7_5 ENG 2013-2014 discussion

13 views
Percy Jackson vs Harry Potter

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Nishant (new)

Nishant Singhal (nishantkumar19) | 5 comments Which one do you think is better?


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

I think that percy jackson is a copy of hp. same story line, same characters, same everything. personally, I like hp better, but pj is okay.


message 3: by Devika (new)

Devika Sen | 1 comments no its not but i like percy jackson more :p


message 4: by Hayoon (new)

Hayoon Chung | 2 comments Percy Jackson!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love Percy Jackson Series Hp is okay but it's toooooooo old


message 5: by Nishant (new)

Nishant Singhal (nishantkumar19) | 5 comments I think percy jackson is more about mythology, so it has a more historical basis whereas harry potter is mostly fantasy. I also think harry potter is for slightly older kids, like maybe half a year older. This doesn't mean percy jackson is babyish, it's just that the harry potter storyline is slightly hard to follow.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Nishant wrote: "I think percy jackson is more about mythology, so it has a more historical basis whereas harry potter is mostly fantasy. I also think harry potter is for slightly older kids, like maybe half a year..."
Good point. Slightly different background, but same structure.


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

I think hp is better because pj is basically changing greek mythology to the modern day.


message 8: by [deleted user] (new)

Liam wrote: "I think that percy jackson is a copy of hp. same story line, same characters, same everything. personally, I like hp better, but pj is okay."

I agree although I disagree with the fact that you wrote that they have the same storyline,characters


message 9: by Nishant (new)

Nishant Singhal (nishantkumar19) | 5 comments Srishti wrote: "PJ is a really good book, but HP is an oldie, and so NO CONTEST."

wait so which one do you think is better?


message 10: by Nishant (new)

Nishant Singhal (nishantkumar19) | 5 comments Im reading the sorcerers stone right now, and I am enjoying it so far. Does Harry ever get to kill Snape later on in the series?


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

Nishant wrote: "Im reading the sorcerers stone right now, and I am enjoying it so far. Does Harry ever get to kill Snape later on in the series?"

I am not telling


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

Liam wrote: "Nishant wrote: "Im reading the sorcerers stone right now, and I am enjoying it so far. Does Harry ever get to kill Snape later on in the series?"

I am not telling"


Snape dies but harry doesn't kill him


message 13: by Nishant (new)

Nishant Singhal (nishantkumar19) | 5 comments Okay thanks


message 14: by Hayoon (new)

Hayoon Chung | 2 comments @srishti so u said u cant choose unless one of them is really good, so does that mean that they r not good in ur opinion? Right, and still, I still like Percy Jackson better!


back to top