Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Who will live? Who will die?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Jul 15, 2007 06:49AM
Everyone dies and I don't have to hear about it anymore.
reply
|
flag









hedwig dies, and mad-eye, dobby dies, fred dies,tonk dies, lupin dies. alot of ppl die. its so sad. oh and bellatrix dies but we don't feel sorry for her cause she's a meany.
*spoiler* duh!
All through these books these people die:
James potter
Lily potter
Quirrell
Cedric diggory
Sirius Black
Dumbledore
Charity Burbage
Alastor moody (Mad eye moody)
Hedwig
Scrimegour
Bathilda bagshot
Remus Lupin
Tonks
Tonks dad, Ted
Peter pettigrew
Bellatrix lestrange
Fred weasley
Crabbe
Colin creevey
Voldemort and kind of Harry but he came back.
All through these books these people die:
James potter
Lily potter
Quirrell
Cedric diggory
Sirius Black
Dumbledore
Charity Burbage
Alastor moody (Mad eye moody)
Hedwig
Scrimegour
Bathilda bagshot
Remus Lupin
Tonks
Tonks dad, Ted
Peter pettigrew
Bellatrix lestrange
Fred weasley
Crabbe
Colin creevey
Voldemort and kind of Harry but he came back.

You forgot Dobby on your list Meghan(Meg).


Gasp! Nobody likes Snape! He's my favorite character. And I do feel bad for him. Snape's memories is my favorite chapter in Deathly Hallows. Don't you feel a little bit sorry for the boy coming from a broken home whom everybody made fun of and he spent his life in love with someone who didn't love him back? And that he sacrificed his life to protect Harry even if he hated him? It makes me sad all over just typing that.
To answer your question about Harry dying and not dying: Lily protected Harry as a baby with her sacrifice of love. Love was the magic that cast a shield on him. In Order of the Phoenix Dumbledore comments that love is the most powerful magic and the reason why its door is always locked in the department of mysteries. Love is the power from the prophecy Harry has that Voldemort knows not both times he hits Harry with avada kedavra undefended. First Lily protects him and then Harry protects himself. Just like Lily, because he willingly sacrificed himself the magic of love shielded him (but not the horcrux). And since Voldemort took Harry's blood, the original shield Lily placed on him still lives and gives him added protection. So he doesn't die (well the horcrux part of him does); love protects him. The spell knocked him unconscious though (getting rid of a horcrux is going to knock you out) and in that in-between state, he could have still ended it if he gave up and chose to die, but it would have been his choice. The love shield also protected all the people he sacrificed for and part of the reason Voldemort's curses wouldn't work (that and the elder wand not working for him).

I can't see why you like Snape,Annalis, he's a butt head. I kind of understand the way Harry Potter dies, thanks.


all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic