that of a middle school ..."
Oh, I know! The House of Night was sooo bad! I also read the first two and ended up just stopping. I can understand breaking up with Eric, but to cheat on him with two different guys in ONE book is just over the top in my opinion





I'm honestly not a fan of The Mortal Instruments. I thought City of Glass was very well done but the rest...I wasn't a fan. I see it as fanfiction sadly.






I dont know why








omg so true! I thought Morganville Vampires was good (everyone I saw who read it, liked it) but after reading the first two books, I still can't see why those people liked it so much. Nothing happened in the book that wasn't overly predictable or absolutely boring. It is a kinda good series, but so overrated.
TMI too. I read it, thinking it would be good (it is, kind of) but then there was a movie and 3 more books + a prequel series and 2 other series based on the same world. Kind of disconcerting how 'popular' it became from that book that didn't inspire me to read everyday.





omg so true! I thought Morganville Vampires was good (everyone I saw who r..."
exactly!!!!!



can you imagine 3 new trilogies over the next decade with the same over used shadowhunter world?

can you..."
I know I think I am going to stop! I got to City of Fallen Angels and now it is getting repetitive and annoying

i read COFA but could not get into COLS. given clare has good ideas, i felt it will be fruitful if she can channelize it into making new stuff.

The idea had so much potential, but the second and third books were very disappointing.
Leanne wrote: "The Matched trilogy.
The idea had so much potential, but the second and third books were very disappointing."
I agree. I LOVED Matched! Gave it 5 stars. Then I couldn't even finish Crossed.
Couldn't finish these series. For most I didn't even finish the first book. Well I did finish the Immortals series by Alyson Noel but I really really wish I hadn't. That way back when I never DNF now I DNF like a pro :-D
The idea had so much potential, but the second and third books were very disappointing."
I agree. I LOVED Matched! Gave it 5 stars. Then I couldn't even finish Crossed.
Couldn't finish these series. For most I didn't even finish the first book. Well I did finish the Immortals series by Alyson Noel but I really really wish I hadn't. That way back when I never DNF now I DNF like a pro :-D










I enjoyed Mortal Instruments, but really think Infernal Devices is better. Again, I don't understand the hype? I didn't even finish the series. I stopped after reading book three because it was done. Why go on with the series? I enjoyed Beautiful Creatures, but couldn't get through the second one.
I think the biggest overrated book I've read was Ender's Game. My mother has been telling me to read this book since I was in grade school. Countless people have scolded me for not reading it, especially as a scifi fan. So I sat down and read it. And really wasn't impressed. I guess maybe if I'd read it earlier? It was probably good for its time (wasn't it all before the technology that surrounds us today?) but I just didn't see what everyone else saw in it.



can you..."
But think of the many books were written in our plain boring world


The concept was good but for me the author tried to make the story more dramatic and started piling more and more things into the book which she didn't need to like (spoilers) she didn't need two executions, deaths, kidnapping, bombing,a illegitimate child and double crosses in just one book, that's over saturating the drama, you need at most three plot points while working on world building and relationship development (which were both quite poor in this book.



I read all of the books from both of these series. I think Rapture by Lauren Kate is one of the few books I would be okay with burning. Divergent just annoyed me because of Tris. She was soooo annoying! I had the same problem with Luce. And neither Daniel nor Four had any real personality in my opinion. Four was okay but I had no clue why he would want Tris as for Daniel...I hate him. He was irritating and had that whole "I know what's best for you so be a good girl and do everything I say" and with the exception of the third book, Luce pretty much did exactly that. Hate weak female leads.



I read all of the books from both of these series. I think Rapture by Lauren Kate is one of the few books I would be okay with burning..."
Kind of agree with you about divergent series especially Alliegiant, Four irritated me SO much, he was stupid and reckless when he got captured in insurgent because 'he was trying to save Tris' he literally says to her when she sees him being put in jail by the soldiers 'these are the consequences' basically saying because you gave yourself up I decided to give myself up, so he sacrifices himself for no reason meaning his side loses one of their best fighters and the enemy get an extra divergent mind making tris more disposable and them having another divergent mind if something goes wrong with tris, good job four, good job.


I know I'm a minority, most people enjoy this book.





The Iron Fey series by Julie Kagawa
The Selection series by Kiera Cass
Elemental series by Brigid Kemmerer
And John Green's books are okay... not great but not bad either. So they're over rated according to me.



Typical jerk/bad boy and the girl with a lot of attitude pretending to be above the guy's standards when mentally she just can't stop gussing over his looks..ugh..


Books mentioned in this topic
Glass Houses (other topics)Marked (other topics)
Twilight (other topics)
Go Ask Alice (other topics)
New Moon (other topics)
More...