Haruki Murakami fans discussion
Short Stories
>
Your favorite Murakami short story?
message 1:
by
Hertzan
(new)
Feb 26, 2008 11:33AM
one of my all-time favourite stories from Murakami is the amazing THE KANGAROO COMMUNIQUE. I read it with a jaw slightly dislocated. It was so evil and so off-centre and so wrong. A magnificent character study - which Murakami does so well - taken to such an extreme in this short story.
reply
|
flag
*
I like The Kangaroo Communique, but Family Values (I think that is the name from Elephant Vanishes) is my favorite.On meeting my 100% woman... was also good.
The story "barn burning" left some kind of lasting impression with me. I don't know if I would call it my favorite, but out of all the short stories I have read by Murakami, this one definitely got to me in some way. I couldn't tell you why.
My favorite would be "Landscape with Flatiron" from After the Quake. I don't have any objective reasons for liking it, but subjectively, I could relate a lot to Junko. The Junko and Miyake relationship makes my heart tense up all over. I think it's the only Murakami work that I've had such a highly emotional response to.
I really found all of After the Quake to be completely marvelous. I any collection there are some stories that are better than others, but the leanness of ATQ combined with the shared focus of the works really makes it read like 5 parts of a whole - each story can stand on its own, but when read together they sort of coalesce into something magnificent and really powerful. So I'm going to cheat here and say that ATQ is my favorite Murakami short story, or perhaps that I like all 5 stories equally. Much in the same way that you'll never get a mother to tell you which child she loves more than the others, I will not be forced to choose here.
Sleep in The elephant vanishes.Awesome piece of work, with the theme of the monotony, and the trappings of routine, and how in the end no matter how far we try to run away from routine, we'll be trapped one way or another (or at least that's how I perceived it. =)
Shinigawa Monkey was my 2nd favourite.
Is there one book where Murakami has many stories collected into one volume. I would like to check out one of his short story collections when I get the chance.
Daniel, Blind Willow Sleeping Woman and The Elephant Vanishes are collections of his short stories.I think Birthday Stories as well, but I'm not too sure =)
Jonathan wrote: "Daniel, Blind Willow Sleeping Woman and The Elephant Vanishes are collections of his short stories.I think Birthday Stories as well, but I'm not too sure =)"
Jonathan, Shannon, thanks I wrote that down on my list of books to read.
I think Birthday Stories as well, but I'm not too sure =)"Birthday stories is just edited by Murakami, includes only one written by him, which is published already in BWSW. Worth reading also, of course. Each story and author is presented by HM.
Has anyone read any Endo Shusaku--I finished his book Silence sometime last year. The reason I read it was because supposedly he wrote the book in Nagasaki where I used to live. It was good, but, of course, nothing like Murakami's book.
"Thailand" in "After the Quake" is my absolute favorite.
By the way, "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" from Knopf is such a great book. I was so surprised by the wonderful selection of Murakami's short stories. I had read all the stories in Japanese, but I couldn't help buying the book because there aren't any books like this in Japan.
By the way, "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" from Knopf is such a great book. I was so surprised by the wonderful selection of Murakami's short stories. I had read all the stories in Japanese, but I couldn't help buying the book because there aren't any books like this in Japan.
It seems too hard to pick one, but some gut feeling leads me to say "Landscape with flatiron". Both Junko and Miyake individually, and the way in which they connect,rises this special fire within me, quiet and tense at once.I've read the story many times over, and it feels all the more like I carry it inside as a part of me.It gives me an incredible feeling, of something, to quote Junko, "too raw, too heavy, too real to be called an idea".
"On Seeing the 100% Perfect Girl...".This is a perfect example of how to express one of those abstract emotions that we often only scratch the surface of, expressed fully and concretely in an excellent story.
EDIT 2/20/10 - After finishing the book The Elephant Vanishes, I have to say my favorite was the title story itself. The Elephant Vanishes is a perfect example of Murakami's work; he brings out a subtle feeling that borders on the edge of our concious reality, through a story that is surreal but concrete. In the case of this particular story, that feeling was centralized around outgrowing something that always seemed strong and reliable, and more powerful than yourself. I recently moved back to my hometown, which is a small/medium town after having been living in a major city for many years, and upon returning I felt "bigger" than everything - the people and things I used to look up to in this town seemed to have shrunk in size and importance, and many of them were no longer there.
the Murakami world is fascinating and intriguing.Just finsihed reading Underground and Blind Willow,SLeeping Woman.Absolutely stunning!!! The Chance Traveller and The Mirror are my favorite!!! have read it over and over again....
All :) I love them all though Kafka on the Shore, and After Dark are my favourites.
100% Perfect Girl and All God's Children Can Dance are my absolute favorites.
My favorite is "The Year of Spaghetti" (I think it's called -- I read it in Japanese several years ago). I think it perfectly captures the way so many people retreat into loneliness.
"Super Frog Saves Tokyo". One of my favorite short stories of all time. I couldn't tell you why, I don't care to analyze my feelings on the matter :-)"The Year of Spaghetti" was great too.
