17 And Under Debate discussion

34 views
books > Twilight (which the group decided is TRASH!!!)

Comments Showing 1-50 of 94 (94 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) if only emma were here she would b so mad @ u.


message 2: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
omg, Twilight was like omg AMAZINGNESS!!!!!!!!!


message 3: by ♥Sarah♥ (last edited May 24, 2009 01:19PM) (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) emma would so agree w/ claire right now.


message 4: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
????


message 5: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) yup. she LOVES twilight. like crazy. she's @ her cousin's b-day party right now though....
:(


message 6: by ♥Sarah♥ (last edited May 24, 2009 01:23PM) (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) let's try 2 keep this group active!


message 7: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
oooohhhhhhh........ sounds like shes a person i'd wanna talk 2! Twilight is like, the most amazing series ever written!


message 8: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) lol. i'll tell her that.


message 9: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
lol coolio


message 10: by [deleted user] (new)

DEATH TO ALL TWINERDS!!! WROAR!!!!

omg, my lil bro was watching the movie 2day, and towards the end, when james was attacking edweirdo, i was waving around a knife, telling edward 2 die, no joke... lol


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

lol


message 12: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments I think Twilight disgraces the name of literature. the plot had potential (girl falls in love with vampire who is constantly fighting the urge to eat her), but the mediocre, non-developed characters and horrible writing style ruined it from page 1.


message 13: by Emilie[-MLE-] (last edited May 26, 2009 02:21PM) (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments it's like the "Bits-O-Honey" of books.


message 14: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments uhhh . . . bits-o-honey is actually a really cheap, crappy kind of candy.


message 15: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments that's okay. I forgive you.


message 16: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments you're welcome.


message 17: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments i'm just that awesome.

lol


message 18: by [deleted user] (new)

TWILIGHT ROCKS!! Image and video hosting by TinyPic


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

It is a Romeo and Juliet lovestory.Undieing and forbidden love.It is the stories' essence, that and I ♥ Edward to death.


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm


message 21: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) Whisper Marie wrote: "It is a Romeo and Juliet lovestory.Undieing and forbidden love.It is the stories' essence, that and I ♥ Edward to death."

emma would love u right now. I can't say anthing 'bout Twilight 'cause I haven't read it. I'm basically doing emma's opinion.


message 22: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
I definitly agree with Whisper Marie. I found that it's moral is good vs. evil, us vs. our wants, the story goes far beyond a vamp. wanting to suck the blood out of his girlfriend. I also am crazy 4 Edward


message 23: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments I don't see how you could call it "us v. Our wants" because the entire series is about how bella WANTS Edward, not because he was a great person, but because he was a "bad boy" "dangerous" and "sexy". I think it's a shallow story of teenage lust that is about as romantic as beating yourself over the head with a baseball bat.


message 24: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
no, i was talking about Edward wanting Bella's blood badly and fighting against it


message 25: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments That may be a theme of the book, but I think that so many people like twilight not because it's written well (it's not) or because it sends a good message (it doesn't), but because it tells the story of a glamorized version of "love", with enough difficult patches to make it seem real to the audience.


message 26: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
ahh


message 27: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments I am of the opinion that Twilight is cheap trash. You are intitled to your opinion too.


message 28: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
i agree


message 29: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments Okay.


message 30: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
.....


message 31: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments Haha! The conversation just kinda died, didn't it?


message 32: by Claire, the faithful vice mod (new)

Claire | 72 comments Mod
lol yeah


message 33: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) no more debate


message 34: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) lol


message 35: by [deleted user] (new)

lol what do we do now?


message 36: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) idk.


message 37: by [deleted user] (last edited Jun 02, 2009 12:56PM) (new)

Edward Cullen....Edward Cullen... tries so hard to not suck out the blood of 17-19 year old Isabella Marie Swan.It physically HURTS him to be near her, yet he endures it due to love.Passionate love that is the most pure love you could ask for.Could you imagine, trying to keep yourself from something that you almost HAVE to have and if you refuse it, it causes you actual buring pain?Can you?At all?Can you even imagine the absolute searing pain he goes thru? Just to be with her?


message 38: by [deleted user] (new)

Im going to leave this topic... I hate reading anything about love. Too mushy


Amanda TWILIGHT LOVER (twilight21) | 6 comments TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT
TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT
TWILIGHT twilight




message 40: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments Very very very true.


message 41: by [deleted user] (new)

If I could say what I want to right now, the world would explode. I shall now leave this online Hell.


message 42: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments good for you.


message 43: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) now things r getting hectic.


message 44: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments How is twilight anythng new? It's just the same love story that's been around for eons retold with a bloody twist. There is nothing special about a badly written, cheesy, unbelievable story of wimpy lust.


message 45: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) i hate not being able 2 say anything about the book!


message 46: by Emilie[-MLE-] (new)

Emilie[-MLE-] | 105 comments Why? Have you not read it?


message 47: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) yeah


message 48: by ♥Sarah♥ (new)

♥Sarah♥  (sarahrox) lol


message 49: by [deleted user] (last edited Jun 10, 2009 11:37AM) (new)

I HATE Twilight!!!! It's trash that gets WAY too much hype for NO STORY and insufferable characters.
Edward is so stalkerish! If anyone read the partial draft of midnight sun, HE OILS BELLA'S WINDOWS.
And it's not really "love." They just automatically fall in love, the minute they meet? No! That's not love!
Oh, and Bella is such a Mary Sue! She always puts herself in peril and is saved by the guy!


message 50: by Mandy (new)

Mandy | 24 comments Oh boy. Your'll probaly kick me out for this, but it seems to me that yall are being wayyyy to extreme about this. You don't like twilight. We get it. Is there really any reason to rant on about it, just because others like it?

And, in responce to your reasons on hating twilight:

A) they did not fall in love automatically. I've read and heard about cases where people fell in love much quiker. If I seem to remeamber correctly, Edward wanted to suck her blood when they met...

b)Unbelivable? Ummm,, yea! Hello. Its about vampires. Jeez, what do you espect?

C)Mary Sue? OKay... Because you know its being so prim&proper to hang out with vamps. And then, OMIGOSH, get saved by them! I mean, Bella should totally fight the vampires her self! Then, she'll be died, but at least not a Mary Sue (Also, btw, is a really dumb term. People with the name Mary or Sue are not always anti-feminist okay? Those names have been around a lot long then most, so really more feminst have had the name Mary then Ashley or whatever)

I could go on more but... don't really feel like it. All Im saying is it sure seems like you guys hate twilight because "everybody else" likes twilight. So, I guess your trying to be diffeernt, huh?

And, why on earth to you read all the books, plus partial draft, if you hate the seris so much? And dont give me, "I just read it because _____ made me" or "I read it because, I like, had to see how stupiod they where!"


« previous 1
back to top