Shannon Hale Fan Club discussion
If you could only have one, with no side effects, which gift would you have?
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Jan 28, 2008 05:47PM
I'm not quite sure which one I'd chose. But I think I'd go with wind. Some many advantages with that one. Being able to see whats ahead, use it as defense and so on. I'm not sure it's my favorite, but it's the one I think I'd like to have. I dunno, I think I'm still undecided.
reply
|
flag
i agree Esstay, wind would be an extroadinary gift. it would be so useful in many different situations. its very difficult to decide.Though i would only have it if there were no side effects.





Wind for me...probably. All of them would be cool, but the knowledge of the wind would be amazing, and just think....you could make yourself fly!



Isn't choosing Nature Speaking kind of cheating? all the gifts for the price of one?

It all becomes clear...

Isi is one of the special few who can speak more than one, right?
of course, she's not quite as cool as enna anyway so it doesn't matter.

I guess you could interpret it either way, though.
And Enna cannot even hear animals, thank you very much.


do you think people who would have been naturally charming and eloquent get people-speaking, or do you think someone who is naturally very socially awkward and un-persuasive could get it? wouldn't the social awkwardness work against the people-speaking?

I would like to have wind because I hate it when wind is outta control! I would use it like Alyssa said and do chores too! There's a lotta things you can do! The other gifts are awesome too though!!

I love all of them! Nature and Animal Speaking and People Speaking all have advantages!!!

Tree speaking WOULD be cool! Especially if you put it like that!



I'm going to experience all of them and how beautiful they are just like you did Alyssa. Wind, I'll sit in my tree and listen, feel. Fire, I'll sit and watch, smell, listen to it. Animal, I'll listen, watch look. People, I'll close my eyes and listen to a crowd.
Books mentioned in this topic
Twilight (other topics)Dragon Slippers (other topics)
Forest Born (other topics)