@ lizzy - did you see the movie version of "All God's Children Can Dance"? It was quite good I thought
Ignoring some of the short stories that are partially included in the novels (like Firefly from Norwegian Wood or The Wind-up Bird) I'd have to say "Sleep" from The Elephant Vanishes collection, "Landscape with Flatiron" from After the Quake and "Crabs" from Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman really moved me."The Year of Spaghetti" also struck a cord. Hmm.. come to think of it, I've been cooking nothing but spaghetti, pasta, penne and such for the past 3 weeks or so while listening to Rossini "for some reason". I should get out more :-).
2078028 well done Mihai ;-)nothing like a plate of "Spagetti al sugo" lifts the spirit up!
i like birthday girl, it has a special place for good things to come, makes you want to have a special thing for your birthday
I really like The Kangaroo Communique...so unique >.<
It really is too hard to pick one! All of them have something special and unique, yet they are all very similar in style and atmosphere..I absolutely love "Kafka on the shore" and "Norwegian Wood" <3
Hi Folks I'm not sure this is the right place to ask but I asked this on an Amazon thread a while back & no-one knew the answer & I was wondering if anyone could help me as it's getting to me now!.
In The Wind Up Bird Chronicle edition I read (Vintage)there is Murakami Biography at the back & it states in it that "Kafka On The Shaw" was so popular in Japan that it spawned a spin off book containing Murakami's replies to some of his thousands of e-mails which where sent to him by fans of the novel".
Does anyone know to which book they are referring? I would love to read it. I have searched but got no leads so far???
Thanks Furny x
Furny wrote: "Hi Folks I'm not sure this is the right place to ask but I asked this on an Amazon thread a while back & no-one knew the answer & I was wondering if anyone could help me as it's getting to me now!..."
Furny, from what I've read his replies were never published in a book. I think they were published on a website or something. Actually, I've also tried to find them, and I think the reason I can't is because the replies were never translated into english. Hope this helps...
And to answer the thread question, my fave Murakami short is possibly "Aeroplane: Or How He Talked To Himself As If Reciting Poetry" from "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman". I love the god dang eff out of that story
Thanks so much Darren for your reply that of course would make sense (although I wish my info in my book had been a bit more specific so as not to get me all excited for nothing!Lol!)It is a shame though I was hoping to be able to find & read it!.
'A Kidney-shaped Stone That Moves Everyday', 'The Bakery Attack (the first one)' and 'Man-eating Cats'.
Mitra wrote: "All :) I love them all though Kafka on the Shore, and After Dark are my favourites."plus 1Q84! At the beginning I didn't like the female character but then, throughout the three books, I found his last work as good as, if not better than, his other best works!
Kangaroo CommuniqueSay hey, how’s tricks?
I like "A Window". The character's background is so unique.
My favourite short story is 'Tony Takitani.' (^_^)
Tony Takitani Hanalei Bay
and some more short stories :) His short stories are incredibly intriguing as much as his novels :)
"On Meeting My 100 Percent Woman One Fine April Morning"!!! :)and the book "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" is one of the best short stories collection! it's been ages since i read all the murakami short stories, next on my re-read, then im sure i can name some more favourites on here! :D
Willy wrote: ""On Meeting My 100 Percent Woman One Fine April Morning"!!! :)
and the book "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" is one of the best short stories collection! it's been ages since i read all the murakami..."
I 100% agree with everything :) That story is also my favorite, but I like "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" short stories collection best!
and the book "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" is one of the best short stories collection! it's been ages since i read all the murakami..."
I 100% agree with everything :) That story is also my favorite, but I like "Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman" short stories collection best!
The Second Bakery Attack from
The Elephant Vanishes
is by far and away my favourite short story by anyone to date.I just began Blind Willow Sleeping Woman on Tuesday though, so perhaps that will change... ^_^
I loved "The Year of Spaghetti", it described the loneliness so well. Also "the Silence", it captured the essence of hatred against someone, a good read when you find someone annoying. Another good one I don't think it's ever been published is "The Train Whistle", its about the intense feeling of being in love.
"Barn Burning" had a kind of long slow effect on me. I don't remember it being very memorable the first time I read it but I kept coming back to it and had to re-read it a couple of times.
Monica wrote: "... Another good one I don't think it's ever been published is "The Train Whistle", its about the intense feeling of being in love. "Yes, I like that one too. It's in New Penguin Parallel Text Short Stories in Japanese.
My hands-down favorite Murakami short story is "The Kangaroo Communique." A kind of obsession I can relate to there.
'A Window' from The Elephant Vanishes is my favourite. A really beautiful little story. I also love The Year Of Spaghetti, but the last line of the piece ruins it for me a little, so 'A Window' is my nomination.
Brian wrote: "'A Window' from The Elephant Vanishes is my favourite. A really beautiful little story. I also love The Year Of Spaghetti, but the last line of the piece ruins it for me a little, so 'A Window' is ..."
I don't remember which one was 'A Window,' maybe I should read The Elephant Vanishes again...
I don't remember which one was 'A Window,' maybe I should read The Elephant Vanishes again...
For me is the Birthday Girl it was so good and the end so astonishing for me.
Haruki Murakami fans
Books mentioned in this topic
The Elephant Vanishes (other topics)Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman (other topics)
New Penguin Parallel Text: Short Stories in Japanese (other topics)
